The divide of the Dallas Cowboy's fandom

Trouty

Kellen Moore baby
Messages
31,526
Reaction score
80,467
In the recent past, certain players/personnel have drawn a predominant amount of disdain from our fanbase -- Jerry Jones, Jason Garrett (especially the last two years), Nick Hayden, JJ Wilcox, Carr (depending on the day), even Greg Hardy.

Then, there were the fringe guys that towed the line of love and hate, depending on the particular fan -- guys like TWill, McFadden, Mo, Doug Free.

Now it's spilled over to fan favorites, guys that have done all they can to help the organization, and were at one point or another almost universally loved, two players specifically -- Tony Romo and Dez Bryant.

While Romo has always had his detractors for various reasons, most fans knew this guy was our backbone and always presented us a chance to win. The sole reason why we were even remotely relevant, and a cover up of a mediocre coaching staff and front office. At the same time, Dez was the guy that was the conduit for Tony and the endzone. Our guy we could count on to grab that ball in traffic and bring it down for 6.

Now, after a series of injuries to both players, the fandom is out and very vocal in their disapproval for our two Big Name, fan favorite players.

It's almost sad to see these two guys go down this path. Is this what happens as players age, as they go through various injuries. Is this a byproduct of a team that has toiled in mediocrity for over two decades, spilling out now into our assessment of our very best.

Perhaps it's because we have two new rooks, with sky-high potential on offense in Zeke and Dak, and they are simply pushing the older stars out the door.

Injuries happen, and, especially in the case of Dez, we should excercise patience, yet we aren't. With Tony, it's a bit more problematic, as his growing amount of injuries make it hard to defend him against his now growing amount of detractors (yet, I still try).

I get it, it's sports -- and perhaps that very simplistic statement answers my own question. Yet, I want to reflect with a post, how sad it is to see things going down the way they are. Especially since I'm new to a large fanbase that can hear my rant.
 

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
In the recent past, certain players/personnel have drawn a predominant amount of disdain from our fanbase -- Jerry Jones, Jason Garrett (especially the last two years), Nick Hayden, JJ Wilcox, Carr (depending on the day), even Greg Hardy.

Then, there were the fringe guys that towed the line of love and hate, depending on the particular fan -- guys like TWill, McFadden, Mo, Doug Free.

Now it's spilled over to fan favorites, guys that have done all they can to help the organization, and were at one point or another almost universally loved, two players specifically -- Tony Romo and Dez Bryant.

While Romo has always had his detractors for various reasons, most fans knew this guy was our backbone and always presented us a chance to win. The sole reason why we were even remotely relevant, and a cover up of a mediocre coaching staff and front office. At the same time, Dez was the guy that was the conduit for Tony and the endzone. Our guy we could count on to grab that ball in traffic and bring it down for 6.

Now, after a series of injuries to both players, the fandom is out and very vocal in their disapproval for our two Big Name, fan favorite players.

It's almost sad to see these two guys go down this path. Is this what happens as players age, as they go through various injuries. Is this a byproduct of a team that has toiled in mediocrity for over two decades, spilling out now into our assessment of our very best.

Perhaps it's because we have two new rooks, with sky-high potential on offense in Zeke and Dak, and they are simply pushing the older stars out the door.

Injuries happen, and, especially in the case of Dez, we should excercise patience, yet we aren't. With Tony, it's a bit more problematic, as his growing amount of injuries make it hard to defend him against his now growing amount of detractors (yet, I still try).

I get it, it's sports -- and perhaps that very simplistic statement answers my own question. Yet, I want to reflect with a post, how sad it is to see things going down the way they are. Especially since I'm new to a large fanbase that can hear my rant.
Great post.......I am guilty of jumping on some of the marginal guys, but just because I want better players......I don't get the vile and disdain for our stars, guys like Dez and Romo that have laid it on the line, time and time again

I think some of it is just the times........we argue about everything and nothing is sacred......we argue on the news, over politics, over sports, even on TV shows like American Idol, Survivor or DWTS were we choose the winners......everyone picks sides and it is hate the other guy.....now it is blending into hating our own guys

Maybe it is too much information.....we didn't have Troy, Emmitt and Michael on Twitter or being followed by TMZ...we see all their flaws
 

BourbonBalz

Star4Ever
Messages
12,207
Reaction score
8,178
I don't care whether Tony or Dak is the QB as long as we win. Tony, IMO, gives us the best chance of doing that right now when he's healthy and I don't think it's even debatable. I'm looking forward to the future with Dak, but anyone that thinks Tony isn't better this year and maybe even next year just doesn't have a clue. Regardless, this issue does not cause a split in anything as far as I'm concerned.
 

boysfanindc

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,226
Reaction score
2,863
In the recent past, certain players/personnel have drawn a predominant amount of disdain from our fanbase -- Jerry Jones, Jason Garrett (especially the last two years), Nick Hayden, JJ Wilcox, Carr (depending on the day), even Greg Hardy.

Then, there were the fringe guys that towed the line of love and hate, depending on the particular fan -- guys like TWill, McFadden, Mo, Doug Free.

Now it's spilled over to fan favorites, guys that have done all they can to help the organization, and were at one point or another almost universally loved, two players specifically -- Tony Romo and Dez Bryant.

While Romo has always had his detractors for various reasons, most fans knew this guy was our backbone and always presented us a chance to win. The sole reason why we were even remotely relevant, and a cover up of a mediocre coaching staff and front office. At the same time, Dez was the guy that was the conduit for Tony and the endzone. Our guy we could count on to grab that ball in traffic and bring it down for 6.

Now, after a series of injuries to both players, the fandom is out and very vocal in their disapproval for our two Big Name, fan favorite players.

It's almost sad to see these two guys go down this path. Is this what happens as players age, as they go through various injuries. Is this a byproduct of a team that has toiled in mediocrity for over two decades, spilling out now into our assessment of our very best.

Perhaps it's because we have two new rooks, with sky-high potential on offense in Zeke and Dak, and they are simply pushing the older stars out the door.

Injuries happen, and, especially in the case of Dez, we should excercise patience, yet we aren't. With Tony, it's a bit more problematic, as his growing amount of injuries make it hard to defend him against his now growing amount of detractors (yet, I still try).

I get it, it's sports -- and perhaps that very simplistic statement answers my own question. Yet, I want to reflect with a post, how sad it is to see things going down the way they are. Especially since I'm new to a large fanbase that can hear my rant.

For my own perspective:

I love Romo always will, not only been a great football player but also a leader and a great guy.

I love Dez and root for him, but I don like his behavior when he does things that I believe hurt the team. There is a difference.

My kids do things I don't like and they should not do, it does not mean I do not love them anymore it means I am disappointed in their behavior.

I discipline them for poor behavior, not because I do not like them but because I care about them and want to seem them do better.

This sometimes is a black and white world in a lot of peoples minds, something is either good or it is bad there is no gray.
 

Trouty

Kellen Moore baby
Messages
31,526
Reaction score
80,467
Great post.......I am guilty of jumping on some of the marginal guys, but just because I want better players......I don't get the vile and disdain for our stars, guys like Dez and Romo that have laid it on the line, time and time again

I think some of it is just the times........we argue about everything and nothing is sacred......we argue on the news, over politics, over sports, even on TV shows like American Idol, Survivor or DWTS were we choose the winners......everyone picks sides and it is hate the other guy.....now it is blending into hating our own guys

Maybe it is too much information.....we didn't have Troy, Emmitt and Michael on Twitter or being followed by TMZ...we see all their flaws

The age of information, driven by millennials (I am one, but don't act as such, at least I feel I don't) greatly amplifies everything you noted, Bkight.

In my opinion, I think the futility of the franchise draws the largest amount of angst from our fandom, and bleeds itself down to our players.

My LA Kings had a very angry fanbase for years and years. Ever since I started following them in '96, every year was a giant bash fest, and rightfully so. They were pathetic. They drafted pathetic, and outside of 2 or 3 oh-so-close years, were woefully bad.

Then we got Dean Lombardi (our GM), and he changed the whole foundation of the organization, and with that, fans drank ALL the kool aid, on the way to two championships in three years (having gone 45 years without one, beforehand).

The futility of our franchise is seriously hemorrhaging into our fanbase, at least partially causing this devide, me thinks. And I can't fault it. But damn, it's disheartening to see, as we all adore our team.
 
Last edited:

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
The age of information, driven by millennials (I am one, but don't act as such, at least I feel I don't) greatly amplifies everything you noted, Bkight.

In my opinion, I think the futility of the franchise draws the largest amount of angst from our fandom, and bleeds itself down to our players.

My LA Kings had a very angry fanbase for years and years. Ever since I started following them in '96, every year was a giant bash fest, and rightfully so. They were pathetic. They drafted pathetic, and outside of 2 or 3 oh-so-close years, were woefully bad.

Then we got Dean Lombardi (our GM), and he changed the whole foundation of the organization, and with that, fans drank ALL the kool aid, on the way to two championships in three years (having gone 45 years without one, beforehand).

The futility of our franchise is seriously hemorrhaging into our fanbase, at least partially causing this device, me thinks. And I can't fault it. But damn, it's disheartening to see, as we all adore our team.
Yeah I forgot about that.....winning cures all ills.....fans my age-45 always harken back to the old days because that is when we made the playoffs every year and won 5 SBs

How did you pick Dallas from LA in the late 90s?
 

Trouty

Kellen Moore baby
Messages
31,526
Reaction score
80,467
Yeah I forgot about that.....winning cures all ills.....fans my age-45 always harken back to the old days because that is when we made the playoffs every year and won 5 SBs

How did you pick Dallas from LA in the late 90s?

I'm a resident of Los Angeles. At the time when I started following the Kings, the Stars were one of our biggest rivals, and always whooped us (Modano and Hatcher, in particular) :(
 

haleyrules

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,060
Reaction score
42,877
The age of information, driven by millennials (I am one, but don't act as such, at least I feel I don't) greatly amplifies everything you noted, Bkight.

In my opinion, I think the futility of the franchise draws the largest amount of angst from our fandom, and bleeds itself down to our players.

My LA Kings had a very angry fanbase for years and years. Ever since I started following them in '96, every year was a giant bash fest, and rightfully so. They were pathetic. They drafted pathetic, and outside of 2 or 3 oh-so-close years, were woefully bad.

Then we got Dean Lombardi (our GM), and he changed the whole foundation of the organization, and with that, fans drank ALL the kool aid, on the way to two championships in three years (having gone 45 years without one, beforehand).

The futility of our franchise is seriously hemorrhaging into our fanbase, at least partially causing this devide, me thinks. And I can't fault it. But damn, it's disheartening to see, as we all adore our team.
Nice post and very accurate. The last time l recall the Kings...the Canadiens spanked them for the Stanley Cup...with Gretsky and crew!! Fond memories of L.A.;)?!!
 

Cowboy4ever

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,189
Reaction score
4,494
This is the same fan base that boo'd Troy at the end of his career. It is a "what have you done for me lately" fan base. Not saying it is right or wrong but it is the way it seems.
 

haleyrules

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,060
Reaction score
42,877
Ah, the finals that McSorley's stick killed us!
McSorley...grew up very close to where l grew up. I know many people who know him. Not me. Anyway, that was very political. It was a very Canadian piece of business. Sports are not clean. L.A was "Destined" to lose that series. Gretsky and crew did their job by getting them there. The rest was history and corruption. I had an old boxer friend who always told me...in 'boxing' don't believe what you see. As l grow older...l think it applies to all big money endeavours!!:(!
 

THEHEREAFTER

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,862
Reaction score
6,301
Good post but I think what's going on with Dez is different. I think it's mostly maturity/accountability with Dez along with frustration over injury. I think it's a little more complex with Romo due to the fact that he has direct competition at his position amongst other issues.
 
Top