You may be right.. When I have some time I will go look it up and post the numbers here.
Here is what the two men did inside the 10 yard line the last four seasons:
2020
Henry 35 carries 71 yards (2.1) 10 TD 13 first downs
Elliott 32 carries 39 yards (1.2) 5 TD 9 first downs
2021
Henry 17 carries 47 yards (2.8) 7 TD 9 first downs
Elliott 17 carries 25 yards (1.5) 7 TD 8 first downs
2022
Henry 17 carries 27 yards (1.6) 10 TD 10 first downs
Elliot 22 carries 53 yards (2.0) 11 TD 13 first downs
2023
Henry 24 carries 36 yards (1.5) 8 TD 8 first downs
Elliott 11 carries 28 yards (2.5) 3 TD 4 first downs
I believe for statistical purpose they count a touchdown also as a first down so this should not be read as first downs and touchdowns are separate. Because of the ambiguity in the accounting though I will focus though on TDs.
I think we can see that over the last three seasons it's a virtual dead heat. Elliott has scored on 21 of 50 totes from 10 and in for a healthy 42% success rate. Henry by comparison has scored on 25 of 58 carries for 43%. Ironically Henry's success rate WAS better in 2019 and 2020. He scored 20 TDs on 59 carries to 12 on 69 for Zeke. Although we should not forget that Zeke played 2020 suffering from Covid after-effects behind a line that was missing Tyron for most of the year, a rookie Steele at RT for most of the year, Connor (revolving door) Williams at LG and a rookie Biadasz at center. And just for fun throw in Zack Martin gimped for half the games. And if recall correctly we shut him down for the last 4 or 5.
Over the past two seasons they've gone back to about even.. Zeke at 42.4% (14/33) and Henry at 43.9% (18/41) .. Still the numbers don't lie. Over the past four seasons Henry would have to be given a slight edge over Zeke.