That would have been fine.
My main points were
a) we over paid for a RB
b) he hasn’t “won” us any games yet that I believe multiple other combinations of RB’s couldn’t have won as well
c) he already appears to be declining despite the hordes of fan boys that told me he was so special and worth it because he was so durable and great at getting those “dirty yards” (ironically now a lot of those same people are complaining he can’t get to the outside, lost his speed, doesn’t break tackles, doesn’t make people miss, etc which a lot of us pointed put before the contract...too late now!)
d) it’s been proven time and time again you don’t need an elite RB to win games, not that he is elite anymore, if he ever was