You Can’t Change Reality

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
85,576
Reaction score
77,824
Do you think Dak is a great QB that can lead this team to a SB? That Dak is in that upper crust of QBs, the handful that can win a SB in this league?

Because most here haven't suggested he's the worst QB or just flat out terrible. I haven't. The OP hasn't. visionary didn't. We all acknowledge that Dak is decent, maybe good. But is he great? Can he take a team on a long playoff run and win a SB?
I don’t think you have to be great to win a ring. If you are asking me do I think Dak is as good as Joe Flacco, Eli Manning or Nick Foles? Yes. Y’all are missing me with you need an elite QB. It’s falling on deaf ears because for the past 20 years I can’t even get to five elite QBs that have won rings. I can only get to Brees, Brady, Mahomes and Rodgers.
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
62,161
Reaction score
96,228
Wow man do you know what sarcasm is? Murray is a clown. A culture killer.

LOL? What? You keep mentioning Murray being a dog as some sort of rebuttal to the argument Dak isn't great.

But the kicker is I don't think Murray is all that good anyway so I am not sure how constantly bringing up Murray somehow proves your point here.
 

Whyjerry

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,885
Reaction score
27,360
You seem to think Dak and he are similar. You also seem to think Dak is on that top level that can win a SB.

I don't think either QB can do it. There is too much inconsistency in both their games and both often come up small in tough situations.
I think you are mental because you keep saying things I never said. Where EXACTLY did I bring up Cousins and used him as a comp for Dak? Where? You did that yet projected that on me. Really weird? Are you drunk?
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
62,161
Reaction score
96,228
I don’t think you have to be great to win a ring. If you are asking me do I think Dak is as good as Joe Flacco, Eli Manning or Nick Foles? Yes. Y’all are missing me with you need an elite QB. It’s falling on deaf ears because for the past 20 years I can’t even get to five elite QBs that have won rings. I can only get to Brees, Brady, Mahomes and Rodgers.

First of all, Manning is a two time SB MVP. Rip him all you want but he's on a different level than Dak.

Foles? Lightning in a bottle. So if basically your postseason success plan is just get lucky as **** like the Eagles, well then, I suspect you are going to be waiting a long time. Because for every Foles there are dozens of similar QBs who just fizzle out.
 

Whyjerry

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,885
Reaction score
27,360
LOL? What? You keep mentioning Murray being a dog as some sort of rebuttal to the argument Dak isn't great.

But the kicker is I don't think Murray is all that good anyway so I am not sure how constantly bringing up Murray somehow proves your point here.
Dude get some coffee. I was being sarcastic with Murray. Very sarcastic. Are you drunk or are you really this stupid?
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
62,161
Reaction score
96,228
I think you are mental because you keep saying things I never said. Where EXACTLY did I bring up Cousins and used him as a comp for Dak? Where? You did that yet projected that on me. Really weird? Are you drunk?

You said you could win with Cousins. You said you could win with Dak. Ergo, you seemingly think they are comps.

Let's make this simple. Who is the better QB? Dak or Cousins? Is either on a different level than the other, meaning is one noticeably better than the other?
 

CyberB0b

Village Idiot
Messages
12,746
Reaction score
14,281
Yeah he peaked a few years ago. He is what he is.

And unfortunately he's a cap anchor for the next few years. We are basically stuck in purgatory now for at least 2-3 years until it becomes cap friendly to think about cutting him.
The bad news is that it is hard to find a QB even at Wentz or Dak’s level.
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
62,161
Reaction score
96,228
Dude get some coffee. I was being sarcastic with Murray. Very sarcastic. Are you drunk or are you really this stupid?

Wait, do you think I believe you are saying Murray is a really good QB?
 

Whyjerry

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,885
Reaction score
27,360
You said you could win with Cousins. You said you could win with Dak. Ergo, you seemingly think they are comps.

Let's make this simple. Who is the better QB? Dak or Cousins? Is either on a different level than the other, meaning is one noticeably better than the other?

I would take Dak over Cousins. I am going to be very clear now because I think you might be in some mental distress…both players have their moments. Can win a game for you and go on nice runs. They ARE NOT consistent game changers. I think you could flip around QBs 8-16 and say the same about all of them.

Now I am not going to reply anymore tonight. My suggestion is for you to hydrate before bed and take a couple Advil.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
85,576
Reaction score
77,824
First of all, Manning is a two time SB MVP. Rip him all you want but he's on a different level than Dak.

Foles? Lightning in a bottle. So if basically your postseason success plan is just get lucky as **** like the Eagles, well then, I suspect you are going to be waiting a long time. Because for every Foles there are dozens of similar QBs who just fizzle out.
Foles,Stafford, Flacco…Eli was not that great. He had great stretches after stinking it up in the playoffs.
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
62,161
Reaction score
96,228
I would take Dak over Cousins. I am going to be very clear now because I think you might be in some mental distress…both players have their moments. Can win a game for you and go on nice runs. They ARE NOT consistent game changers. I think you could flip around QBs 8-16 and say the same about all of them.

Now I am not going to reply anymore tonight. My suggestion is for you to hydrate before bed and take a couple Advil.

And the odds of winning a SB with those guys in that 8-16ish range aren't all that great at this point. Hence my point I've made from the start. Dak is in that interchangeable range, ergo, I don't think you should expect that he can win big games for you and go on any sort of long playoff run. He's a good, not a great QB.

What's funny about this is after all your ramblings, you basically agree with me. Dak is good. He's not great.
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
62,161
Reaction score
96,228
Lol yall blame everything on Dak.

And you always blame everyone but Dak.

He wasn't great today. He didn't lose the game himself. He didn't win the game. He joined a list of disappointing performances today, especially many on the defensive side of the ball.
 

Zordon

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,404
Reaction score
47,241
I cannot believe some of you are STILL defending this scrub! It's been a year plus of inconsistent play from Dak. He had the ball in his hands at the end of the game and the start of OT and could not get a single point. He's Wentz with better PR.
 

CowboyFrog

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,684
Reaction score
11,618
This is the "I am here to jack with real Cowboys fans" thread...again why, 14 point lead and a "great" defenee doesnt allow a no name WR who is a huge dissapointment win a game..DQ has some questions to answer.
 

CowboyFrog

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,684
Reaction score
11,618
And you always blame everyone but Dak.

He wasn't great today. He didn't lose the game himself. He didn't win the game. He joined a list of disappointing performances today, especially many on the defensive side of the ball.


great post!! this is it
 

ICP

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,403
Reaction score
4,264
So..... You're saying they really suck, overrated, fools gold, poorly coached, undisciplined?
 

McKDaddy

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,160
Reaction score
10,962
Dude wilts far too often in big time moments. Rodgers, once again came through for his team. Really shows the difference between truly great, and mid tier.

I have said this for years. I don't put this loss solely on Dak by any means but it's just another game where he contributed to the loss more than he contributed to a win. If you have a limited ceiling, gotta play really clean football.
 
Top