Which leads to the biggest issue. McCarthy was brought in to get this team over the hump, and despite having the opportunity to do so, he’s failed. While this study was just done on regular-season games, when we take a deeper dive into the playoffs, it paints an even bleaker picture.
In the Cowboys 2023 playoff game against the
Green Bay Packers, the Cowboys were dealt a 48-32 loss, at home, against a team most thought was the underdog coming into AT&T Stadium. In 2022, the Cowboys seemed to have turned the corner, beating the
Tampa Bay Buccaneers on the road in the Wild Card round, before losing on the road to the
San Francisco 49ers 19-12. In 2021, the Cowboys were again embarrassed at home by the 49ers in a 23-17 loss in the Wild Card round.
The Cowboys hired Mike McCarthy to do what former head coach Jason Garrett could not. Get them to and through the playoffs. After falling flat on that responsibility for five years, it leads a lot of fans questioning why McCarthy would return to the Cowboys on a new contract after following the path Garrett did for over a decade. While the lack of ideal candidates in this head coaching cycle is a real thing, McCarthy has shown for five years what he can do against the top half of league and in the playoffs and it has not been good enough. In fact, in their best years against those teams, with a positive point differential, McCarthy was not calling plays and was not the team’s offensive coordinator.
https://www.bloggingtheboys.com/202...teele-tyler-guyton-dak-prescott-mike-mccarthy
McCarthy hasn't earned earned retention and for the exact reason he was hired to replace Garrett.
He hasn't earned the privilege. Earning it always matters.
This is still the unchanged reason demanding an altered accountability standard: For a team that has fallen flat in the playoffs for almost two decades now, a lot of fans hope for change, but not blindly as to directions missed.