Who besides the Cowboys have a Top 5 QB, Receiver, and Defensive star?

fivetwos

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,527
Reaction score
26,513
Personnel isn’t a problem in Dallas and hasn’t been for a while.

It’s subpar coaching and the absolute worst of breaks repeatedly in the biggest of spots.

Jerry said if he got SB30, he would never ask for another.

Make your own judgement.
 

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind
Messages
57,633
Reaction score
35,578
That doesn’t make him a top five QB. It’s silly to even suggest it, we all know Dak has looked horrible this year at times as well so which is he? If he plays well and beats the Seahawks and Eagles coming up at home I’ll give him his props until then I ain’t buying any of this nonsense.
It’s not silly to suggest it. He’s only had two bad games this season. Some who get paid to talk football have mentioned him in the MVP conversation. You should be giving him some props now, but you’re a hater. He’s playing outstanding football.
 

Nav22

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,844
Reaction score
17,018
That doesn’t make him a top five QB. It’s silly to even suggest it, we all know Dak has looked horrible this year at times as well so which is he? If he plays well and beats the Seahawks and Eagles coming up at home I’ll give him his props until then I ain’t buying any of this nonsense.
Good thing nobody on Earth cares what you think.

Dak was 3rd in the NFL in Total QBR entering this week.

If you can't see that he's been balling, that's on you and your lack of a football IQ.
:laugh: :laugh: :laugh:
 

SDCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,564
Reaction score
22,484
That doesn’t make him a top five QB. It’s silly to even suggest it, we all know Dak has looked horrible this year at times as well so which is he? If he plays well and beats the Seahawks and Eagles coming up at home I’ll give him his props until then I ain’t buying any of this nonsense.
Bruh, he has absolutely been a top 5 QB. cut the crap.
 

CowboysLakerBamaFan

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,298
Reaction score
3,126
Who’s their defensive star? It will be Jalen Carter at some point but I won’t say it now.

Kelce Jones and Mahomes for sure…
Well ....Hassan Redick was like 4th place for defensive MVP last year....

Is he a Top 5 defensive player? Personally I don't think so this year (though since getting cast off he's on a tear again) but I think whatever stretch needs to be made to get Reddick in that list , an equal stretch would be needed to squeeeeeze Dak into that list.... but let's see how he does now that he'll be facing actual NFL talent again after 2 nothing teams.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
76,465
Reaction score
70,736
Well ....Hassan Redick was like 4th place for defensive MVP last year....

Is he a Top 5 defensive player? Personally I don't think so this year (though since getting cast off he's on a tear again) but I think whatever stretch needs to be made to get Reddick in that list , an equal stretch would be needed to squeeeeeze Dak into that list.... but let's see how he does now that he'll be facing actual NFL talent again after 2 nothing teams.
That's your opinion. Dak right now is playing top 5. Hassan Reddick.....Top 5 edge rusher? Maybe? Top 5 defensive player? No. Micah, TJ Watt, Myles Garrett.....hell he's not even playing better than Daron Bland right now. Hell I'm not even suer if Micah is.
 

mcmvp

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,207
Reaction score
2,123
Dak, Lamb, Parsons

Who besides the Cowboys have a Top 5 QB, Receiver, and Defensive star?​

Who besides the Cowboys can say they’ve played 7 of 11 games against teams that will pick in the top 10 of next year’s draft?

I will say the Cowboys do know how to kick the crap out of these opponents like nobody else… Hats off to them for that…
 

Yobwocs

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,793
Reaction score
3,942
Who besides the Cowboys can say they’ve played 7 of 11 games against teams that will pick in the top 10 of next year’s draft?

I will say the Cowboys do know how to kick the crap out of these opponents like nobody else… Hats off to them for that…
Last year Eagles schedule was weak and all we heard was that they play the teams on their schedule
 

NFCBeasts

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,150
Reaction score
1,361
That's your opinion. Dak right now is playing top 5. Hassan Reddick.....Top 5 edge rusher? Maybe? Top 5 defensive player? No. Micah, TJ Watt, Myles Garrett.....hell he's not even playing better than Daron Bland right now. Hell I'm not even suer if Micah is.
Don’t entertain the Eagles fan …… my new strategy is if we ignore him he will go troll commanders zone
 

mcmvp

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,207
Reaction score
2,123
Last year Eagles schedule was weak and all we heard was that they play the teams on their schedule
You do not see the difference, do you? The Eagles used that schedule to get the #1 seed.

How are the Cowboys using theirs?
 

CowboysLakerBamaFan

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,298
Reaction score
3,126
That's your opinion. Dak right now is playing top 5. Hassan Reddick.....Top 5 edge rusher? Maybe? Top 5 defensive player? No. Micah, TJ Watt, Myles Garrett.....hell he's not even playing better than Daron Bland right now. Hell I'm not even suer if Micah is.
If we're talking like RIGHT NOW (as in focusing on last 3 or 4 weeks)....then I agree w/ you.

If we're talking "Top 5" based on who we think the actual best players are...based everything we know about the player, including multiple seasons, and how we think the year ends....then I'll stick to my original statement.

Nevertheless....this whole thing is opinion-based. And none of it matters a hill of beans till February
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
76,465
Reaction score
70,736
If we're talking like RIGHT NOW (as in focusing on last 3 or 4 weeks)....then I agree w/ you.

If we're talking "Top 5" based on who we think the actual best players are...based everything we know about the player, including multiple seasons, and how we think the year ends....then I'll stick to my original statement.

Nevertheless....this whole thing is opinion-based. And none of it matters a hill of beans till February
I was under the impression we are talking right now. Sure it's cherry picking. Last 4 games benefit us in the discussion.
 
Top