Would you trade McFadden for Peppers?

[Aven8]

Orange and grape. Throw in a case of fruit punch and you can have Jameil Showers, too.

 

[Aven8]

I have not kept up with Houston, but did that QB flop?

Brock you mean?? Awful.

 

[haleyrules]

I would trade Darren for whatever any club offered. Peppers would be asking for too much I would say. I was thinking more like a bucket of KFC...Crispy..

 

[Swanny]

Really? Why would GB do that!? You might as well ask would you trade DMC for JJ Watt. Both trade scenarios are just as likely to happen

 

[CalPolyTechnique]

Of course I would, but it'll never happen.

 

[CalPolyTechnique]

Could have gotten Dwight Freeny for peanuts. Right now he has 3 sacks for the season. I wonder if Cowboys may look into trading Romo for JJ Watt next year? Throw in a 2nd rounder?

Nah, folks didn't like the idea of an old guy producing; he'd be a "progress stopper" we were told.

 

[Leadbelly]

I wouldn't trade to the Packers because it only makes them better. Let them try to win without a running game. Only helps us. Knile Davis does not solve the Packers problem.

If I trade DMC he's heading back to the AFC. It only makes sense to acquire a 29 y/o RB if a team is pretty good but their running game is underperforming. Ravens, Chargers, Jags. We trade him to an NFC team and you KNOW the Fates will have us playing that team in the playoffs. Bad juju.

DMC is not worth nothing. DMC is a starting caliber RB.

 

[DFWJC]

I think this is a no-brainer for us. I thought we should have signed Peppers when we had the chance and that already came back to bite us.

McFadden does nothing for this team right now, and Peppers would be an immediate upgrade and really help cement this defense by bringing some pass rush for a year.

what?
GB, is this a joke. Honest question.

I'm thinking maybe you're posting this to mock some of the outlandish ideas for trades (all favoring Dallas by a mile) that have been posted lately.

is it?

 

[Galian Beast]

I think people think Julius Peppers is 27, isn't on the last year of his contract, and not on the verge of being a backup to a younger better player on a team that has no running game. No Knile Davis is not the answer to their woes.

 

[dogunwo]

GB is 4-2 and just traded for a RB. Why would they trade Peppers to a team they may have to play in the playoffs?

GB is 3-2, and they will not make the playoffs.

 

[mattjames2010]

GB is 3-2, and they will not make the playoffs.

No, they are 4-2, they played Thursday night. And I will put a lot of money down saying they will make playoffs.

 

[mattjames2010]

As for would I trade for Peppers? He's 36 years old. Let's compare him this year to a guy we have

Julius Peppers 6'7 285 pounds. 2.5 sacks on the season, 6 tackles, 1 FF

David Irving 6'7 273 pounds. 1 sack, 5 tackles, 3 FF

No, I do not trade for Peppers who is in the twilight of his career. I watch Irving develop who is only 23.

 

[dogunwo]

No, they are 4-2, they played Thursday night. And I will put a lot of money down saying they will make playoffs.

You are right, they are 4-2, and I would take that bet

 

[haleyrules]

As for would I trade for Peppers? He's 36 years old. Let's compare him this year to a guy we have

Julius Peppers 6'7 285 pounds. 2.5 sacks on the season, 6 tackles, 1 FF

David Irving 6'7 273 pounds. 1 sack, 5 tackles, 3 FF

No, I do not trade for Peppers who is in the twilight of his career. I watch Irving develop who is only 23.

Irving looks like a good kid and the Cowboys got him for nothing!!

 

[Verdict]

Based on talent alone, probably, but I don't know their cap numbers, so it is hard to know if it would be s good deal for the Cowboys or not.