What a ring for Romo would mean

romothesavior

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,512
Reaction score
4,366
My buddy (a Colts fan) and I had an interesting chat last night about his love for Peyton Manning. He was talking about how even though he will always love the Colts and is a big Luck fan, nothing will ever compare to the Manning years because they were his formative years as a fan. Luck may win ten Super Bowls, but he will never be Peyton. Peyton took over when my buddy was in 4th grade, and quite literally saved football in Indianapolis. He put the Colts on the map and made them relevant here.

My dad often says similar things about Roger Staubach. He was in his teens during the 70s glory years, and always raves about ol Roger the Dodger. He still roots hard for the Cowboys and watches them most weeks, but it's just not the same as when Staubach was out there.

This got me to thinking; who is my Manning, my Staubach? Without a doubt, it's Tony Romo.

I'm 26, and my first vivid memory of the NFL was Super Bowl XXX when I was seven years old. Little did I know it would go downhill from there. Sure, there were a lot of other great moments, like Emmitt breaking Payton's record, but for most of my formative years, being a Cowboys fan was a futile enterprise. We weren't even relevant.

Enter Tony Romo. My username (romothesavior) is a bit hyperbolic, but the dude made the Cowboys relevant for the first time in my adult life. I'll always remember his first game, the bobbled snap in Seattle, the beautiful 13-3 season, all the heroic comebacks and frustrating losses. Sure, 8-8 has sucked the past three years. But it beats being a kid and avid fan, and looking forward to 5-11s and Quincy Carter and Troy Hambrick.

Just like my buddy with Manning and my dad with Staubach, I am invested in Romo like no other player. And like my buddy and my dad, I'll keep rooting for my team long after he's gone. Much to the annoyance of my significant other, the Cowboys hold a special place in my heart that little else can match. But when I'm 50 and yelling at the TV for some other gunslinger to win us ring number 10, it'll be with just a shade less passion than I possess now. I had never contemplated that until my conversation last night, and it's made me appreciate his career and this season even more.

Yes it's just a game, and yes I'm just a fan watching grown men play it. But I want Romo to win one so damn bad. Not only so I can rub it in all the naysayers faces, but because he deserves one. The dude should go down as a first ballot Hall of Famer, one of the all-time greats to wear the Star or strap on a helmet. But it won't happen without a ring. He will never earn widespread respect without one. So ******, lets get a ring!
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
I think it could mean the difference in HOF or not. Tony has played to an elite level but as a team we have failed, if he and this team can achieve a SB win then I think that will push Romo over the top
 

romothesavior

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,512
Reaction score
4,366
I think it could mean the difference in HOF or not. Tony has played to an elite level but as a team we have failed, if he and this team can achieve a SB win then I think that will push Romo over the top

Wholeheartedly agree.
 

TimHortons

TheXFactor
Messages
1,343
Reaction score
950
I think a ring would have alot of fans here talking about HOF, but I'm not sure if 1 would get him in. I think 2 would for sure get him in, but 1 would be on the edge IMO. In this day and age with big QB numbers, for a QB with 1 ring it would take amazing stats ala Manning to get in. While Romo does have great stats, they're not on the level of Manning's. I think 2 would definitely get him in.
 

CowboyChris

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,511
Reaction score
4,961
If he doesnt win a ring, I doubt he makes it to the HOF. Some may argue he needs to 2 to get in. Despite all that I think one ring will shut up alot of his naysayers which is equally as important.
 

Toruk_Makto

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,242
Reaction score
17,336
Romo will always go down as the best QB I ever rooted for on the Cowboys.

What this will mean to others is they will realize that Romo is the best QB they ever watched play on the Cowboys.
 

Alexander

What's it going to be then, eh?
Messages
62,482
Reaction score
67,294
My buddy (a Colts fan) and I had an interesting chat last night about his love for Peyton Manning. He was talking about how even though he will always love the Colts and is a big Luck fan, nothing will ever compare to the Manning years because they were his formative years as a fan.

This is true. I suppose that there is a generation now that only knows Romo. Too bad, because they missed some greats in Staubach and Aikman and a pretty good one in Danny White.

Having seen them all, Romo would need a ring to elevate him onto the Cowboys' Rushmore though. No question about it.
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
I think a ring would have alot of fans here talking about HOF, but I'm not sure if 1 would get him in. I think 2 would for sure get him in, but 1 would be on the edge IMO. In this day and age with big QB numbers, for a QB with 1 ring it would take amazing stats ala Manning to get in. While Romo does have great stats, they're not on the level of Manning's. I think 2 would definitely get him in.

Peyton does have great numbers and is a shoe in but even Manning has never put up over 90 QB rating every year he has played and Romo has. If a guy like Moon can get in with an offensive scheme like the run and shoot Romo should be able to make it with a ring
 

TimHortons

TheXFactor
Messages
1,343
Reaction score
950
Peyton does have great numbers and is a shoe in but even Manning has never put up over 90 QB rating every year he has played and Romo has. If a guy like Moon can get in with an offensive scheme like the run and shoot Romo should be able to make it with a ring

As I mentioned though, the standard for QB's stats are much higher in this era than they were in the past. Stats today need to be much higher to be considered impressive than in the past. Plus, Moon had got into the HOF due to more than just his play
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
As I mentioned though, the standard for QB's stats are much higher in this era than they were in the past. Stats today need to be much higher to be considered impressive than in the past. Plus, Moon had got into the HOF due to more than just his play

true but then Romo is around the top every year. I think a ring gives him a very good chance of making the HOF
 

ufcrules1

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,652
Reaction score
3,800
It would mean everything. Without it, he will always be known as a choker. He has no room for error right now with his age and past play in win and in/playoff games.
 

nablives

Active Member
Messages
978
Reaction score
232
I'd say for most folks, it's the only thing that can validate him. Without it, even if he takes Dallas to the next 4 Super Bowls and losses them all, he'll always have a negative label attached to him. It really sucks too, because if you've been closely tuned into the story of Romo, the dude honestly seems like a pretty likable guy, and he's left it all out on the field just to keep the Cowboys as good as mediocre. I don't think I've ever felt as bad for a pro athlete as I do for him in regards to his national image. He's been far from perfect, but he's been so much better than so many talking heads and fans with agendas want to give him credit for.
 

Red Dragon

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,395
Reaction score
3,773
I've been a member of a Giants message board for 7 years. I used to live in New York state. Let me tell you: Eli Manning has won two Super Bowls, is a two-time Super Bowl MVP, and he's still mocked and criticized all the time, even by many Giants fans.


People are really overestimating what winning a Super Bowl does for a player's reputation.
 

perrykemp

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,503
Reaction score
9,274
true but then Romo is around the top every year. I think a ring gives him a very good chance of making the HOF

I think there is an argument that Romo could make the HoF will a couple of deep playoff runs that don't result in Superbowl victory.

I think it's virtually impossible for Romo to make the HoF will only a single playoff victory to his credit.
 
Top