Vince Young or Tony Romo?

[Da Hammer]

Vince Young is a talent and he can play pretty good. But he's not near as accurate and he can't lead a team with his arm. He completed about 49% of his passes last year and is improved this year. But it's still in the 50% range.

okay sorry i missed this one. he's completing 62.7 % of his passes not in the 50% range! and he completed 51.5% last year not 49%. im not saying hes a great accurate passer yet but he's better than a LOT of people give him credit for. and he's improving which is the most important thing! but at least unlike other people u at least give him some credit which is so absurd when people just completely diss him for no good reason!

 

[NickZepp]

okay sorry i missed this one. he's completing 62.7 % of his passes not in the 50% range! and he completed 51.5% last year not 49%. im not saying hes a great accurate passer yet but he's better than a LOT of people give him credit for. and he's improving which is the most important thing! but at least unlike other people u at least give him some credit which is so absurd when people just completely diss him for no good reason!

And he's only passing it about 15-20 times a game. He's not as good as Romo. Not even close. If he's passing it as much as Romo is he's completed 45-50% of his passes.

 

[Da Hammer]

And he's only passing it about 15-20 times a game. He's not as good as Romo. Not even close. If he's passing it as much as Romo is he's completed 45-50% of his passes.

I'm not saying he's as good as Romo. if u read my 1st post in this thread yesterday you would see that i said i would take Romo for the next 2 years cause Romo is yea better right now. i said i would take Young in 3 years cause i think by that point he will be among the elite in the game. He will be almost unstoppable at that point in his career when he gets to be a lot more accurate and have better playmakers around him.

and yea he's only passing about 20 times a game because they really dont have the playmakers around him to sling it 35 times a game. they have a great running attack and so why would they pass it to unexperienced not very talented receivers when they can just run it down peoples throats very effectively and wear them out??? Also Fisher has always been known as a conservative guy that loves to run the football.although if Vince had T.O, Witten, and Crayton trust me they would be throwing a lot more than 20 times a game. and nobody would be doubting that Vince will be a great QB!

i just wish people wouldnt blast Young saying he will be a bust when he hasnt had good talent around him and yet he is clearly getting better every time he steps onto that field. and is WINNING which is the most important stat no one is mentioning!!!

 

[BHendri5]

ah how it irks me when people cant read and act like they can. when did i compare MJ's game to Vince Young's level of playing a game??? i would be an idiot if i say hes playing at a level that Jordan did! i said that Vince Young will to win and to get better is something that is at MJ's level which anybody that has ever followed his career would agree with me. i have no problem with people challenging what i say but next time challenge me about something that i actually said :bang2:

OH, I understood exactly what you said. YOu now are trying to twist what you said around, because I called you on it. Basically, any way you want to spew it, you are still trying to compare VY, to MJ, and he does not compare in any form or fashion.

 

[Da Hammer]

OH, I understood exactly what you said. YOu now are trying to twist what you said around, because I called you on it. Basically, any way you want to spew it, you are still trying to compare VY, to MJ, and he does not compare in any form or fashion.

:laugh2: Its kind of hard to twist something when i basically repeated what i said last time... :laugh2: I called u out for telling me i compared MJ and VY in a way i didnt. which u did whether u want to admit it or not

 

[BHendri5]

yea Brandon Jones who couldnt lose anybody is a good receiver. also not to mentioned dropped a crucial ball against Indy that would have put them in FG range at the end of the game against Indy and would probably be 3-0 right now if he had caught it. and yea White is a very legit RB that only came to training camp 30 pounts overweight. and that has not been able to get the majority of the carries from Chris Brown a guy that nobody wanted as a FA this last season and the only reason they got him back is because they were concerned about their lack of depth at RB. they resigned him at the minimum for 1 year. O-line is good but like Romo here in Dallas he makes his O-line look even better than it is because of his ability to move around in the pocket and avoid sacks that most QB couldnt. and seriously VY's style wat is that supposed to mean???

Seriously im gonna let go that u mentioned Vick because WOW that just kills ur entire credibility :bang2:

you have no cred, our O-Line is very very good, Romo does not have to make it look good. The Titans O-line is good, VY does not make it look good, it is good. BRandon JOnes is a good receiver and White has already proved that he is legit even before he stepped on an NFL field, because he went to camp overweight, that was immaturity, getting the money and then just fat catting it around.

Don't confused Vick's talent with his decision about his off field activity,
Vick is talented, no doubt about it. Both guys are very talented, but Vick is a better passer, he throws the ball a 100mph all the time, and that is part of his problem, both guys cannot read defenses, and both guys are a run first QBs.

So they always take their eyes off their receivers downfield when they make up their minds to run, that is the very reason why VY, ended up throwing the pass to his O-Lineman in that same game you want to blame on Brandon Jones. Vince pulled the basll down to run, but someone cut off that running lane and then he pulled up to try to pass and there was no one there but an O-lineman.

Yeah, you keep rolling with VY, and I'll keep rolling with Romo and all the other guys that are complete QBs.

 

[BHendri5]

:laugh2: Its kind of hard to twist something when i basically repeated what i said last time... :laugh2: I called u out for telling me i compared MJ and VY in a way i didnt. which u did whether u want to admit it or not

LOL, whatever man, you remind me of talking to one of my relatives. I just hope the light comes on for you soon.

I'm done with you.

 

[jimmy40]

Romo.

It's not even close for me.

Vince Young will be a very good QB. He's as athletic as all git out-- however I don't ever see him having the touch on the football that Romo has-- nor does he have Romo's mental game. Don't get me wrong-- Young can gun it in. But Romo will always be able to read defenses better and will complete touch passes that Young won't.

Obviously Romo is the better QB but VY will never have to say he was third string behind Quincy Carter.

 

[RomoIsBack]

romo how can you not after that fumble/run

 

[MichaelWinicki]

Obviously Romo is the better QB but VY will never have to say he was third string behind Quincy Carter.

Undrafted FA's will go through that.

 

[Da Hammer]

you have no cred, our O-Line is very very good, Romo does not have to make it look good. The Titans O-line is good, VY does not make it look good, it is good. BRandon JOnes is a good receiver and White has already proved that he is legit even before he stepped on an NFL field, because he went to camp overweight, that was immaturity, getting the money and then just fat catting it around.

Don't confused Vick's talent with his decision about his off field activity,
Vick is talented, no doubt about it. Both guys are very talented, but Vick is a better passer, he throws the ball a 100mph all the time, and that is part of his problem, both guys cannot read defenses, and both guys are a run first QBs.

So they always take their eyes off their receivers downfield when they make up their minds to run, that is the very reason why VY, ended up throwing the pass to his O-Lineman in that same game you want to blame on Brandon Jones. Vince pulled the basll down to run, but someone cut off that running lane and then he pulled up to try to pass and there was no one there but an O-lineman.

Yeah, you keep rolling with VY, and I'll keep rolling with Romo and all the other guys that are complete QBs.

you say i have no cred and then you expect me to take you seriously when u keep comparing Vick to Young. Anyone that actually watches Vince Young plays knows that he is nothing like Vick except that they both have the ability to run. you want me to take u seriously when u say that White proved he was legit before he came into the NFL??? WOW... yea... oh and i love how u accuse me of twisting wat i say when ur teh one twisting what i say! My post yesterday i complimented both young and romo. mentioned why both are great and that in the next 2 years i would take Romo over Young yet u make it seem like im all young and dont think much of Romo. this is my last post to u cause WOW ur just killin yourself with the things ur sayin...

i will end my post with this. Steve Young and Joe Montana 2 of the greatest QB's in the history of the NFL have both said that Vince Young is the real deal and will be a great QB. Ur saying u have more cred than them???

 

[coblue]

Just watched the CBS 60 Minutes piece.

It was their typical one sided bias piece - and he still came off bad.

Leaders are not late for things. Leaders don't get pissed at the organization for their mistakes.

He is one of the most gifted athletes ever to be born, and that has allowed him to accomplish great things - and skewed his reality for the world.

 

[MichaelWinicki]

romo how can you not after that fumble/run

VY is showing some attributes of being a good to possibly very-good NFL QB. Romo on the other hand is doing some things that are downright historic-- not just with the Dallas Cowboy record book but the NFL record book... that's the difference between these two QB's at this point.

 

[Rampage]

you say i have no cred and then you expect me to take you seriously when u keep comparing Vick to Young. Anyone that actually watches Vince Young plays knows that he is nothing like Vick except that they both have the ability to run. you want me to take u seriously when u say that White proved he was legit before he came into the NFL??? WOW... yea... oh and i love how u accuse me of twisting wat i say when ur teh one twisting what i say! My post yesterday i complimented both young and romo. mentioned why both are great and that in the next 2 years i would take Romo over Young yet u make it seem like im all young and dont think much of Romo. this is my last post to u cause WOW ur just killin yourself with the things ur sayin...

i will end my post with this. Steve Young and Joe Montana 2 of the greatest QB's in the history of the NFL have both said that Vince Young is the real deal and will be a great QB. Ur saying u have more cred than them???

vince young is alot like vick except young can throw a little bit better

 

[Da Hammer]

vince young is alot like vick except young can throw a little bit better

oh man i think me and you have already had plenty of discussions about Vince although its been a while but still i wont repeat myself to u again.

 

[jimmy40]

Undrafted FA's will go through that.

Doesn't change the fact does it?

 

[jimmy40]

VY is showing some attributes of being a good to possibly very-good NFL QB. Romo on the other hand is doing some things that are downright historic-- not just with the Dallas Cowboy record book but the NFL record book... that's the difference between these two QB's at this point.

At what point? This is not VY's 5th year. This whole thread is stupid. Romo is light years ahead of VY right now, as he should be.

 

[Beninato]

Vince Young is a garbage QB. He's Mike Vick 2.0, Don't even mention him the same sentance as Romo.

Actually better yet, wait till' that running back throws more TDs then INTs.

 

[MichaelWinicki]

Doesn't change the fact does it?

And it makes Romo's progression even more amazing.

 

[Da Hammer]

At what point? This is not VY's 5th year. This whole thread is stupid. Romo is light years ahead of VY right now, as he should be.

this man is a wise man!