The Garrett bashing is trite, tired, and lacking in truth

[PAINFROMUKRAINE]

Personally, I feel dubbed by Jerry in terms of our HC. He is trying to sell us the second coming of Sean Payton and yet we have the second coming of Wayne Fontes (the HC of the Lions in the 1990s). Garrett has not progressed in any manner at all in terms of the HC Position. His game day management is below average still after 4 years. He seems to not truly understanding the game during the most crucial moments.

 

[Eddie]

We have more injured players than we do healthy ones. What do we really expect?

My only issue is not having a replacement ready for Romo. If we don't have one this coming draft, then we deserve our fate.

 

[RunDMC]

And so far we half seen no winning, just escuses for his 8-8 seasons and near-playoffs and near wins in playoffs.
There come a time when we in the sewing circle just half to look up and say whaaa?

So much fail with this post. First of all Dallas won the division last year and were an asinine overturn of a catch from going to the NFC Championship despite some severe limitations on the defensive side.

The three eight and eight seasons if you look at that team outside of Romo, Witten, and Dez they were a below average football team. Garrett's ability to rally his troops, get a message across, and the individual talent of those guys is what made us competitive each year. They pretty much perennially had one of the worst offensive lines in the league until 2013 when they drafted Travis Frederick. The defense only had two impact players. DeMarcus Ware who clearly wasn't himself after his neck injury in 2009 and Sean Lee who hasn't been able to play a full season.

This season we've lost two of the best football players on the planet. You can't win without two superstar players that are as valuable as Romo and Dez are not to mention a decimated defensive line. They just don't have the horses hell the bodies to be able to play for four quarters.

 

[windward]

I did not know Garrett's mom posted on this board

Welcome

This is one of the more tired responses that could be included in the OP.

Considering the source, it's hardly surprising.

 

[erod]

Bellichick had winning seasons with a backup QBs playing big chunk of the season.

heres my question. A lot of people didnt like Phillips, what is the difference between Garrett and Phillips right now?

Phillips is like Switzer, riding the work of the previous guy and dragging it into the gutter over time.

Garrett is more like Landry or Jimmy (maybe) because he's building the roster through youth.

 

[SultanOfSix]

And if I chop off your arms and legs...it would be just your excuse why you didn't get your work done today.

That's a terribly inapplicable analogy with reference to what I stated.

 

[visionary]

So Garrett is not to blame when the team is playing poorly

So we should not give him credit when the team does well?

That is good to know

 

[Doomsday101]

So Garrett is not to blame when the team is playing poorly

So we should not give him credit when the team does well?

That is good to know

It all falls to the HC, comes with the job, good and bad wins and loses.

 

[Bleu Star]

So Garrett is not to blame when the team is playing poorly

So we should not give him credit when the team does well?

That is good to know

Funny how that works huh... lol

 

[CATCH17]

We have more injured players than we do healthy ones. What do we really expect?

My only issue is not having a replacement ready for Romo. If we don't have one this coming draft, then we deserve our fate.

I thought we could get a 3-5 record without Romo.

I had no idea that we were this Romo dependent. I knew he made us a juggernaut but had no idea he basically masks several shortcomings.

 

[Frosty]

Phillips is like Switzer, riding the work of the previous guy and dragging it into the gutter over time.

Garrett is more like Landry or Jimmy (maybe) because he's building the roster through youth.

Did you ACTUALLY Just compare Jason Garrett to Tom Landry and Jimmy Johnson......talking about going over the top....lost all respect for this thread with that comment. ...... who spiked your Kool Aid

One winning season and you compare this guy to Super Bowl Champion HOF coaches......WOW

 

[noshame]

If the Giants coaching staff hadn't had a epic meltdown and we were 1-3 right now would you all feel the same way?

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

So much fail with this post. First of all Dallas won the division last year and were an asinine overturn of a catch from going to the NFC Championship despite some severe limitations on the defensive side.

The three eight and eight seasons if you look at that team outside of Romo, Witten, and Dez they were a below average football team. Garrett's ability to rally his troops, get a message across, and the individual talent of those guys is what made us competitive each year. They pretty much perennially had one of the worst offensive lines in the league until 2013 when they drafted Travis Frederick. The defense only had two impact players. DeMarcus Ware who clearly wasn't himself after his neck injury in 2009 and Sean Lee who hasn't been able to play a full season.

This season we've lost two of the best football players on the planet. You can't win without two superstar players that are as valuable as Romo and Dez are not to mention a decimated defensive line. They just don't have the horses hell the bodies to be able to play for four quarters.

There be so much "could half, should half" "we wuz robbed" "look at last year" that I quickly lost interest.

Yes, unbelievably injuries happen. They happen to others too. And in pairs. Others seem to reload. We on the other hand seem to bring in journeymens who don't fill the chamber.


as to Garrett rallying the troops, I half never thought of Garrett as a rallyer, as a motivator, simply as a bus operator who says his underachiefers are passionate, half a strong work ethic and try to do too much. That is not rallying, that is enabling the underachiefers.

Only THREE 8-8 seasons? I was worried it was four or more. This is a team with a few superstars and lots of journeymens. It is scary how we go from Romo, Dez and Witten to the Randles, Churches and Mincys. Gift me 22 solid players any day over 3 superstars and 19 journeymens.

As to the defense, I want to hear more about the impact players but all I likely will here is crickets and I don't means Buddy's band.

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

Did you ACTUALLY Just compare Jason Garrett to Tom Landry and Jimmy Johnson......talking about going over the top....lost all respect for this thread with that comment. ...... who spiked your Kool Aid

One winning season and you compare this guy to Super Bowl Champion HOF coaches......WOW

I just hate it when you make too mush sense. But I was left speechless (such as it is) by the Garrett to Landry/Jimma comparison. I am sure he meant in his demeanor, but Landry must be spinning in his grave and Jimma might be halfing another drink aboard his yacht and yukking it up about the comparison.

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

So Garrett is not to blame when the team is playing poorly

So we should not give him credit when the team does well?

That is good to know

I would like a coach that coaches in such a way that he gives us an edge... Any edge.

He doesn't. Regrettably, that's true.

 

[Bleu Star]

I thought we could get a 3-5 record without Romo.

I had no idea that we were this Romo dependent. I knew he made us a juggernaut but had no idea he basically masks several shortcomings.

Yet we still have no "Romo Succession Plan" in place....

 

[CATCH17]

Yet we still have no "Romo Succession Plan" in place....

The odds of us getting another QB like him are not good.

Lets say in the last couple of drafts that we had a Manziel, Bridgewater, Winston, or MArriotta.. Does anyone feel like we have a bright future with any of those guys? Especially with Captain predictable Jason Garrett as their coach?

We are screwed once Romo leaves because I doubt Jerry or Stephen would ever get rid of Jason.

 

[Doomsday101]

The odds of us getting another QB like him are not good.

Lets say in the last couple of drafts that we had a Manziel, Bridgewater, Winston, or MArriotta.. Does anyone feel like we have a bright future with any of those guys? Especially with Captain predictable Jason Garrett as their coach?

We are screwed once Romo leaves because I doubt Jerry or Stephen would ever get rid of Jason.

Based on your own view no doubt you believe that.

 

[CATCH17]

I would like a coach that coaches in such a way that he gives us an edge... Any edge.

He doesn't. Regrettably, that's true.

And it's so obvious..

You have to be a Garrett homer or just don't think coaching matters and it's 100% about the players.

 

[Bleu Star]

The odds of us getting another QB like him are not good.

Lets say in the last couple of drafts that we had a Manziel, Bridgewater, Winston, or MArriotta.. Does anyone feel like we have a bright future with any of those guys? Especially with Captain predictable Jason Garrett as their coach?

We are screwed once Romo leaves because I doubt Jerry or Stephen would ever get rid of Jason.

I like Mariota. Of all that have made the transition in the last two years, I would bet on him, Carr, and Bortles.