Start, Bench, Cut – Aikman, Romo, Dak

[NotForLong]

1 - Aikman
2 - Romo
3 - Dak

However if this was a magical scenario where they’re in a new, 21 year old bod, I’d be curious to see what Romo would be like with modern day offensive coaches.

Very interesting . . . Imagine if Romo played 1 year with Andy Reid

 

[NotForLong]

Didn’t they win 13 games when Romo got hurt in 2016?

That was an amazing team once in a Lifetime Offensive Line . . . Losing Fred Beard really has took a tool on this team

In All honesty losing Fred Beard may have been more pivotal to Dak then we realize or remember to factor in.

And for the record Romo had healed and was medically cleared to play Football . . . Sadly The Mad Gambler from Arkansas was playing this game in 2016 and choose to . . .

Start: Dak
Bench: Romo

And the rest has been Cowboy disunity ever since

 

[NotForLong]

Yeah he also threw the ball a heck of a lot more.

Do you want to go on record and say Romo was a better leader, had as stronger arm, and was more accurate than Romo? I have a bridge to sell you if so

 

[CowboysRule]

Yeah he also threw the ball a heck of a lot more.

Do you want to go on record and say Romo was a better leader, had as stronger arm, and was more accurate than Romo? I have a bridge to sell you if so

He did throw a lot more, and threw less picks than Aikman.

I will not say he had a stronger arm because he didn't. Aikman had an absolute cannon. But you don't need an incredibly strong arm to succeed. Romo could make all the throws needed. Romo was either more or just as accurate as Troy. People tend to forget how accurate Romo was. Most of his picks weren't due to inaccuracy, it came down to poor decision making. Leadership, I don't know. I wasn't in the locker room. Do you think that if you put Romo on those 90's teams at QB we don't win Super Bowls?

 

[McKDaddy]

Doesn't matter which order the first two are. Like another poster said, the answer could change depending on the team assembled around them. There is only one you cut in every scenario.

 

[blueblood70]

Brady whooped on us first week of this year....Brady didn't have a terrible year. If he wanted to he could play again and still be a top 10 QB. Let's not exaggerate his demise.

he whopped a bad game plan 19 points is hardly an explosion.,. it was our pitiful Gameplan on offense that lost us that game.. anew OL, rookie LT, new LG , New rt, lost half our targets in the pass game, zeke running well and they abandon the run and went pass happy ..worst GP of Moore's career and he ended with 2nd worst ..that why he got fired. Hardly be able to debate Dak finally beats NE and TB12 when they basically were much weaker teams and older players.

 

[McKDaddy]

But on no planet was Romo more talented than Troy Aikman.

I'm not saying I agree from a pure talent standpoint but hasn't Troy said Tony was a better QB? I think Troy has a lot of respect for Romo's game.

 

[phildadon86]

He did throw a lot more, and threw less picks than Aikman.

I will not say he had a stronger arm because he didn't. Aikman had an absolute cannon. But you don't need an incredibly strong arm to succeed. Romo could make all the throws needed. Romo was either more or just as accurate as Troy. People tend to forget how accurate Romo was. Most of his picks weren't due to inaccuracy, it came down to poor decision making. Leadership, I don't know. I wasn't in the locker room. Do you think that if you put Romo on those 90's teams at QB we don't win Super Bowls?

I think if Romo tried going to Cabo during a playoff run Jimmy would have sat him.

Romo wasnt as accurate as Troy. I would have loved to see Romo behind that 90s OL though.

 

[McKDaddy]

Start: Dak (any era)
Bench: Staubach
Cut: Romo & Aikman (they threw 2 many interceptions)

sorry haters

Congratulations. You have identified yourself as being clueless.

 

[blueblood70]

He did throw a lot more, and threw less picks than Aikman.

I will not say he had a stronger arm because he didn't. Aikman had an absolute cannon. But you don't need an incredibly strong arm to succeed. Romo could make all the throws needed. Romo was either more or just as accurate as Troy. People tend to forget how accurate Romo was. Most of his picks weren't due to inaccuracy, it came down to poor decision making. Leadership, I don't know. I wasn't in the locker room. Do you think that if you put Romo on those 90's teams at QB we don't win Super Bowls?

yup and more mobile could do more off schedule stuff and didn't have the team Aikman had..Romo is severely underrated around here. blame the Qbs for not carrying a team with far less talent and weaker coaching staffs..right, blinded by Lombardis syndrome Trys got 3 must all be him but who me games where Aikman had to overcome a bad OL, no run game and shaky coaching in big games. never es22 that ol, moose and the pay calls made sure of it..

Team games and Troy wins the who had a clearly better team around him more consistently. same with Staubach.. they always call it more dak friendly or romo friendly what they really meant is they tried getting those qbs the same advantaged and talent TROY had his entire career. lol like the best run game , OL, and FB with MI and Novacek with better play callers and HOF HC.. Id call that Troy Friendly

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

As soon as Dak gets hurt . . . Fingers crossed

Sheesh

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

That was an amazing team once in a Lifetime Offensive Line . . . Losing Fred Beard really has took a tool on this team

In All honesty losing Fred Beard may have been more pivotal to Dak then we realize or remember to factor in.

And for the record Romo had healed and was medically cleared to play Football . . . Sadly The Mad Gambler from Arkansas was playing this game in 2016 and choose to . . .

Start: Dak
Bench: Romo

And the rest has been Cowboy disunity ever since

I’m just saying the narrative we couldn’t win without Romo…..is not entirely true. We couldn’t win with bad backups….soon as Dak got here that changed and I agree. This team overall hasn’t been the same since Fred has been gone

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

he whopped a bad game plan 19 points is hardly an explosion.,. it was our pitiful Gameplan on offense that lost us that game.. anew OL, rookie LT, new LG , New rt, lost half our targets in the pass game, zeke running well and they abandon the run and went pass happy ..worst GP of Moore's career and he ended with 2nd worst ..that why he got fired. Hardly be able to debate Dak finally beats NE and TB12 when they basically were much weaker teams and older players.

Buccs just won a SB with this same team lol

 

[NotForLong]

Sheesh

. . . The gloves are off . . . I just want a Super Bowl before the World Ends

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

. . . The gloves are off . . . I just want a Super Bowl before the World Ends

Dak gonna give you one just be patient lol.

 

[blueblood70]

Buccs just won a SB with this same team lol

same??! Arians and Gronk gone. many linemen out.. do you see clearly or trying to work hard to make a narrative fit a debate?

we can obviously see tb12 and that TB team wasn't even the same as their SB year and tb12 with NE is far different then beating NE with new rookie QB i believe Jones was new at the time. great game for fans on both game but saying somehow its an impressive pin to put in cap, hardly..like beating Jordan with the wizards or beating bulls without MJ lol. its not the same at all.

 

[NotForLong]

Dak gonna give you one just be patient lol.

Ok . . . I'll be here routing for Him if He figures it out

But I believe He is on a Short Leash in Big Mike's Farewell Tour . . . I believe this year the Status Quo has changed and Big Mike is going all in

 

[Cowboy_svt]

Congratulations. You have identified yourself as being clueless.

i identify as a true american cowboy patriot who supports whoever is the current qb and hates everyone prior to them

 

[starfan1]

. . . The gloves are off . . . I just want a Super Bowl before the World Ends

well given current state of affairs he better get a SB next year. Better brush of on your Rosetta stone for additional languages

 

[McKDaddy]

i identify as a true american cowboy patriot who supports whoever is the current qb and hates everyone prior to them

That's ridiculous. If you are going to look at the world that way, why even bother to respond to a post that requires you treat them all in their prime and available?