Williamsboys
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 1,261
- Reaction score
- 1,244
Where's the 8-8 chart??
Look, we've gone in circles talking about Dak and his abilities.I wonder how well Dak would've done?
We've seen Dak on some really good teams his first 4 years and has some luxuries that most NFL QB's aren't fortunate enough to have and he only has 1 playoff win to show for it.
Team accomplishments aside.. There is nothing special about him as a player on the field. He's not the reason we win or lose games.
He's a QB that is always stuck in neutral.
Defenses prioritize taking away Zeke. Sure they will look at film of what Dak likes to do but they know you shut down Zeke and its game over. Wentz is a different. He can beat teams without always using his running back. He will just throw to his TEs.Weird how Dak ran the offense while Pollatd was in just as effectively. They must game plan for Zeke while he's off the field.
Thinking teams game plan for Wentz and not Dak shows an extreme amount of ignorance.
I concede your point that Watson had better coaching and WR... And yet Dak has better stats as demonstrated by the OP. What is going to happen now that Dak has better coaching and a better WR? Lamb is a DeAndra Hopkins clone. You're a smart guy. You know the answer.
You like in your own little world.Defenses prioritize taking away Zeke. Sure they will look at film of what Dak likes to do but they know you shut down Zeke and its game over. Wentz is a different. He can beat teams without always using his running back. He will just throw to his TEs.
Look, we've gone in circles talking about Dak and his abilities.
Does Derek Carr's cap hit cripple the Raiders? Did it cripple the Raiders the previous years? What about Andy Dalton's cap hit with the Bengals? What current QB's cap hit is crippling their franchise right now? I can only think of Jared Goff at the top of my head.
The goal is to win a Superbowl.
Paying any QB a ton of money hurts your teams ability to win what matters.
There is a reason rookie contract QB's and vets on cheap deals keep winning titles.
Check out the RedZone stats. He’s not exactly elite there, completes about 50% of his passes.
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/2019/redzone-passing.htm
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/2018/redzone-passing.htm
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/2017/redzone-passing.htm
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/2016/redzone-passing.htm
The links you provided showed completion %'s of 52.5%, 50.75%, 55.35%, and 59.20%, and you are going to say that he completes "about 50%". Interesting way to word it, is there an agenda?
53-55% seems to be the average based off those tables, so he's in that average range. We need a big body receiving threat and thank god we got rid of Witten.
You like in your own little world.
Compare Dak last year to the rest of the NFC east QBs in the redzone. He is 3rd in the division.The links you provided showed completion %'s of 52.5%, 50.75%, 55.35%, and 59.20%, and you are going to say that he completes "about 50%". Interesting way to word it, is there an agenda?
53-55% seems to be the average based off those tables, so he's in that average range. We need a big body receiving threat and thank god we got rid of Witten.
Compare Dak last year to the rest of the NFC east QBs in the redzone. He is 3rd in the division.
I was averaging the inside 20 and inside 10 columns which is around 50%.
That's not how you find redzone %
ok inside the 20 he’s around 55%
Inside the 10 he’s below 50%
Want exact?
2019- 20 yd- 52%. 10 yd- 48%
2018- 51%. &. 50%
2017- 55%. & 46%
2016- 59%. &. 48%
Right, so your intent on pulling those numbers was what? When you say "not exactly elite" you're hinting at it being negative, despite those not being bad at all.
You aren't replying to a thread that is claiming Dak is elite, so that's a weird response, but to play along how are Mahomes and Russell Wilson elite if they're below average in the most important part of the field?Just a counterpoint to all the Dak is elite stats thrown around.
He’s average in the redzone. So how is he elite if he’s only average in the most important part of the field?
Dak should have better numbers, he has a better offense around him than those other QB's.
That's not how you find redzone %