Who is the best QB entering 2015? From NFL.com

[brymatt94]

Because he's not that good.

And here I thought this opinion went extinct a few years ago and we could move on to other topics.

 

[PoundTheRock]

I never said Romo didn't beat the Eagles in the playoffs. Congratulations to Tony Romo on beating a washed up Donovan McNabb. I'm still proud of him to this day.

 

[Toruk_Makto]

Ya know....that's a damn good point.

(But I'd take him here in a heartbeat.)

As would I. But that's a projection.

I couldn't in good conscious put him top 5 for 2015 QBs.

 

[benson]

I never said Romo didn't beat the Eagles in the playoffs. Congratulations to Tony Romo on beating a washed up Donovan McNabb. I'm still proud of him to this day.

That was the entire premise of your pathetic argument. How Romo COULDN'T do that. Yet he has, on many occasions he has done everything he could possibly do to get this team to the next level.

You're done here.

 

[DFWJC]

Brees
Ben
Eli
Luck - Mostly due to the age factor. Way more physically talented than Romo.
R. Wilson - Another age pick.

I knew I recognized that familiar stench of PoundTheRock
Beyond full of crap.

 

[PoundTheRock]

That was the entire premise of your pathetic argument. How Romo COULDN'T do that. Yet he has, on many occasions he has done everything he could possibly do to get this team to the next level.

You're done here.

The next level is not the divisional round of the playoffs. I know we as Cowboys fans don't know anything about success in the NFL anymore, but please have some self-respect as a fan.

 

[DandyDon1722]

That was the entire premise of your pathetic argument. How Romo COULDN'T do that. Yet he has, on many occasions he has done everything he could possibly do to get this team to the next level.

You're done here.

He's been done for a long time. I own him so bad he doesn't even respond anymore and I don't read him anymore. I see his name and just keep scrolling. Never contributes one single thought on the team other than Romo drive-by's and notice they are all one or two sentences because he gets crushed.

I have much more respect for guys like KJJ who defends his position with intellectually reasoned posts. A 7th grader can write cheap shots.

Nothing to see here.

 

[Aikmaniac]

Pound the Rock. You're good.

 

[burmafrd]

I think he has spent too much time pounding something else...

clearly someone who takes everything BSPN says as gospel and has not a thought of his own

 

[ActualCowboysFan]

I barely watch games on CBS because Phil Simms is such an awful color guy. So I can't say I respect his opinion that much, but whatever.

I appreciate your confession. I always thought that there was something curious about your thoughts on the game. Your admission that you barely watch the games really brings clarity to your situation.

 

[burmafrd]

Rodgers is the best QB in football at this time and he has a decent edge to the #2 guy Brady and a bit more of an edge to #3 which is Romo. Brees was up there but he is fading and his last year was turnover city. Peyton is done. neither one of them deserve top 10 at this time. Next comes a group consisting of the Rapist, Rivers and then Luck.

 

[burmafrd]

Until Wilson shows he can carry a team he is not a top 10 QB. Ryan has to show he can do something in the late part of the season and playoffs. Newton is spotty. Flacco is streaky.

 

[erod]

Until Wilson shows he can carry a team he is not a top 10 QB. Ryan has to show he can do something in the late part of the season and playoffs. Newton is spotty. Flacco is streaky.

Wilson had a rough game against Dallas, and he was putrid against Green Bay until that final throw.

As much as the Dez catch is driving us crazy, Packer fans have to still be wondering how they didn't win that game. They left so many points on the field.

 

[rags747]

Brees
Ben
Eli
Luck - Mostly due to the age factor. Way more physically talented than Romo.
R. Wilson - Another age pick.

Eli, what a homer u r...

 

[phildadon86]

The next level is not the divisional round of the playoffs. I know we as Cowboys fans don't know anything about success in the NFL anymore, but please have some self-respect as a fan.

You arent a cowboys fan, you also argued the Eagles front office is better then the Cowboys. After 3 first round picks off of number 27, your point is invalid. Romo was the best QB in the entire LEAGUE last season. You should just post on Eagles boards. Your arguments are much better founded and liked there

 

[DFWJC]

I never said Romo didn't beat the Eagles in the playoffs. Congratulations to Tony Romo on beating a washed up Donovan McNabb. I'm still proud of him to this day.

Something stinks...oh, it's you again.
Why don't you and 2-3 other haters form your little circle J over Eli.
Massive troll

 

[JDSmith]

Something stinks...oh, it's you again.
Why don't you and 2-3 other haters form your little circle J over Eli.
Massive troll

Because it's probably just one guy using multiple names. Not much of a circle.

 

[Craig]

The next level is not the divisional round of the playoffs. I know we as Cowboys fans don't know anything about success in the NFL anymore, but please have some self-respect as a fan.

You win. You get what you wanted. You are now ignored. Go report back to your teams message board that you did it again. Woooooo!

 

[gimmesix]

What is there to explain? I'm saying nationally people don't think Romo is as good as those other QBs and they're largely right. That's why he wasn't included in the poll.

No. They're largely wrong and have been for years. But I do agree that nationally people have a perception that Romo is not as good as those other QBs. It's been built on a lot of falsehoods, but it's there.

Posted this before reading the rest of this thread, so I'd just like to say nevermind. No sense beating my head against a dense brick wall.

 

[AzorAhai]

Because he's not that good.

Kind of like your posts