Creeper
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 15,607
- Reaction score
- 19,779
Who is kidding whom? The story of evil bad guys taking land from the peaceful innocent seemingly weaker people has been told a million times. We had Cowboys and Indians movies, cattle ranchers taking land from sheep herders, even cave men fighting each other over territory. Even the love story angle in the first movie has been done a million times. Romeo and Juliet anyone? The Avatar story wasn't new, other than the scenery and special effects. Both movies were about the visual splendor. The problem with the second movie is it was too long. Too much time was spent on the spectacular sea life. And honestly, the introduction of young ones into the story almost always kills a movie.Was watching something on Youtube about year or so prior to them releasing Avatar 2
He said when they brought the writing group together that many of the writers were brain storming about ideas of things they could do like new animals or fighting scenes and so on.
He said he stopped them and told them that they were first going to break down what made the first movie/story so successful. When the writers started talking about things they could do in the second story again he basically told them until they break down what made the first one a hit they would not be talking about what they could do in the second and if they continued to do so the would basically be fired.
The essence of his story was that he wanted to capture the magic of the story from the first one and not just look to what new scenes and animals they could come up with. To concentrate on the core story and not the bells and whistles.
That might be a good idea. However I think in doing so he just made the same movie just a different setting.
Evil bad guys come to take out your land, we must protect it. They just changed the land.
Plus, it is an overly cynical view of humans vs aliens. We are a species that worry more about a snail dart than our own planet, why would we be okay will killing off an intelligent alien species on another planet? I'd like to believe we are better than that. In fact, the reality is, the writers know the audience will side with the aliens. They know you will root for the aliens only proving we are not as evil as they make the bad guys seem, even for whatever natural resources they want to rob.