G2
Taco Engineer
- Messages
- 24,928
- Reaction score
- 26,517
I'm not taking anything away from Romo. In fact, I wasn't really bashing Romo and defending Prescott with the idea/excuses. All I'm saying is our defense wasn't very good. And it wasn't just the GB playoff game, it was all season. The offense (I'm and NOT saying it was all Dak - at all!) was the money maker in 2016. The O line was fantastic, Elliott was outstanding, the WR's/TE's were pretty good and Prescott was good enough.AGain, I would respectfully disagree. Not at all saying our defense played well that day, they had their struggles. But it isn't the first time Aaron Rodgers carved up a defense. That said I agree the defense bore a good deal of responsibility
Whenever you mention Romo's league leading # of 4th quarter comebacks during his period as starter, the inevitable return criticism of Romo opponents is "if he hadn't played so terribly early, he wouldn't have had to lead the comeback". We've all heard it.
if we're going to be consistent, same applies here. For most of the first half Dak was awful and that continued into our 1st possession of the 3rd quarter with that pick. And you know what, those things happen. QB's are human. He had a bad stretch, then got it going but it was just too late to overcome.
I think one could make a real strong argument that we don't fall behind 21-3 in that game if Romo was the starter. AGain--the best we can do is guess, because the reality is what it is and the reality is, the Cowboys--as a team--lost that game that day. GB earned it.
I agree AR is fantastic, but Prescott still had a very good game for a rookie in his first post season game. That's all.
Here's another thing, I actually don't think Prescott was THAT great in 2016 and THAT horrible in 2017. Statistically, they're pretty much the same. Same TDs passing and rushing, more attempts, INTs and lower comp % in 2017 - obviously but the yards were 20 a game lower in 2017. The difference was the guys around him. Same with this season.
My point in all of this is what's so bad about having a well balanced offense to allow your QB to do what he's good at? Fans need to understand Prescott isn't Romo or Aikman etc....
We may never find a QB like Roger or Troy, so take what we have and make the components stronger. If something comes along, sweet!
I was a huge Romo fan, but it's getting old. He retired. And the same excuses he is given should be afforded to Prescott.
The 2016 GB game wasn't as bad as you make it out to be in my opinion. He got them in position to score and there were some drops. His stats reflect a solid game.
3 TDs, over 300 yards and a 103 rating is plenty good enough. Hell, ONE defensive stop and we don't lose by 3.