Mike McCarthy = Bill Belichick

[bigdsgirl]

For all Cowboy fans wanting Bill for HC should be buyer beware! Bill had Tom Brady all those years and when Brady left he didn't do so well. Mike also had Rodgers..as soon as he left the same results as Belichick..These quarterbacks made the coaches look genius. Dak Prescott is not even in same league as those quarterbacks!

 

[Bagman]

Not even in the same universe. Belichick's attention to detail at every level of a football team is incredible. Belichick would make a lot of things better for this team

 

[Hawkeye0202]

For all Cowboy fans wanting Bill for HC should be buyer beware! Bill had Tom Brady all those years and when Brady left he didn't do so well. Mike also had Rodgers..as soon as he left the same results as Belichick..These quarterbacks made the coaches look genius. Dak Prescott is not even in same league as those quarterbacks!

 

[Wilson]

Not a good comparison. With that said, I don't want another aging coach. We need younger, but not so young that he's learning on the job—someone with proven and successful experience. I don't care if he's from the Cowboy's organizational tree. Come to think of it, how about we go outside the withering tree?

 

[Tabascocat]

BB is a defense specialist, Mike specializes in nothing. One has standards, the other doesn’t.

 

[kskboys]

Officially nominated for Most Inane Thread of the Year.

 

[darthseinfeld]

BB is a defense specialist, Mike specializes in nothing. One has standards, the other doesn’t.

McCarthy was a very good OC before becoming a HC

 

[darthseinfeld]

Officially nominated for Most Inane Thread of the Year.

I still favor Jason Witten for OC

 

[diamonddelts]

Belichick would make a lot of things better for this team

Except the win loss record.

 

[cavemanct]

My God they will never co exist.

 

[Tabascocat]

McCarthy was a very good OC before becoming a HC

Was is the keyword there, his offense is stale and outdated now.

 

[diamonddelts]

She is right.

 

[montgod]

Not a good comparison. With that said, I don't want another aging coach. We need younger, but not so young that he's learning on the job—someone with proven and successful experience. I don't care if he's from the Cowboy's organizational tree. Come to think of it, how about we go outside the withering tree?

Why would any young coach go to the Boys knowing they can't even start the players they want to start? Not going to happen imo. Jerry needs coaches who are desperate for a job who will be Yes men. McCarthy was perfect for that. Belichick fits the same mold and he'll probably accept just to get closer to the record and sacrifice his usual power of all role. I'm sure he'll also bring along Josh McDaniel to relive the magic on the offensive side

 

[montgod]

BB is a defense specialist, Mike specializes in nothing. One has standards, the other doesn’t.

If he was brought on, I'd guess he'd try to bring his old buddy Josh McDaniel to run the O side of the ball...

 

[darthseinfeld]

Was is the keyword there, his offense is stale and outdated now.

Your statement was that McCarthy specializes in nothing. McCarthy is an offensive specialist. His offense being stale doesn't change the specialty of offense. It just means the game has passed him by

 

[Tabascocat]

Your statement was that McCarthy specializes in nothing. McCarthy is an offensive specialist. His offense being stale doesn't change the specialty of offense. It just means the game has passed him by

Which in turn means he specializes in nothing now

 

[Coogiguy03]

For all Cowboy fans wanting Bill for HC should be buyer beware! Bill had Tom Brady all those years and when Brady left he didn't do so well. Mike also had Rodgers..as soon as he left the same results as Belichick..These quarterbacks made the coaches look genius. Dak Prescott is not even in same league as those quarterbacks!

Bill never had a DAK, never had a DAK

 

[JBS]

Close your account. Stop watching football. Give something else a try

 

[JayFord]

Bill ain’t coming here because Bill is a GM/HC there’s no other way around that he NEEDS power and authority

Only person Jerry would concede power to is Deion Sanders

 

[quickccc]

Not a good comparison. With that said, I don't want another aging coach. We need younger, but not so young that he's learning on the job—someone with proven and successful experience. I don't care if he's from the Cowboy's organizational tree. Come to think of it, how about we go outside the withering tree?

You have to gamble on the hot, young upcoming asst.coach that you greatly feel will be a successful HC.

Young ex-coordinators learn on the job...McVey, Lafleur, Demarco Ryan, Dan Campbell...and Ben Johnson will be in the same mix very soon.

But we have to help give the them the player personnel support they will sorely need...
Lions have done that...on both sides ofthe ball..

Do we the Cowboys have the ability to deliver the needed player personnel support cast for a young HC ..??

Or will we so ever continue the Moneyball approach..??