Ultimately playoff success will determine how Dak’s career will be perceived

[CowboysFaninHouston]

I have NEVER seen Papy or Khiladi say they want to Cowboys to lose.

There's a difference in criticizing the QB and rooting for the team to lose.

If you can show proof of them saying they hope the Cowboys lose then it's a different story, but you and I both know you can't because nobody says that. It's hyperbole from Dak over Dallas fans.

You're siding with someone that disparages Aikman to prop up Dak. I hope you know that.

has Khiladi ever said anything positive about any single play about Dak? one time! a single time? show me one post.

in fact Khiladi celebrated Dak's injury two years ago, and jumped on Dalton band wagon claiming that the cowboys are about to soar..

we know all too well about poopydog. lets not even go there.

there is a difference between criticizing a QB incessantly and nit picking every single play and never ever giving any credit whatso ever to any play he may have made....there is a difference criticizing a bad play compared to every single play.....khiladi even went out of his way on the 30 yard completion, not giving an inch of credit to Dak pulling off the play and instead said it was because eagles defense failed and the mistake was what allowed him to make the play, and Dak gets zero credit!!!

I am not siding with anybody, its you who is trying to spin that as you always try to do (and fail)....you know where I stand on Aikman, I have even said in the past, I take Aikman over Dak in a heartbeat if there was an option to replace one player on the team...so don't even go there...don't even try.Aikman is a HOF QB, deservedly so. one of the best QBs cowboys ever had. but knowing who you are...I am not one bit surprised in your lack of integrity and accusations you try to make....because that's who you are. its what you are. you just can't help yourself.

 

[rambo2]

Week to week roller coaster of the nfl and fans reactions towards Dak are more up and down than the stock market, but regardless of how Dak plays like this past week, or the week before and his ints and his flashes of greatness and then his mistakes, you can’t judge Dak until he has playoff success, that’s what separates a good qb from a great qb, so we’ve seen what he is capable of, but without playoff success he will never be viewed as a great qb regardless of his numbers and regular season record

Dak has a chance at having a big time career. Just imagine if they win it all this year and what could be in front of him. I would absolutely love it if that happens.

 

[Cmac]

.....then he is similar to TRomo then. Fair.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Dude if he didn’t get hurt you would look dumb. You already do for making that bet not actually knowing if he would play all year. It’s going to funny if it happens. It probably won’t though so whatever you want me to put in my signature I will. Just find it funny you’re holding me to a bet when the guy missed 2 games. This whole board knows it. I’m a man of my word though. So here we are

Well, seeing as how I made that bet with you and pointed out the reasons being Pollard getting more action and Zeke's health shows that I knew how things would go. He's got a lot of wear and tear. I'd be shocked if he played a full season at this point.

I wouldn't bet on someone that plays a demanding position and has a lot of wear and tear on his body.

I'm not going to make you put anything in your signature. I'll take the bragging rights instead.

So, whenever you call me "football stupid" it makes you look bad also lol

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

has Khiladi ever said anything positive about any single play about Dak? one time! a single time? show me one post.

in fact Khiladi celebrated Dak's injury two years ago, and jumped on Dalton band wagon claiming that the cowboys are about to soar..

we know all too well about poopydog. lets not even go there.

there is a difference between criticizing a QB incessantly and nit picking every single play and never ever giving any credit whatso ever to any play he may have made....there is a difference criticizing a bad play compared to every single play.....khiladi even went out of his way on the 30 yard completion, not giving an inch of credit to Dak pulling off the play and instead said it was because eagles defense failed and the mistake was what allowed him to make the play, and Dak gets zero credit!!!

I am not siding with anybody, its you who is trying to spin that as you always try to do (and fail)....you know where I stand on Aikman, I have even said in the past, I take Aikman over Dak in a heartbeat if there was an option to replace one player on the team...so don't even go there...don't even try.Aikman is a HOF QB, deservedly so. one of the best QBs cowboys ever had. but knowing who you are...I am not one bit surprised in your lack of integrity and accusations you try to make....because that's who you are. its what you are. you just can't help yourself.

Again, like most Dak over Dallas fans you're confusing criticism for the QB as hoping the team loses.

I asked you to provide some proof of them rooting for us to lose and crickets.

I don't see you defending Aikman slander when it comes to defending Dak. You just pass that right up... I wonder why?

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Again, like most Dak over Dallas fans you're confusing criticism for the QB as hoping the team loses.

I asked you to provide some proof of them rooting for us to lose and crickets.

I don't see you defending Aikman slander when it comes to defending Dak. You just pass that right up... I wonder why?

again, spinning and pointing fingers. you are a dallas lose over dak success fan.... proven yourself to be as much.

criticism of bad play is fine. show me I have said otherwise.... criticism of every single play is wrong. which is what you and your buddies do often.

I provided you plenty of proof....Khiladi won't deny it, given you are close pals, just ask him and he will tell you..
so show me a single post of any dak supporter that says, they rather see dak succeed and dallas lose? that's the inference you made. right?

not sure what to make of your last statement. totally irrelevant.... you seem to have been riled up by one of the posters, looking for something in your ever dak bashing attempt. My opinion of Aikman is known, I have said as much. I don't need to defend Aikman. he doesn't need defending. its an insult to even try and if any poster thinks otherwise, then that's their opinion.

but you showed your mentality once again. its either bash Dak 100% of the time or else you are a Dak supporter and supposedly now an Aikman hater!!!

like I said, I never expect anything else from y ou...its who you are. its what you are. you just can't help yourself.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

again, spinning and pointing fingers. you are a dallas lose over dak success fan.... proven yourself to be as much.

criticism of bad play is fine. show me I have said otherwise.... criticism of every single play is wrong. which is what you and your buddies do often.

I provided you plenty of proof....Khiladi won't deny it, given you are close pals, just ask him and he will tell you..
so show me a single post of any dak supporter that says, they rather see dak succeed and dallas lose? that's the inference you made. right?

not sure what to make of your last statement. totally irrelevant.... you seem to have been riled up by one of the posters, looking for something in your ever dak bashing attempt. My opinion of Aikman is known, I have said as much. I don't need to defend Aikman. he doesn't need defending. its an insult to even try and if any poster thinks otherwise, then that's their opinion.

but you showed your mentality once again. its either bash Dak 100% of the time or else you are a Dak supporter and supposedly now an Aikman hater!!!

like I said, I never expect anything else from y ou...its who you are. its what you are. you just can't help yourself.

Me and my buddies? lol

You and your buddies dog Aikman to defend Dak.

See, I can lump you in also.

 

[phildadon86]

Well, seeing as how I made that bet with you and pointed out the reasons being Pollard getting more action and Zeke's health shows that I knew how things would go. He's got a lot of wear and tear. I'd be shocked if he played a full season at this point.

I wouldn't bet on someone that plays a demanding position and has a lot of wear and tear on his body.

I'm not going to make you put anything in your signature. I'll take the bragging rights instead.

So, whenever you call me "football stupid" it makes you look bad also lol

Lol. You said Dak had a bad game against Philly. Let’s not talk about football smarts. Either way I’m not going to be very active in the coming weeks. Have some stuff going on with my mom.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Me and my buddies? lol

You and your buddies dog Aikman to defend Dak.

See, I can lump you in also.

where did I dog Aikman? but then again you are a well known member with a vivid imaginations that makes up stuff pretty often.

yeah, you and your buddies. if the shoe fits (which it does).

funny, you accused, yet failed to show one single post from anyone you are accusing of taking Dak over Dallas...now you are trying to spin away from another one of your bullshiet's


like I said, you are who you are. you can't help yourself. its just who you are...what you are....

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

where did I dog Aikman? but then again you are a well known member with a vivid imaginations that makes up stuff pretty often.

yeah, you and your buddies. if the shoe fits (which it does).

funny, you accused, yet failed to show one single post from anyone you are accusing of taking Dak over Dallas...now you are trying to spin away from another one of your bullshiet's


like I said, you are who you are. you can't help yourself. its just who you are...what you are....

You care way too much.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

You care way too much.

you get way too emotional about things that don't really matter.

 

[Jarv]

Oh yah and Dalton was going to take us to the promised land. LOL

Quoted by you...

QB's dont have success or failure, teams do.

Stafford has to be the best example of that truth.

And NO, playoff success is NOT what separates QB's. Its usually the team that he is surrounded by. But yes, the laymans and know nothings will blame one guy or the QB.

Dalton or Dak, it's the team and not the QB according to you one second.

Then...Quoted by you the next second..

"Oh yah and Dalton was going to take us to the promised land."

So which is it?

 

[BoysForLife]

Quoted by you...

QB's dont have success or failure, teams do.

Stafford has to be the best example of that truth.

And NO, playoff success is NOT what separates QB's. Its usually the team that he is surrounded by. But yes, the laymans and know nothings will blame one guy or the QB.

Dalton or Dak, it's the team and not the QB according to you one second.

Then...Quoted by you the next second..

"Oh yah and Dalton was going to take us to the promised land."

So which is it?

for Roy, it's whatever serves to prop up Dak.

that's not a snide statement. It's a statement of fact/truth. Whatever needs to be said to prop up Dak and "discredit" his "haters", that's what he'll say in that moment.
Nothing more complicated than that. As Mountaineer Cowboy has brilliantly shown above, for some folks, personally, there are certain players who are more important than the Cowboys as a whole

You have stumbled across an example of this.

 

[BoysForLife]

you get way too emotional about things that don't really matter.

You ever get this emotional arguing with someone who refuses to acknowledge that Dak has flaws or made a mistake?

Don't bother to answer, we both already know the answer anyways.....

 

[Doomsday101]

I like Dak but should we win a SB, in my book that would not all of a sudden make him an elite QB. Elite are guys who perform at top level year in and year out. I love having Dak and fully believe he is capable of helping this team to a SB. Winning a SB will define this team.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

You ever get this emotional arguing with someone who refuses to acknowledge that Dak has flaws or made a mistake?

Don't bother to answer, we both already know the answer anyways.....

show me one post where I said dak doesn't have flaws...

show me one of your posts where you praised anything dak has done?

yeah, we know what you are....

 

[BoysForLife]

show me one post where I said dak doesn't have flaws...

show me one of your posts where you praised anything dak has done?

yeah, we know what you are....

I never said you said Dak doesn't have any flaws.

I said you never call out any of the Davidians. you only call out the "haters".

and call yourself "down the middle"

 

[PA Cowboy Fan]

I judge Dak the same way I judged Romo. He must play like this in the playoffs.

 

[rambo2]

I judge Dak the same way I judged Romo. He must play like this in the playoffs.

He has a decent chance of doing that this year.

 

[PA Cowboy Fan]

He has a decent chance of doing that this year.

I hope he does.