Dak has ruined this team

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,888
Reaction score
10,005
I didn't necessarily disagree with the contract amounts...the question of fair or not fair is for fans to argue (as we are).....the big part you missed was about the years in the contract. it wasn't about the dollars. Dak wanted a shorter contract (4 years) and Jerry wanted a longer contract (6 years). that's where the negotiations fell apart. so it got delayed and the price went up as it always does in NFL as time goes by.

you keep ignoring that fact...

and as I said, Jerry could have walked away or accept what Dak had wanted in a shorter contract, which in hind sight might have been better because he could get out of the contract sooner.

it doesn't matter. this mess is not Dak's fault. he is what he is. Jerry runs this team. he signs the players. he oversees the draft. he oversees FA. his is solely responsible for the mess that's Dallas.
Dallas is a mess? we have been very competitive for some time now... just not good enough to get to the big game. Our current roster is not a mess. Our qb is not a mess, our cap situation is not a mess.... team is in good shape, regardless of what all the bitter people think.
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
31,832
Reaction score
18,069
Jerry should have let Dak walk. He got great value on the first contract, got lucky, Gave away the ranch on the second, dumb move.

I'm curious. And done what? Give me real solutions. NOT signed Brady,NOT signed Rogers Real solutions that were available to him.
that sums it up. why do we have trouble understanding and evaluating our own players? we drafted a RB 4th over all. that's dumb where RBs are dime a dozen and high impact players their rookie year. well, then we went ahead and handed him a second contract, making him the highest paid RB in the league history, with two years left on the contract, after having seen what happened to Gurley and the rams. we handed Lawrence (now a second time) a gauranteed contract for one good year out of 4 years. he is costing us about 4M/sack. we paid Cooper and made him highest paid WR in the league. now, I like cooper. I think he is a good WR, but he is not top 15. so why make him highest paid.

Jerry plays fantasy football and its been the demise of this team.
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
31,832
Reaction score
18,069
every team tries to land the qb. It isnt easy and it is mostly luck IMO. The Dolphins have been trying since Marino. The Browns have been trying since kosar. The chargers have been trying since Fouts(thye finally got their guy... again LUCK)
Bengals had been trying since kenny Anderson, finally got their guy. Teams hit gold and then struggle the second that qb retires. Want proof... watch what is happening in Steeler land and Saints world. So much so Sean Peyton said im outta this place!
oh, I 100% agree. everyone keeps screaming about contract value contract value and they point to Ravens and couple of other teams having won it with average QBs, not seeing the fact those teams had several other stars and great defenses and those players cost a lot of money. the easiest and cheapest (despite contract values) path to a superbowl is via a franchise QB and that's why QBs are over paid and every team over drafts QBs hoping to hit on one. just see Cinci and Rams winning the superbowl.
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
31,832
Reaction score
18,069
Dallas is a mess? we have been very competitive for some time now... just not good enough to get to the big game. Our current roster is not a mess. Our qb is not a mess, our cap situation is not a mess.... team is in good shape, regardless of what all the bitter people think.
well, you are correct in some sense. we are semi-competitive, just not a good enough team to make a run in the playoffs.
 

Redline360

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,446
Reaction score
4,772
Problem is the owners. From top to bottom.

Ridiculous contracts to Jaylon, zeke, Tank, dak, coop, and etc. Dumpster diving FA , hiring and keeping incompetent coaches way to long. Lack of building a competitive defense for to long

Paying elite money for a quarterback who's coming off a huge injury and barely cracks the top 10 was just another shot to the head after the zeke contract. Double tap to mame sure were dead
 

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,888
Reaction score
10,005
oh, I 100% agree. everyone keeps screaming about contract value contract value and they point to Ravens and couple of other teams having won it with average QBs, not seeing the fact those teams had several other stars and great defenses and those players cost a lot of money. the easiest and cheapest (despite contract values) path to a superbowl is via a franchise QB and that's why QBs are over paid and every team over drafts QBs hoping to hit on one. just see Cinci and Rams winning the superbowl.

yea, they use Flacco as their example.... but lets leave out the fact Flacco had one of the greatest defenses in the history of the NFL.
 

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,888
Reaction score
10,005
well, you are correct in some sense. we are semi-competitive, just not a good enough team to make a run in the playoffs.

IM curious... were the Bucs good enough to make a run last year? Were the Chiefs good enough to make a run? Were the Packers good enough? Were the Niners? Apparently not, they failed to make it to the Super Bowl... so were those teams failures? A mess? horrible coaches? Bad front offices?
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
31,832
Reaction score
18,069
IM curious... were the Bucs good enough to make a run last year? Were the Chiefs good enough to make a run? Were the Packers good enough? Were the Niners? Apparently not, they failed to make it to the Super Bowl... so were those teams failures? A mess? horrible coaches? Bad front offices?
they all have made a "run" obviously only one team makes it to the superbowl...but Buc won it the year before...we didn't even get to the playoffs. GB made it to the CCG, we couldn't come close. chiefs have shown ability to make it and win it. we haven't...

so taking a single year as proof of anything is meaningless, but look at the past 5 years and every one of those teams has had the ability to make a run...we tend to just lose in the first round. well, I am sure you will bring up 2018....if you want to call that a run, then fine. your choice
 

TwentyOne

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,842
Reaction score
4,463
Think about all that we’ve given up for this teams buy in with him

-cap hell for the next decade

-losing out on good players and free agents

-he’s about to get his second coach fired next year

-the 2016 decision to go with him over Romo leading to a first round exit

-squandering the best cowboys team in 20 years with another first round exit due to poor qb play

-cutting or trading players who don’t get along with Dak or we just can’t simply afford them anymore


Think about the following qb option we had the last 2 years

1. Tom Brady
2. Aaron Rodgers
3. Russell Wilson
4. Dashaun Watson
5. Matt Stafford


And Dak makes more money than all of them. I know this isn’t all predicated on Dak but it’s kind of hard not to feel that we’ve been cheated out of something since we signed him to this ridiculous deal

I dont think Dak is the one to blame to be ruining this team. The blame has to go to the front office: JJ and his sun.

Dak is just a negative byproduct of the people who make decissions.
 

Loso86

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,680
Reaction score
3,862
I wonder if all of you guys remeber trying to find a capable WB after aikman until Romo...l
LET...IT...GO! Lol I hope he leaves and we end up with a jag at the WB spot making 30 mil because that's where the league is headed. So have fun with the Wentz, and Cousins and so ons
 

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,888
Reaction score
10,005
they all have made a "run" obviously only one team makes it to the superbowl...but Buc won it the year before...we didn't even get to the playoffs. GB made it to the CCG, we couldn't come close. chiefs have shown ability to make it and win it. we haven't...

so taking a single year as proof of anything is meaningless, but look at the past 5 years and every one of those teams has had the ability to make a run...we tend to just lose in the first round. well, I am sure you will bring up 2018....if you want to call that a run, then fine. your choice

it is what it is... we havent gone far. The difference between winning and losing is razor thin, and that was never more evident than this years playoffs.
 

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,888
Reaction score
10,005
they also won with Banks and Dilfer
Banks???? you are gonna have to clue me in on what year that was.

They won with Dilfer?? hmm, what year was that , let me see.The Ravens 2000 defense is possibly the greatest defense in NFL history. They allowed 3,10,7, and 3 points in their 4 playoffs game. Dont talk to me about Trent Dilfer.
 

Vtwin

Safety third
Messages
8,183
Reaction score
11,172
well you just hell bent on proving that the current state of the team is dak's fault.

I never said lowballed him, I just said the offer was lower than what he was willing to accept. FACT. undeniable fact. the two sides didn't come to agreement and they walked away. FACT, undeniable fact.

so this low ball stuff is your line of thinking, as it is obviously your premise that he is greedy and that low balling non-sense is part of the logic you are trying to insist to prove Dak is greedy. all I said and its a fact that the offer was lower than he was willing to accept and that they could have had him for cheaper if they would have been willing to meet the demands back then than compared to what he eventually got (FACT, undeniable fact). the fact that Jones' walked away not willing to pay an additional couple of millions or so....its called a negotiation....at any point the parties can simply walk away (i.e. see Randy gregory)

i the negotiation sticking point was the length of the contract second time around. its well documented in the media and subsequently they agreed to a much higher contract value with longer length...if you want to say the media is not the proof of anything and show me where that's the case...then I am going to ask you show me as there is no proof outside of what was reported by the media in either case.

and it wasn't a 4, vs. 5, it was a 4 vs. 6 years and the reason behind it as reported by the media was to hit FA after 2023 when the cap goes up significantly.....that's why goff, Wentz and Wilson signed extensions and their teams willing to do so, as they all become FA in 2023 or 2024 (they all bet on themzelves just like Dak), with the expected raise in the cap, expecting salaries to go up significanty would give them opportunity to negotiate a much higher contract.

and Dak played hardball.. ok, lets assume he did....SO WHAT? he is within his negotiating rights to ask for $80M/ year as I said before....if that's what he thinks he can get. now, fans would balk and argue about contract value, etc.....but us fans opinions has absolutely zero bearing on anything other than our emotional investment and opinions in ranking players based on contract value (how many times did we hear he is second highest paid and should play at second highest level, but I guess now our expectations are lower because he is now the 4th highest paid which is what I mentioned back then too....).

facts.....Jones could have walked away. facts he didn't. you blame Dak for that. which is because of your anger and hatred towards Dak and your emotional investment in all of this.

Dak didn't sign himself to a contract. it takes two. a player will ask for as much as he thinks he can get. Gregory could have asked for 20M. would he get it? Clowney was reported to be wanting upwards of 20-22M/year for his contract. he didn't get it. he was on a one year deal with Cleveland.

once you put your emotions and anger and hatred away and look at this purely in a business perspective you will clearly see, its not about greed and what anyone owes anybody....its a business negotiation of what I think my services are worth (based on my own opinion) and what the other side is willing to pay and thinks I am worth... I have been in similar situations and demanded a much higher dollar rate and the contracting agency walked away and weren't willing to do it.....see, they walked away. I have been able to get similar rates in the past from other contracting agencies. see, they didn't walk away. its not greed. its business. purely and simply, nothing but.
You sir, are a real piece of work.

I made it clear that an assignment of "fault" was not even in my mind. I made it crystal clear numerous times with bolded and italics to make it crystal clear what I was saying. Yet you open your latest diatribe with "well you just hell bent on proving that the current state of the team is dak's fault.". LOL... I guess I should try using colors to reach you.

You are literally arguing with yourself here. Most of this gibberish has nothing to do with anything I have said. I get it though. When you get owned so thoroughly,,, ya got to do what ya got to do, amirite??

Let's review.
You said Dak could have been signed in 2018 for 24ish proving that you don't what you are talking about since that is by rule, not even possible. Big hit to your credibility right there.

Now you provide your latest gem. That it was 4 vs 6. Wrong and easily verifiable. Another direct hit on your credibility. Apparently you couldn't answer my challenge and produce one example of a franchise QB contract being only four years overall.

The best one yet though.... You actually said "and subsequently they agreed to a much higher contract value with longer length." Credibility gone. Do yourself a favor and take a second to refresh yourself on the facts. Specifically the length. There was nothing "longer" about it.

I realize that this is a waste of my time as you are going to do what you always do and twist my words into something I didn't say and then argue against arguments I never made in order to serve your seemingly massive ego.

There are two types of people in the world. Those that want to BE right and those that want to get it right.

I'll finish by doing something I do after a difficult training session with a dog. No matter how difficult it was I always make sure to end on a positive note by asking for something we've already gotten down so we can end on a successful note, with treats and praise, in order give us the best chance for success the next time we go to work.

So in that vein.... I ask you.... can we agree that today is Wednesday?

(SIts back and waits for an explanation about time zones and the Earths rotation and that it might not be Wednesday on the other side of the planet.....)
 

Slick

Well-Known Member
Messages
875
Reaction score
734
Dallas is a mess? we have been very competitive for some time now... just not good enough to get to the big game. Our current roster is not a mess. Our qb is not a mess, our cap situation is not a mess.... team is in good shape, regardless of what all the bitter people think.
Which team have you been watching? This team is a disaster.
yea, they use Flacco as their example.... but lets leave out the fact Flacco had one of the greatest defenses in the history of the NFL.
Which is why Dak’s money should have went to the defense.
 

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,888
Reaction score
10,005
Which team have you been watching? This team is a disaster.

Which is why Dak’s money should have went to the defense.
how many 2000 ravens defenses have there been? You are a fool if you thnk you can just spend and draft a 2000 ravens defense. If it were so simple, all teams would do it.
 

Reid1boys

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,888
Reaction score
10,005
Which team have you been watching? This team is a disaster.

Which is why Dak’s money should have went to the defense.
dumb packers should have offered rodgers 20 million per and spent some money on defense. Should have offered adams 3 years 22 million with 3 million signing bonus.

Get the defense/...
 

Vtwin

Safety third
Messages
8,183
Reaction score
11,172
Banks???? you are gonna have to clue me in on what year that was.

They won with Dilfer?? hmm, what year was that , let me see.The Ravens 2000 defense is possibly the greatest defense in NFL history. They allowed 3,10,7, and 3 points in their 4 playoffs game. Dont talk to me about Trent Dilfer.
Banks started 8 games in that SB run so technically he is right, kinda, sorta.
 
Top