Sean Payton with the dumb coaching **merged**

[Titleist]

Not really., Dak sucks and he was right.. the Cowboys just got bailed out by the refs on that throw..

That was blatant pass interference on Coop

 

[khiladi]

That was blatant pass interference on Coop

Not really... both guys were using their hands... just a normal battle that goes on all the time...

 

[Zekeats]

I don't know. He probably would have caught the ball, if he could've raised his other arm up to it.

I believe that too but I really don't like the play call. I will say this it was a one option throw and it was to the guy you gave up a number 1 for so I am happy about that but I still am not a fan of the call.

 

[Blast From The Past]

It also needs to be said that showing balls and taking the shot ultimately won the game. Did anyone want to see Brees with the ball back down 6 with over a minute left?

not me

 

[Lodeus]

That was Jason Garrett. It was Freaky Thursday.

 

[DFWJC]

And I don’t mean garret. What a dumb decision by Payton to call a time out with 2.03 on the clock. That jus gave us license to pass the ball.

Is anyone going to criticize the wonder boy coach?

Nice to see the shoe on the other foot for a change.

His early challenge cost them too, because Beasely was clearly short on tbat 4th qtr 3rddown conversion.
He also passed on taking the 3 points early...though I get that to some degree

Real nice

 

[NumOneQB]

Peyton was atrocious the 1st half. Every now and then you get a gimme game. This was his. Saints will be back on track next week. Garrett-top’s biggest goof was keeping Gregory in the game.

 

[Taggy12]

He blew a challenge that led to not challenging knee by 11. He did a lot of dumbness

and that questionable catch by cooper thats could go either way in 2nd quarter

 

[droopdog7]

and that questionable catch by cooper thats could go either way in 2nd quarter

I thought the cooper play was a catch all day. Easy call actually.

 

[SackMaster]

I don't say this often, but Garrett was the smarter game time head coach tonight.

As someone who is far from a Garrett supporter, I got to give him credit for not doing anything monumentally stupid like the 3 mistakes Payton made.

The first challenge was iffy, at best.
The second challenge was stupid so early in the game with losing the first challenge.
The last time out BEFORE the 2 minute warning for a measly 3 seconds?

Let me put it this way, if Garrett did those, I might have started a Fire Garrett thread for as bad as those 3 were.

 

[Dre11]

Hater? Just stating the obvious. We have major game management problems and this was one of them bailed out by a tricky tack PI call.

Lol...clear PI, and Payton was stupid. Admit it...lol

 

[Dre11]

Not really... both guys were using their hands... just a normal battle that goes on all the time...

Lol....you are ridiculously stupid....lol

 

[Zekeats]

Lol...clear PI, and Payton was stupid. Admit it...lol

If there is a holding call on Collins and we are 2nd and 20 from the 23 is the pass play a good call still?

 

[Vomit]

And I don’t mean garret. What a dumb decision by Payton to call a time out with 2.03 on the clock. That jus gave us license to pass the ball.

Is anyone going to criticize the wonder boy coach?

I was glad to see it. Maybe being in the same proximity as Garrett influenced him?

 

[Dre11]

If there is a holding call on Collins and we are 2nd and 20 from the 23 is the pass play a good call still?

Was there? Ifs and sh*** are for fools.

 

[Zekeats]

Was there? Ifs and sh*** are for fools.

Still not a good call and not a thread worth creating. To magnify a meaningless call by a coach who won a Super Bowl when we have a guy who has literally found every possible way to lose a game is just plane stupid.

 

[Dre11]

Still not a good call and not a thread worth creating. To magnify a meaningless call by a coach who won a Super Bowl when we have a guy who has literally found every possible way to lose a game is just plane stupid.

He lost the game....what a coach...ll

 

[Zekeats]

He lost the game....what a coach...ll

He lost the game? That loss is on Sean Payton? Did you watch any of the game? Our Defense WON the game. They didn't lose because he called a timeout before the two minute warning.

 

[JJHLH1]

Payton made several boneheaded decision. Going for it on 4th down early in the game against our defense instead of taking a gimme FG? Wasted his challenges early for no huge reason. Just dumb.

 

[Dre11]

He lost the game? That loss is on Sean Payton? Did you watch any of the game? Our Defense WON the game. They didn't lose because he called a timeout before the two minute warning.

No he made the dumb challenge that left him with none to challenge Beasley 1st down, left 3 on the 4th down call, and the timeout. Yeah it's on him,