Batman1980
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 7,913
- Reaction score
- 11,565
I think if just the player talent was involved, Ramsey wins with fans of the team or non fans.
And I would take the back to back picks of JAX of Ramsey and Fournette over Elliott and Charleton. But they were looking at that season and not necessarily the future with the Elliott pick. They were one season removed seeing how the RB affected the offense and record and they duplicated that in 2016 with Elliott. They also saw how the RB and TOP helped their D.
QCE, hard to fault them for taking either player but I don't think 2016 comes close to that without Elliott on board, he was the catalyst. Long term, we'll see how that shakes out but I am not big on 2nd contracts to RBs anyway or 15-17M a year for a CB. And I do think Ramsey is heading toward the fattest contract for a D player in league history. Since the CBA, don't see a lot of teams in the SB with that.
To me, Elliott and Charlton>Ramsey and Fournette. I am sold on Elliott as a franchise back and Charlton as a 1B DE. I am not sold on Ramsey as a 1A cornerback or Fournette as a franchise back. Clear choice to me.