CZ POLL Where do you rank Dak Prescott among quarterbacks in the NFL?

[blueblood70]

109 jk

anyone selecting 21 and lower is absolutely the definition of troll a hater.. i can see 6-10 or 11-15 but man what you smoking that can push 20 other qbs ahead of dak.. thats INSANE

 

[khiladi]

I’m pretty sure roster has nothing to do with Dak’s high ranking by many...

 

[G2]

6-10 is reasonable.

 

[DFWJC]

I’m pretty sure roster has nothing to do with Dak’s high ranking by many...

So, in the 3-day sample size

Prescott 62-89, 69.7%, (18-25, 72%)
Dalton 48-65, 73.8%, (11-16, 69%)
DeNucci 13-15, 86.7%, (4-4, 100%)
Thorson 5-11, 45.4%, (n/a)

fwiw

 

[khiladi]

So, in the 3-day sample size

Prescott 62-89, 69.7%, (18-25, 72%)
Dalton 48-65, 73.8%, (11-16, 69%)
DeNucci 13-15, 86.7%, (4-4, 100%)
Thorson 5-11, 45.4%, (n/a)

fwiw

I think what stands out the most is the amount of reps Dalton is getting.

 

[khiladi]

So, in the 3-day sample size

Prescott 62-89, 69.7%, (18-25, 72%)
Dalton 48-65, 73.8%, (11-16, 69%)
DeNucci 13-15, 86.7%, (4-4, 100%)
Thorson 5-11, 45.4%, (n/a)

fwiw

Apparently, on the 27th, when the OL was starting a bunch of back-ups, Dak was throwing awful INTs and getting sacked. So Dak answering questions about the ability to lead a team when he’s not getting all-pro blocking, even in training camp, is still an issue...

• In one of the first plays of team period, Dak Prescott threw an interception after being pressured by a blitzing Jaylon Smith. Dak threw to a spot on the field with no offensive player in the area. Only safety Ha Ha Clinton-Dix was there to pick the ball off and run into the end zone for a pick-six.
• Dak was later picked off by rookie Trevon Diggs, who had another good practice. Diggs caught an overthrow by Dak over the middle and was able to have a sizable return before the play was whistled dead.

https://www.dallascowboys.com/news/practice-points-defense-flusters-dak-more

 

[Gangsta Spanksta]

currently 65% say top 10 which is exactly where most pundits rank him.

the irony is the noisy 35% that rank him lower post in troll fashion non-stop.

or you can say 85% see dak being from 6-15. and the outliers are 15% of the people.

 

[davidariust24]

Ignore the contract situation. Assume the contract is whatever you want it to be.

Where do you rank Dak Prescott among quarterbacks in the NFL?

He's between 8 and 13

 

[jterrell]

or you can say 85% see dak being from 6-15. and the outliers are 15% of the people.

sure you can if you ignore that most of that 29% saying 11-15 is simply wrong.

Chris Simms: 8th
Sporting News: 8th
Yahoo Sports: 7th
Athlon Sports: 5th
CBS Sports: 5th
NFL top 100 9th

 

[Direwolf63]

There are guys around here who think he's around 70 or so

 

[Gangsta Spanksta]

sure you can if you ignore that most of that 29% saying 11-15 is simply wrong.

Chris Simms: 8th
Sporting News: 8th
Yahoo Sports: 7th
Athlon Sports: 5th
CBS Sports: 5th
NFL top 100 9th

top 5 is being homerish IMO. And you saying that most of that 29% saying 11-15 is simply wrong without providing some sort of graph of all instead of things you pick and choose, is just fitting things to go along with your narrative.

I mean this article for example that says that dak is a top 10 QB: https://www.bloggingtheboys.com/202...10-quarterback-heading-into-2020-season-wentz by NFL exutives and coaches, says the following:


"Prescott checks a lot of boxes. He averages 10 wins per season, he’s never missed a game, he pushed for 5,000 yards last season and, as one NFL coordinator said after a recent film study, he has elite footwork in the pocket.

All this was enough to earn Prescott a few top-five votes, but he was mostly in the 7-to-12 range, with evaluators citing inconsistent ball placement as a core issue."

So it says that there were a few NFL executives and coaches that think that Dak is a top 5 QB but the majority of them ranked Dak 7 to 12. That fall closer into the range that I said that was reasonable. It's my opinion, but I can take guys a lot more serious that say that Dak is 6-10 or 11-15, and see valid arguments for those numbers, versus guys who say he is 1-5, which makes me think they probably are a Homer or guys saying he is 16-20 or 21 or lower, which makes me think they either under value him, or are in the hater catagory. I mean you can have your own opinion but the fact remains that the majority of the board falls into the 6-15 range and I personally find that quite reasonable.

 

[DFWJC]

sure you can if you ignore that most of that 29% saying 11-15 is simply wrong.

Chris Simms: 8th
Sporting News: 8th
Yahoo Sports: 7th
Athlon Sports: 5th
CBS Sports: 5th
NFL top 100 9th

To be fair,
Staff rankings (won't use single individual like Simms, Coherd—who I think said he was 16 or so.)

NBC Sports: 12th
The Athletic: 12th (or 14th?)
DMN Staff: 8th
Pro FootballFocus: 11th

 

[Brax]

So, in the 3-day sample size

Prescott 62-89, 69.7%, (18-25, 72%)
Dalton 48-65, 73.8%, (11-16, 69%)
DeNucci 13-15, 86.7%, (4-4, 100%)
Thorson 5-11, 45.4%, (n/a)

fwiw

(11-14) 78%.

 

[DFWJC]

(11-14) 78%.

thx

Prescott 62-89, 69.7%, (18-25, 72%)
Dalton 48-65, 73.8%, (11-14, 78%)
DeNucci 13-15, 86.7%, (4-4, 100%)
Thorson 5-11, 45.4%, (n/a)

 

[Risen Star]

So less than 2% of us are qualified to be an NFL scout.

 

[black label]

rofl

 

[csirl]

If the team thought Dak was in the top 20, they would have given him a long term deal., but.....

 

[DanA]

If the team thought Dak was in the top 20, they would have given him a long term deal., but.....

If they thought he was top 20 they’d give him the 2nd highest paid contract? Not sure about that.

 

[Swagger]

thx

Prescott 62-89, 69.7%, (18-25, 72%)
Dalton 48-65, 73.8%, (11-14, 78%)
DeNucci 13-15, 86.7%, (4-4, 100%)
Thorson 5-11, 45.4%, (n/a)

Any idea on the number of interceptions thrown during this period of time?

 

[Hadenough]

My top 20 QB list:

1 Pat Mahomes
2 Lamar Jackson
3 Russell Wilson
4 Aaron Rodgers
5 Tom Brady
6 Deshaun Watson
7 Drew Brees
8 Dak Prescott
9 Kyle Murray
10 Carson Wentz
11 Matthew Stafford
12 Jared Goff
13 Matt Ryan
14 Jimmy Garoppolo
15 Kirk Cousins
16 Josh Allen
17 Ben Roethisberger
18 Baker Mayfield
19 Phillip Rivers
20 Daniel Jones

Not a badlist. I would flip Cousins and Dak though.