Which roster is better - Dallas or Philly?

[mmohican29]

And what "evidence" is their to support the notion that the Cowboys have a better roster than the Eagles?

We swept them, but if we're being honest, it took some good fortune to do it. Philly was one of the most beat up teams in the league last year as well.

I've answered this Q several times. If you want to believe the Eagles are better, you are free to do so.

But understand this: if you really think the Eagles roster is better and it worries you, your Mother is probably searching your top drawer for her nylons as we speak.

 

[mmohican29]

S. TE. DT. are all clear edges for them.

LB. RB. CB (because of Jones). are all clear edges for us.

The rest are toss ups. Note, I am not telling you the Cowboys can't be the more talented team or aren't the more talented team, but it's a hell of a lot more closer in terms of roster talent than you think.

I'm sorry... were the Eagles playing horseshoes or handgranades @ home or away vs. Dallas last season?

Or was it Football, and awarded the L for their efforts?

 

[Sydla]

I'm sorry... were the Eagles playing horseshoes or handgranades @ home or away vs. Dallas last season?

Or was it Football, and awarded the L for their efforts?

And yet. Both teams went the same distance in the playoffs.

And the Cowboys only finished a game up on them.

So they are a lot closer together than you want to admit.

 

[Sydla]

The final score is best indicator in most athletic contests as to who probably played better.

Sure. For assessing the “team”.

But for assessing an individual player?

 

[mmohican29]

Sure. For assessing the “team”.

But for assessing an individual player?

Please refer to original thread topic.

 

[mmohican29]

And yet. Both teams went the same distance in the playoffs.

And the Cowboys only finished a game up on them.

So they are a lot closer together than you want to admit.

So what? The thread title is which roster is better.

The Cowboys have the better roster. And I've provided evidence at to why.

You keep on about it's close, it's close, blah, blah. Newsflash: all teams in the NFL are "close".

I can't understand why you can't accept that as of today, the Cowboys should be considered the better football team with the better roster because ALL evidence suggests it does, and nothing but a straw argument says it does not.

 

[pancakeman]

Philly has three draft picks before Dallas has their first, so that's gotta enter the equation.

 

[RJ_MacReady]

I can't understand why you can't accept that as of today

Sydla, as it has been pointed out often...much to his is dismay, is a closeted Eagles fan that has no life other than to pump 20-30 posts a day mitigating the positives of the Cowboys and Reebok pumping it up on the Eagles. #comeatmerowdy

 

[Sydla]

Please refer to original thread topic.

You responded to a post in a debate about specific players - Wentz and Prescott - not the team overall.

 

[Sydla]

So what? The thread title is which roster is better.

The Cowboys have the better roster. And I've provided evidence at to why.

You keep on about it's close, it's close, blah, blah. Newsflash: all teams in the NFL are "close".

I can't understand why you can't accept that as of today, the Cowboys should be considered the better football team with the better roster because ALL evidence suggests it does, and nothing but a straw argument says it does not.

Straw argument?

LOL

 

[Sydla]

Sydla, as it has been pointed out often...much to his is dismay, is a closeted Eagles fan that has no life other than to pump 20-30 posts a day mitigating the positives of the Cowboys and Reebok pumping it up on the Eagles. #comeatmerowdy

LOL.

And there it is.

 

[RJ_MacReady]

Philly has three draft picks before Dallas has their first, so that's gotta enter the equation.

Cool. Maybe they’ll bundle picks, move up and select soft tissue toughness for Wentz this year...

 

[RJ_MacReady]

LOL.

And there it is.

It’s always here, big boy.

What’s missing is your tired response of “Hey, now! Look at my post count...I can’t possibly a troll!!!”

 

[Sydla]

It’s always here, big boy.

What’s missing is your tired response of “Hey, now! Look at my post count...I can’t possibly a troll!!!”

LOL

 

[mmohican29]

You responded to a post in a debate about specific players - Wentz and Prescott - not the team overall.

The song remains the same sir.

In addition to the Cowboys having a better roster in totality, Dak has played better than Wentz over each QB's first 3 seasons and also and has never missed a start.

 

[Flamma]

Why aren’t we running 11 personnel under center with Dak?

I'll get back to you right after I talk to Jason tomorrow morning.

You can't tell me that sitting in shotgun with 7 guys dropping back in pass coverage is any easier. If Dak isn't comfortable from that formation then he shouldn't be on this team.

 

[MaaS]

I've answered this Q several times. If you want to believe the Eagles are better, you are free to do so.

But understand this: if you really think the Eagles roster is better and it worries you, your Mother is probably searching your top drawer for her nylons as we speak.

Man, you're quite the internet tough guy! I'll think twice before daring to question your almighty opinion again.

It does not worry me. It's a game between grown men I don't know. I'm just saying that in this game, it's close and depends on your vantage point. I must be insane.

 

[mmohican29]

Not a tough guy, just over the completely unwarranted fawning over a rival team by fellow Cowboys fans.

Let alone the umpteen trolls ready to feed off the stupidity of their anxiety over a team we are close to owning the last 3 seasons.

 

[mmohican29]

Straw argument?

LOL

Yes sir. Please provide proof that the Eagles roster TODAY is better.

You can't.

Thus in your mind, the debate isn't really about what the OP's original question is. It's about hypotheticals.

 

[Fwed]

LOL. Stop your whining.

The stupid missed fumble on the kickoff happened in the first 15 seconds of the game. You had the remaining 59 minutes to outplay and beat us and you couldn't.

butterfly effect.