CyberB0b
Village Idiot
- Messages
- 12,321
- Reaction score
- 13,619
I think the gist is that it’s prefferable to try your luck then to pay all that money for the same result. Especially if you can trade Dak.
That worked out well post-Aikman.
I think the gist is that it’s prefferable to try your luck then to pay all that money for the same result. Especially if you can trade Dak.
Of course they are. It's pure speculation, just like Mock Drafts. I never claimed I was reporting on the Cowboys. Is there a problem?
Those are garbage numbers pulled out of your butt.
Oh! And Dak doesn't make mistakes!Yes yes indeed. Total passing yards is the best way to evaluate how good as QB is.
How many games do you need to see Stafford piss away by throwing terrible interceptions to understand the type of player he is?
How many times do we need to see Cousins throw away a game late in the 4th quarter?
That’s a subjective argument . Dak has been on a better team at least in 2 of his seasons.
I’d argue Stafford , Carr and Cousins are all more prolific passers. Garrapolo we haven’t seen much but his potential appears to be greater.
I’m not sure Dak would have had the same success in Wash, Det or Oak for example.
That worked out well post-Aikman.
You’ve forgotten Carr led Raiders to a 12-4 season and playoffs . Stafford has been the star consistently in Detroit leading them to playoffs several times.Regardless you’re correlating team success with QB talent and passing ability.Carr is a below average QB. He’s been a starter since 2014 but has yet to lead his team to a division title or playoff win.
Cousins has been in the league since 2012 but has never won a playoff game. That includes with the Vikings who are very talented team, other than at QB.
Garropolo has started 10 games in the NFL and has a history of injuries.
Stafford has been a starter since 2009 and has yet to win a playoff game.
Dak is better than all 3. He took over a 4-12 team and led them to 2 division titles in 3 seasons and the second most wins in the NFL behind Tom Brady and the Patriots. Dak was Offensive Rookie of the Year in 2016 and made the Pro Bowl in 2016 and 2018. Based on what the others are earning $30 million a year seems fair for Dak.
Well.....if we are being honest....they didn’t play like pro bowlers last year.Didn’t look too good until he had that WR. And most QB would flourish with 2 Pro Bowl OL.
Imagine if they pay Dak like a SB QB, then the Cowboys go 7-9, Dak throws like only 20 TDs the whole season again, but Zeke has like a thousand carries again. Zeke's going to start getting pissed off watching Dak get as much per season as he's made his whole career. And I would not blame him.
Imagine if they pay Dak like a SB QB, then the Cowboys go 7-9, Dak throws like only 20 TDs the whole season again, but Zeke has like a thousand carries again. Zeke's going to start getting pissed off watching Dak get as much per season as he's made his whole career. And I would not blame him.
You’ve forgotten Carr led Raiders to a 12-4 season and playoffs . Stafford has been the star consistently in Detroit leading them to playoffs several times.Regardless you’re correlating team success with QB talent and passing ability.
Not quite a top 10 defense yet either, but above average last season.Well....he only had two pro bowl lineman last year and didn’t have a number receiver until week 7 or 8 so he should be alright lol.
Doesn't really affect me, no.
I understand but those intangible assets doesn’t define a talented prolific passer.The Raiders were 12-4 in 2016 but lost the division to the Chiefs because Carr was historically bad in the game that mattered most - at Kansas City in December with the division title on the line. He was 17 of 41 for 117 yards. That’s less than 3 yards per attempt.
https://www.denverpost.com/2016/12/09/raiders-derek-carr-struggles-against-chiefs/
Stafford hasn’t won a playoff game in 10 years. Results matter.
Dak has proven to be clutch, which is why he leads the NFL in game winning drives since entering the league, with 14.
Since 2016, Stafford and Cousins both rank in the top 5 in number of attempts when trailing by more than one score. (Dak is 28th) It's very easy to pile up yardage in that situation. Cousins ranks 1st, Stafford 3rd in passing yards when trailing by more than one score.Dak is not better than Stafford or Cousins! Both Stafford and Cousins have passed for more yards on lesser teams. Cousins has been a 4k yd passer the last 4 years. You put those QBs on Dallas and the Cowboys are better team than with Dak. If Dak gets that kind of money we can all forget about doing anything more than winning regular season games.
The point people miss is the only reason he will be paid at what they think of as an elite level is because his contract is up now, and those of the truly elite are not.He's not worth that type of money. I rather go through pains of finding a new QB then to be stuck with an "average, but paid like I'm an elite" QB
QBs of Daks talent level can be signed for 2-5m per year on short term deals. The fact that Dallas is not in a position to acquire a franchise QB right now is not a valid excuse for offering franchise QB money.
Dak is under contract for 2019. Lets play the season and see where we are next January.