Tony Romo HOF

[sportsman]

In your opinion will Tony be a 1st ballot HOF after his career is over

 

[Future]

If he wins a Super Bowl he absolutely should be.

Otherwise, he probably won't get in.

 

[TwoDeep3]

In your opinion will Tony be a 1st ballot HOF after his career is over

If today was all there is, no.

 

[Wayne02]

He'll need at least two Super Bowls to get in.

 

[AKATheRake]

He'll need at least two Super Bowls to get in.

^^ This

 

[dstovall5]

He'll need at least two Super Bowls to get in.

Why? If he won two super bowls he'd easily be considered a top 10 QB, of all time. He'd be near Brady or Manning.

 

[Wayne02]

Why? If he won two super bowls he'd easily be considered a top 10 QB, of all time. He'd be near Brady or Manning.

He has 1 playoff win on his resume and has been labeled a choker, whether it's fair or not, that's how he's perceived by many.

 

[tyke1doe]

If he wins a Super Bowl he absolutely should be.

Otherwise, he probably won't get in.

True. He has everything but the ring.
Yeah, yeah, it aint fair. But it is what it is. He gets a ring, and he's first ballot, IMO, unless he drives the bus like Trent Dilfer and Roethlisberger did in his first Super Bowl.

 

[bark]

He'll need at least two Super Bowls to get in.

Fact

 

[5Stars]

He has 1 playoff win on his resume and has been labeled a choker, whether it's fair or not, that's how he's perceived by many.

As much as the media, (and some cowboy fan alike) hate Romo, he could win 7 SB's and never get considered for the HOF! lol

 

[slick325]

Not without a ring...

 

[casmith07]

In your opinion will Tony be a 1st ballot HOF after his career is over

If the Cowboys win a Super Bowl with him as QB, yes. If not, then no. He'll get in, just won't be 1st ballot.

 

[Wayne02]

As much as the media, (and some cowboy fan alike) hate Romo, he could win 7 SB's and never get considered for the HOF! lol

Honestly 1 may get him in but 2 would cement it.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

He needs a ring. He has the stats to back it up. Needing two rings is insane and that's a bar that's far too high.

 

[Lodeus]

One SB should do it I think. From an undrafted nobody to a SB winner much like Warner should get you in I think.

 

[Ultra Warrior]

Honestly 1 may get him in but 2 would cement it.

Plunkett has 2 & hasn't gotten a sniff at the HOF.

 

[Kevinicus]

Plunkett has 2 & hasn't gotten a sniff at the HOF.

Eli has 2 and has no business even visiting.

 

[Wheeltax]

I think he'll get there, but not first ballot.

Not that I consider the HoF to have any credibility until Drew Pearson is there.

 

[DFWJC]

In your opinion will Tony be a 1st ballot HOF after his career is over

Can't see that happening.

But if he and team eventually has some playoff success, I do see him making the HOF.
He might even make it regardless.

 

[ajk23az]

Plunkett has 2 & hasn't gotten a sniff at the HOF.

He also has about 30 more INTs than TDs and a 67.5 career rating.

Romo already has 60+ more Tds and 30+ higher rating.

Romo needs just one to get in.