So we're just supposed to forget the whole Mingo for a 4th rounder?

KJJ said:
He wasn’t worth a 4th round pick. In 8 games all he had was 5 catches for 46 yards. We saw why Carolina got rid of him.
Click to expand...
We saw a bad qb that couldn't throw him the ball and we saw a big physical receiver that blocks well and can catch the ball.
 
KJJ said:
He was he worth a 4th round pick?
Click to expand...
Sure he is when you look at what players were available. You might have your 3rd receiver for pick 114 and he is on a rookie deal. Look at his production in the SEC when Dart was his qb.
 
Zekeats said:
I mean we all did a double blink last year when that trade was announced. It’s comical at this point. Can someone please post the Bevis and Butthead pic.
Click to expand...
No, you’re supposed to obsess over it for the rest of your life until you are reduced to a Gollum-like state, choking out the words “4th round! 4th round!”
 
rambo2 said:
Sure he is when you look at what players were available. You might have your 3rd receiver for pick 114 and he is on a rookie deal. Look at his production in the SEC when Dart was his qb.
Click to expand...
His production in college doesn’t matter. He regressed in Carolina and they moved on. We traded for him in hopes he could be our WR2. I would have been okay with the trade for a 6th or 7th but we overpaid.
 
rambo2 said:
Sure he is when you look at what players were available. You might have your 3rd receiver for pick 114 and he is on a rookie deal. Look at his production in the SEC when Dart was his qb.
Click to expand...
I mean if you think trading a 4th round pick for the Panthers backup WR (he had been beaten out of the starting lineup by a practice squad player) is a good trade then I am sure there are no shortage of teams who would gladly part ways with their failed backups for a 4th.
 
Adreme said:
I mean if you think trading a 4th round pick for the Panthers backup WR (he had been beaten out of the starting lineup by a practice squad player) is a good trade then I am sure there are no shortage of teams who would gladly part ways with their failed backups for a 4th.
Click to expand...
I think that there is nothing wrong with trading for Mingo. We will see what happens, these receivers will be in a battle to get on the field.
 
kskboys said:
So since we suck at drafting in the 4th round anyway, might as well throw away the pick?
Click to expand...
I don't think it was a bad trade because I don't value a 4th round pick worth 66 points.

The only value a 4th round pick has is to move up in the 3rd or 2nd round. Since Dallas never does that, might as well take a shot with Mingo.

I just don't put as much value on that pick compared to others.
 
KJJ said:
His production in college doesn’t matter. He regressed in Carolina and they moved on. We traded for him in hopes he could be our WR2. I would have been okay with the trade for a 6th or 7th but we overpaid.
Click to expand...
the only thing I can say about Mingo in the NFL is that he's not really had a legit go of things with a legit QB throwing to him.

2023: CAR: Young struggled his rookie year.
2024: CAR: Young didn't do much better
2024: DAL: 8 games in a new system with a backup QB.

I'm honestly curious what he can put together with a full off-season and TC with Dak

Upside: solid WR3
Downside: wasted 4th round pick
 
rambo2 said:
I think that there is nothing wrong with trading for Mingo. We will see what happens, these receivers will be in a battle to get on the field.
Click to expand...
He is going to be a 3 way battle for the number 4 WR spot. His best case this year is the number 4 WR. By the way a 31% catch percentage is abhorrent no matter who is throwing you the football. I would expect practice squad WRs to catch more than 40% of balls thrown their way. At least with Pickens being on the lower end you can say its because he is a big play guy so being under 60% is, almost, explainable. Mingo does not have that excuse as he averaged under 10 yards a catch with basically no ability to catch.
 
atlantacowboy said:
Pickens is the kind of rental you make when the team on the precipice of competing and need that one more piece. This team isn't close to competing bc of the defense. I just get tired of watching the Jones morons make the same errors over and over. They don't learn from mistakes. So, now we have our Irvin, Harper, and Aikman. Maybe one for these RBs becomes Emmitt Smith and we can then relive the 90's. Oh wait..... the defense.
Click to expand...
I agree, but in a watered down league, anything can happen if you can compete. I still have the terrible taste in my mouth after being fed lies last year time and time again about being all in. Think about it, they purposely let a hc,most of the staff, the fans, the team, suffer due to the GB game and how we lost. The most selfish cringey thing Jerry has ever done while owning the team was what we witnessed in 2024. He now wants us to love him lol...he created the problem, rides in on his white horse, attempts to fix the problems HE CREATED, knowingly. This is why fans have serious doubts about anything we do. Good or bad. I understand it completely. I'm cautiously optimistic.
 
Did we see him with Dak? Holding on to the frustration of a sucky 4th round pick trade is one thing. But when they actually make a good trade after, I can let it go. In any relationship, it'll jus stress me out holding out to past mistakes especially if I'm not going anywhere. Does anyone remember the Roy Williams trade? And I'm still a fan sooooo
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

... and 109 more.
Total: 995 (members: 209, guests: 786)

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
465,391
Messages
13,871,795
Members
23,790
Latest member
MisterWaffles
Back
Top