Which player in NFL history would you draft No. 1?

[Whirlwin]

They remind me a little of one another. Obviously Mahomes has freakish athletic ability that Young could never touch and there's very little similarity on the hoof. I think they were equally difficult players to defend though.

I don’t know what I’m missing. I just think the kid is overrated for so many reasons. I guess I’m just used to watching great football from the 70s. I don’t call what they play today Football. I understand the safety reasons but. I don’t think he would’ve survived the season

 

[GenoT]

Tom Brady...and it isn’t even close.

 

[JIMMYBUFFETT]

I don’t know what I’m missing. I just think the kid is overrated for so many reasons. I guess I’m just used to watching great football from the 70s. I don’t call what they play today Football. I understand the safety reasons but. I don’t think he would’ve survived the season

You don't need to talk me into it...I picked Steve Young .

 

[bodi]

Montana

 

[Whirlwin]

You don't need to talk me into it...I picked Steve Young .

I’m just not a fan of Patrick. People think I’m out of my mind but. 60 years of football I’ve seen so much better than him. I’m not just going to settle. I guess he’s the future and I don’t know any better. But I’ll take young every day of the week

 

[cern]

The GOAT, tom brady.

 

[Az Lurker]

I'm not sure any player single handedly dominated like Jim Brown did

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

After what I saw Mahomes do last year Super Bowl . I just don’t think he’s as great as most people think he is. Yeah I know I get ridiculed for it but I really believe it. But only time is going to tell. I’m with Terry Bradshaw I think he’s overrated. Mahomes has already missed games. He’s not a Steve Young

I think he was never the same after the injury. He struggled at times last year that’s for sure.

 

[Whirlwin]

I think he was never the same after the injury. He struggled at times last year that’s for sure.

I get slammed for it, but I appreciate the honesty. I think he was the worst quarterback I’ve ever seen in the Super Bowl last year. And I thought Peyton Manning was bad when he played for Denver. But I get why people like him

 

[CooterBrown]

Wow what an off season. Next someone will start a thread asking what color shoes is the best for a QB. To make this thread even more funny is not one has mentioned any players prior to the 90's. I'm not say this is mine but forgetting about players from prior to the 90's how about a 13th round draft choice that ended up leading his team to be the only team ever to win THREE NFL championship in a row, Bart Starr, or how about a RB that led the league in rushing every year he played, Jim Brown or anither RB that was the all time leading rusher until Emmitt broke his record, Gale Sayers.
.
.

wrong Bear. I'm sure you meant Walter Payton.

 

[Whirlwin]

wrong Bear. I'm sure you meant Walter Payton.

Sweetness. Is my second best all-time player

 

[Whirlwin]

Wow what an off season. Next someone will start a thread asking what color shoes is the best for a QB. To make this thread even more funny is not one has mentioned any players prior to the 90's. I'm not say this is mine but forgetting about players from prior to the 90's how about a 13th round draft choice that ended up leading his team to be the only team ever to win THREE NFL championship in a row, Bart Starr, or how about a RB that led the league in rushing every year he played, Jim Brown or anither RB that was the all time leading rusher until Emmitt broke his record, Gale Sayers.
.
.

I don’t think many people here know what football is. I totally agree with you.

 

[Etchyboy]

My only question here is.....how much Brady wins w/o Belichick or Montana w/o Rice or Walsh?

Umm Could be said what Belichick record would have been without Brady? Remember he got fired from the Browns.

 

[glimmerman]

Sweetness. Is my second best all-time player

What ever.. you want mahomes so bad. Lmao

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

I get slammed for it, but I appreciate the honesty. I think he was the worst quarterback I’ve ever seen in the Super Bowl last year. And I thought Peyton Manning was bad when he played for Denver. But I get why people like him

Oh now wait man Ben Rothlisberger had a bad one too. Peyton was real bad too.

I like Mahomes. I'm not one of these guys that are on this site that thinks he's the best thing since sliced bread. I Think he's flawed too. But last year was his 2nd year as a starter. In that Super Bowl IMO, his defense bailed him out. And in that Texans game.

 

[WillieBeamen]

Tom Brady is the only acceptable answer

 

[12+88=7]

Wow what an off season. Next someone will start a thread asking what color shoes is the best for a QB. To make this thread even more funny is not one has mentioned any players prior to the 90's. I'm not say this is mine but forgetting about players from prior to the 90's how about a 13th round draft choice that ended up leading his team to be the only team ever to win THREE NFL championship in a row, Bart Starr, or how about a RB that led the league in rushing every year he played, Jim Brown or anither RB that was the all time leading rusher until Emmitt broke his record, Gale Sayers.
.
.

This is almost like a fantasy draft. You can get QBs and RBs later.

I went with DE because on defense that's the number one position to fill. If I hadn't gone Reggie White, I would have gone Bruce Smith or my player from the past, Deacon Jones.

Need to get to the QB so choose the best three all time from that position.

 

[Whirlwin]

What ever.. you want mahomes so bad. Lmao

I don’t understand the comment. Walter Payton. The guy was nothing but class.I wouldn’t take them first or second overall. But that wasn’t my point. How do you not like sweetness

 

[Whirlwin]

Oh now wait man Ben Rothlisberger had a bad one too. Peyton was real bad too.

I like Mahomes. I'm not one of these guys that are on this site that thinks he's the best thing since sliced bread. I Think he's flawed too. But last year was his 2nd year as a starter. In that Super Bowl IMO, his defense bailed him out. And in that Texans game.

I think that’s what I was saying.

 

[Whirlwin]

Tom Brady is the only acceptable answer

I don’t know I’d like starting with defense. I’m staying with Charles Haley my cowboy brother