What Makes Dak Irreplaceable?

BoysForLife · Dec 24, 2023

TheMarathonContinues said:
Romo threw a pick which is why we lost to the Bronco's that year.

Case in point. Exhibit A. From one of the chief Dak davidians

Eddie · Dec 24, 2023

TheMarathonContinues said:
I think Dak can take us there I have seen Eli MAnning win 2 rings.....I think Dak can do it but I don't know if this team can. There are just some things you can't do if you want to win a ring and one of them is leading the league in penalties....that's not a SB winner.

Dak will never get us there. That's just a fact of life.

MountaineerCowboy · Dec 24, 2023

Ken said:
What makes one post something like this when he made play after play to get us a go ahead td against a 10-4 team on the road?

What makes Dak irreplaceable to you, Ken?

You're the perfect person to speak on this.

Educate us on why Dak is irreplaceable.

plymkr · Dec 24, 2023

Jipper said:
He's replaceable, and he's shown definitively that he isn't deserving of top money.

Sure he has stats of a top 10 qb but that's bc 1 he's very good against the nfce and 2 he's very good against bad teams.

He will never get the cowboys to the superbowl and likely will be the reason they don't get there bc his Contraxt will prohibit many other signings.

Go with Trey Lance, go with someone off the street, go with a draft pick - dak isn't going to get it done, he just isn't that guy

This. His contract, or future contract, will further hinder our FA approach. Dak better get used to running for his life if we can’t replace players due to his contract.

Take the emotions out of it. Look at it this way. Does anyone think the Vikings should resign Cousins for market value? 53-55 APY. Or would you want the Cowboys to sign Kirk Cousins at 53-55? If you wouldn’t want Cousins then you shouldn’t want Dak. Their careers and play mirror each other. Cousins is a good franchise QB who sucks in big games and the playoffs. Cousins puts up numbers in the regular season and folds in the playoffs.

A lot of talk about Flacco in this thread. Flacco has a Super Bowl win. Dak and Kirk do not.

CT Dal Fan · Dec 24, 2023

The last time Dak set foot on the field today the Cowboys were winning after he led a 17 play do or die drive.

The defense blew it. So the solution is get rid of Dak.

Isn't that kind of like scratching your nose when your butt itches?

Slick · Dec 24, 2023

MountaineerCowboy said:
This dude quit on Dak so hard a few weeks ago that he's had to resort back to the "DURRRR FOR DAK" campaign to try and get back on the Dak fans good side lololol

When you don't flip flop and stand by your convictions 9 years in you don't have to resort to such low tactics.

I found it helpful to use the ignore button on the ignorant. I won’t see any more posts from him.

KingCorcoran · Dec 24, 2023

MountaineerCowboy said:
I always see "But if not Dak then who?" type of replies to basically anyone not happy with Dak as the QB for the Cowboys.

What makes him irreplaceable in the eyes of those with that mindset? Are there people that really think Dak's skill and ability is SO high that he can't be replaced?

What skill or talents sets him apart from say..... Joe Flacco off the couch?

He is a top NFL quarterback. If someone has the opinion that he’s not good enough it’s fair to ask who an alternative is. Dak Prescott is a very good quarterback in his prime. Few in the NFL are significantly better.

Eddie · Dec 24, 2023

CT Dal Fan said:
The last time Dak set foot on the field today the Cowboys were winning after he led a 17 play do or die drive.

The defense blew it. So the solution is get rid of Dak.

Isn't that kind of like scratching your nose when your butt itches?

Dak scoring 20 points is ok with you ???

unionjack8 · Dec 24, 2023

It's time to move on, he's not it, he never has been.
If you extend him you GUARANTEE more years of the same ending.

MountaineerCowboy · Dec 24, 2023

KingCorcoran said:
He is a top NFL quarterback. If someone has the opinion that he’s not good enough it’s fair to ask who an alternative is. Dak Prescott is a very good quarterback in his prime. Few in the NFL are significantly better.

Why can't nobody explain to me what makes Dak so great though?

You think he's a top QB?

Tell me why.

plymkr · Dec 24, 2023

Jipper said:
Probably....but at least there is potential for a different outcome.

With dak there is no other possible outcome

Right. I’m at the point now that if a possible WC win is the best we can do then I’d rather roll the dice with Lance because Lance is younger, more physically gifted, and has a higher ceiling. If he gets things figured out then there’s a possibility for a different outcome. I’ve been watching this movie for 8 years. I know how it ends.

Eddie · Dec 24, 2023

KingCorcoran said:
He is a top NFL quarterback. If someone has the opinion that he’s not good enough it’s fair to ask who an alternative is. Dak Prescott is a very good quarterback in his prime. Few in the NFL are significantly better.

Maybe we could have found Purdy. Nothing wrong with churning the roster ... SF does it all the time. We're happy with who we have.

Nexx · Dec 24, 2023

TheMarathonContinues said:
Romo threw a pick which is why we lost to the Bronco's that year. I had never once felt confident in Romo in the playoffs. And same can be said about Dak.

Romo's foot was step on by his own lineman when threw that pass otherwise thats a completion.

Ken · Dec 24, 2023

MountaineerCowboy said:
What makes Dak irreplaceable to you, Ken?

You're the perfect person to speak on this.

Educate us on why Dak is irreplaceable.

Why?

Well because you MOST likely end up with a Field's, Lawrence, Herbert, etc etc etc.

You literally have a qb playing as well as anyone in the league and this is the silly stuff we are talking about.

Jipper · Dec 24, 2023

plymkr said:
Right. I’m at the point now that if a possible WC win is the best we can do then I’d rather roll the dice with Lance because Lance is younger, more physically gifted, and has a higher ceiling. If he gets things figured out then there’s a possibility for a different outcome. I’ve been watching this movie for 8 years. I know how it ends.

Heck yeah, I'd rather see a young hungry team with unknown potential vs what we are watching now

Pug4366 · Dec 24, 2023

88sAndHeartbreak said:
Remind us all, did he look bad during the 5 game win streak?

So why can’t he win on the road?

MountaineerCowboy · Dec 24, 2023

Ken said:
Why?

Well because you MOST likely end up with a Field's, Lawrence, Herbert, etc etc etc.

You literally have a qb playing as well as anyone in the league and this is the silly stuff we are talking about.

Add Ken to the list of posters that believe Dak is a top QB but has no idea why.

TheMarathonContinues · Dec 24, 2023

Nexx said:
Romo's foot was step on by his own lineman when threw that pass otherwise thats a completion.

I mean we can make some excuses for all mistakes...he bobbled the snap because the football was "wet"...he still threw a pick lol.

TheMarathonContinues · Dec 24, 2023

MountaineerCowboy said:
Hold up.

Did you just say you're not confident in Dak in the playoffs?

You gonna address the MountaineerCowboy fan that's on the Eagles forum or naw?

TheMarathonContinues · Dec 24, 2023

BoysForLife said:
Case in point. Exhibit A. From one of the chief Dak davidians

What point?

What Makes Dak Irreplaceable?

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member