WDN;3954823 said:
Underlining doesn't make you anymore correct. The ball wasn't 15 feet in the outfield. Both Elvis body position and the ball were pretty much in the same position. I remember it because I thought it was an oustanding play.
Im not going to get in a 30 page argument with you. My opinion is that he could of made the same play he did last week and the ballgame is likely over.
I wasn't trying to underline to make me seem more right, I was underlining to emphasize a point yuo may not be considering - that regardless of whether the hit was exactly the same, and Elvis fielded the ball in exactly the same way in the same position on the field and in the same position to throw the ball, the game situation still may have dictated a different approach.
In other words, while we can't say exactly how close the play was to the play he made before, you can know the game situation, which can dictate treating a ball hit and fielded in a similar way differently.
I think that's the kind of thing a lot of fans don't recognize. If, for example, there are no runners on and it is the 4th innning, Elvis may make that throw even though he knows it is a risky throw that could end up getting past the 1st baseman. In that instance it is worth the risk because even if it plays out that way, the catcher is down the line backing up the throw, and even if it goes in the duggout the runner moves to 2nd base with no immediate harm and the team can still get the 3rd out without him scoring . And, of course, even if that runner scores, the game isn't over - there are 5 innings left to make it up. If, however, the consequence of making a throw that you deem risky is that you lose the game on that very play, as was the circumstance last night, the approach is different.
Besides, who knows, it may have been something as simple as Elvis not feeling his feet were in the right position or any number of small things that could have made Elvis less comfortable making that throw than on another play.
I don't question Elivis even the tiniest bit for that. It wasn't an easy play, he fielded the ball well into the grass behind 2nd base, the runner had a huge jump on him out of the batters box because the ball was hit slow, and Elvis would have had to throw against his momentum - if he didn't feel comfortable with the throw then he absolutely made the right choice.
BraveHeartFan;3954949 said:
I agree with that. I'm just not panicking or going crazy about it just yet.
There is no reason to. Being concerned is one thing. All of us should be concerned about the bullpen right now. If over time things don't improve or we never do anythnig to address the situation then we can go crazy about it.