Who hits the hardest? Sean Taylor or Roy Williams

[Hostile]

2004 was after RWs 3rd year, not his rookie year. I never claimed ST hits harder, but he hits nearly as hard, is faster and covers more field then RW and forces QBs/offensive coordinators to game plan around him.

RF, it is being maintained by your cohorts in here that ST hits harder.

After Roy's rookie year he made the list of the NFL's biggest hitters.

ST did not, despite the fact one of your coaches is the main source. In that video I see good play, but not hard hits deserving of praise that he "blows people up."

If you have footage from last year of a superior hit, introduce it.

I'll show you one from Roy's rookie year (not his 3rd) that will be equal to it or more violent.

As I said before, Ronnie Lott must be a Cowboys homer. I put more stock in his answers than any of you guys coming here to call us homers.

 

[burmafrd]

Only a moronic skin homer would even ask the question. Who in this league is known for laying the wood- IT AIN'T TAYLOR. WHo is this league does ROnnie Lott thinks plays like him? IT AIN'T TAYLOR. And as for that BS about Taylor just hitting head on- if nothing else shows just how pathetic skins fans are that does. Why don't you go to an eagle board or a giant board or ANY OTHER BOARD and ask that question? I will tell you why- because you would get the same answer you got here. poor pathetic skin homer.

 

[RiggoForever]

RF, it is being maintained by your cohorts in here that ST hits harder.

After Roy's rookie year he made the list of the NFL's biggest hitters.

ST did not, despite the fact one of your coaches is the main source. In that video I see good play, but not hard hits deserving of praise that he "blows people up."

If you have footage from last year of a superior hit, introduce it.

I'll show you one from Roy's rookie year (not his 3rd) that will be equal to it or more violent.

As I said before, Ronnie Lott must be a Cowboys homer. I put more stock in his answers than any of you guys coming here to call us homers.

Come on Hostile, you have to acknowledge that was a superior hit whether or not you like the guy.

Heres another from 2004 that I'd consider vicious

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HpNXkMO0-S0

 

[BigDFan5]

Come on Hostile, you have to acknowledge that was a superior hit whether or not you like the guy.

Heres another from 2004 that I'd consider vicious

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HpNXkMO0-S0

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XLgRAFUhGCM&search=roy%20williams

 

[AdamJT13]

Then again, you don't see Sean Taylor pulling down from behind even though he's forced into coverage.

Of course you see Taylor pulling down from behind -- when he's close enough to pull down from behind, that is. (No free safety allowed more deep touchdown passes in 2004 than Taylor.)

http://img91.*************/img91/3407/ab0366gi.jpg

 

[AdamJT13]

Come on Hostile, you have to acknowledge that was a superior hit whether or not you like the guy.

Please. The ball popping out made that hit seem bigger than it actually was.

And both of the hits you've posted came against unsuspecting receivers (meaning players catching the ball who don't know the hit is coming). Any safety can hit those guys and make it look like a big hit. Show me a video of Sean Taylor taking on a running back head-on, lifting him off his feet and driving him several yards backward in the air, and doing the same thing to several players who were trying to block him.

 

[peplaw06]

Of course you see Taylor pulling down from behind -- when he's close enough to pull down from behind, that is. (No free safety allowed more deep touchdown passes in 2004 than Taylor.)

http://img91.*************/img91/3407/ab0366gi.jpg

 

[5Stars]

Please. The ball popping out made that hit seem bigger than it actually was.

And both of the hits you've posted came against unsuspecting receivers (meaning players catching the ball who don't know the hit is coming). Any safety can hit those guys and make it look like a big hit. Show me a video of Sean Taylor taking on a running back head-on, lifting him off his feet and driving him several yards backward in the air, and doing the same thing to several players who were trying to block him.

Every defensive player is going to make a good hit now and then...but, Roy has a consistency about how he plays...

These kinds of RedStinks posts are nothing but pee-pee envy!

:starspin

 

[Hostile]

Come on Hostile, you have to acknowledge that was a superior hit whether or not you like the guy.

Heres another from 2004 that I'd consider vicious

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HpNXkMO0-S0

That's better than the ones on the video previously posted.

Like I said, I see good football. I don't see devestating hits in that footage. Good hits? Yeah, there are some good ones. I acknowledge that.

Here's one I want you to see. I am no good at posting snippets of videos or doing graphics. So please see Roy's hit on Sean Alexander at about 1:30 of the video. Note that Sean is running forward. Look where he lands from the point of impact.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ezFgHGSLhyY&search=roy%20williams

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Roy w/o a doubt

look at what he did to Lelie, Jimmy Smith, Todd Heap, Laverneous Coles, some of the hardest hits I ever saw, and will ever see

 

[Bob Sacamano]

oh yeah, Roy dislocated Emmitt's shoulder

 

[Bob Sacamano]

as I read Commander fan posts, all I gotta say is, give it up, there's no competition

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Or the Dallas O-line is be dominating this year?

never heard that

I've even heard that somebody thinks that Watkins or Davis = Sean Taylor.

LINK!

 

[RiggoForever]

That's better than the ones on the video previously posted.

Like I said, I see good football. I don't see devestating hits in that footage. Good hits? Yeah, there are some good ones. I acknowledge that.

Here's one I want you to see. I am no good at posting snippets of videos or doing graphics. So please see Roy's hit on Sean Alexander at about 1:30 of the video. Note that Sean is running forward. Look where he lands from the point of impact.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ezFgHGSLhyY&search=roy%20williams

That's a really powerful hit.

 

[AdamJT13]

oh yeah, Roy dislocated Emmitt's shoulder

Roy actually broke Emmitt's shoulder blade -- by hitting him from the front.

Emmitt had absorbed thousands and thousands of hits before that. He took one hit from Roy, and Emmitt acknowledged it as the hardest he has ever been hit.

 

[5Stars]

Roy actually broke Emmitt's shoulder blade -- by hitting him from the front.

Emmitt had absorbed thousands and thousands of hits before that. He took one hit from Roy, and Emmitt acknowledged it as the hardest he has ever been hit.

Roy Williams will knock you back into the middle of last Tuesday!

 

[Avery]

This reminds me of those old Nightmare on Elm Street movies, the ones where Freddy dies at the end but you know in your heart of hearts that he's not really dead, just waiting until he inexplicably comes back and we do it all over again. Nothing ever changes, just rinse and repeat.

I could give two shats and a twizzler who hits harder. All I know is that as a Cowboy fan, RW does not leave me sleepless at night that he'll do something stupid whereas ST, well...

 

[BigDFan5]

Roy Williams will knock you back into the middle of last Tuesday!

Roy will hit you so hard, your children are born with bruises

 

[Hostile]

That's a really powerful hit.

That's from his rookie year. It isn't his hardest hit IMO. He did to a guy known for his toughness running with the ball. The difference IMO is that Sean didn't just go down from the hit they way you'd expect. He went backwards 2 or 3 yards.

It's one thing to knock a guy backwards who is standing still, a la Parker. It's quite another to have the guy's 225 pounds of forward momentum change directions.

Roy is the bigger hitter.

Check out his tackle on Jeff Garcia in that video too. That's blowing someone up. Again, rookie year.

 

[5Stars]

Roy will hit you so hard, your children are born with bruises

I'm telling you right now...if Roy hits you, you WILL land in another zipcode!

He's a bad...(shut your mouth)...

:starspin