Great job on the video. Unfortunately, people will always blame Roy. It's either because they really don't understand Coverage responsibilites and/or it's a controversial thing to say or write by NFL analysts, "experts", and writers. Controversy = ratings, Web site clicks, and newspaper buys.
One of the good things is that under Phillips we'll likely play a lot less Cover 2. Also, history has shown that if we stay reasonably healthy, the pass rush is likely to get better. But still, there's a problem with James.
Last season when I charted games, from *week one* against Jacksonville I noticed that the Jags were able to hit underneath passes to their running backs with pretty good success. It's tough to tell whose responsibility it is, but I was pretty sure it was James'. After that, other teams would occasionally have success, but mostly they concentrated on throwing the ball deep against Dallas instead of hitting the short passes. It wasn't until we faced the Saints that Sean Payton knew James' major weakness and exploited it as much as he could (only 6 passes in that game traveled more than 9 yards in the air). Then you had James getting exploited against Atlanta with Justin Griffith and others, the Eagles, and then the Lions got the idea of using Mike Furrey against James with great success (11 catches for over 100+ yards).
Jon Kitna said it best "#56 doesn't look like he knows what he's doing out there" and this video proves it. He either seems to do one of three things:
1. Not drop far back enough.
2. Get fooled into thinking the receiver is going short over the middle when they are going long.
3. Just getting burned from the beginning.
Perhaps Phillips can work his magic with James, but this is probably the most important problem to solve on defense or the second most important next to a pass rush. I actually think Carpenter can play ILB very well, if not be a dynamic player at the position. Hopefully Phillips won't be afraid to yank James despite his recent contract extension and will find an OLB in the draft.
YAKUZA