Aikman is a better QB than Dak Prescott

[Legend]

When has the team ever carried dak?

Multiple? Wow! Impressive.

As was those 18 tds per year he carried his team with.

That was the balanced attack back then.

Get the lead with the pass and turn it over to Emmitt to grind out the clock.

Aikman cared about winning instead of his stats.

Something Dak should work on especially during the playoffs.

Dak is making pledges about the number of INTs instead of stating he will win a divisional playoff game.

 

[CowboyRoy]

That was the balanced attack back then.

Get the lead with the pass and turn it over to Emmitt to grind out the clock.

Yep……aikman didnt have to do much on that team. Hand the ball off and keep the defense honest.

dak has to throw for 300 yards 3 tds, no picks and they still lose.

and then fans like you blame him for the loss. Lol

 

[Legend]

Yep……aikman didnt have to do much on that team. Hand the ball off and keep the defense honest.

dak has to throw for 300 yards 3 tds, no picks and they still lose.

and then fans like you blame him for the loss. Lol

Dak did not put up those numbers during the last two playoff games.

23/37 206 yards 1 TD 2 INTs

The playoff game before that:

23/43 254 yards 1 TD 1 INT

 

[CowboyRoy]

That was the balanced attack back then.

Get the lead with the pass and turn it over to Emmitt to grind out the clock.

Aikman cared about winning instead of his stats.

Something Dak should work on especially during the playoffs.

Dak is making pledges about the number of INTs instead of stating he will win a divisional playoff game.

Bwaaaaa!! Dak doesnt care about winning?
should he just hand the ball off to the horrid zeke and let zeke bring home the win?

daks has a 92 qbr with 15 tds and 5 picks in 6 playoff games. Hes played well overall.

has aikman ever won a playoff game when his defense gave up 200 yards rushing? How about 175 yards rushing?

 

[CowboyRoy]

Dak did not put up those numbers during the last two playoff games.

23/37 206 yards 1 TD 2 INTs

The playoff game before that:

23/43 254 yards 1 TD 1 INT

Your stats are off.

And dak played the bucs one of those games and went for 300 and 5tds.

 

[Legend]

Your stats are off.

And dak played the bucs one of those games and went for 300 and 5tds.

I meant the 49ers games. The Bucs were 8-9

 

[Legend]

Your stats are off.

And dak played the bucs one of those games and went for 300 and 5tds.

Dak has never won two playoff games in a season.

When he played a team above .500 in the playoffs in the last two seasons; he did not perform well.

 

[CowboyRoy]

I meant the 49ers games. The Bucs were 8-9

Its was the goat Tom Brady. Supporting cast doesnt matter according to you. Tom Brady against Dak Prescott.

QBs win games and QBs have records right?

 

[CowboyRoy]

Dak has never won two playoff games in a season.

When he played a team above .500 in the playoffs in the last two seasons; he did not perform well.

He would have won two playoff games if he had Aikmans supporting cast.

Is this sinking in yet? Im still getting the feeling you aren't getting it.

So is Aikman better than Dan Marino since Aikmans team won more playoff games?

 

[RustyBourneHorse]

Aikman also had to survive the growth of the team. He came to a very bad team which had a revolving door roster while it was being built.

He had to get over the Philly hump, with that killer defense and an absolute hatred for the Cowboys. Remember the 11 sack game in 91? Sacked 11 times and hit countless times, in an era where a rusher could follow through on the hit if they were within a step.

Dak has had a much easier road than Aikman, especially when you factor in the parity of today's watered down NFL.

Aikman's later years struggles were as much a result of the beatings he took (Concussions and back injuries) and the dramatic culture shift the loss of Johnson and supreme arrogance of Jones brought to the team.

You can point to a specific season and say Aikman had more to work with but overall career wise, I'm not buying it. Dak has had it pretty damn good and has not capitalized on what he has had to near the extent Aikman did with what he had.

True with the 1989 and 1990 season, but I think Irvin, Harper, Novacek, and Smith are nice weapons. Though yes, Dak has had easier rides than those two seasons. Plus, I don't think any comparison is necessary between Jimmy and Jason Garrett.

 

[Qcard]

Why not just say what's on your mind kiddo.

Suddenly you are coy...bashful?

I am good oldie!!

Suddenly I am supposed to care about being bashful...

Go fish...you are not entitled to anything other what I post.

Dak Hate is Not About Football

 

[CowboyRoy]

True with the 1989 and 1990 season, but I think Irvin, Harper, Novacek, and Smith are nice weapons. Though yes, Dak has had easier rides than those two seasons. Plus, I don't think any comparison is necessary between Jimmy and Jason Garrett.

Aikman wins no SB's with Daks supporting cast and Garrett as his HC. None.

 

[RustyBourneHorse]

Aikman wins no SB's with Daks supporting cast and Garrett as his HC. None.

I don't know that. What I would imagine is he wouldn't win anything with Garrett as Garrett was worse than Chan Gailey.

 

[Legend]

He would have won two playoff games if he had Aikmans supporting cast.

Is this sinking in yet? Im still getting the feeling you aren't getting it.

So is Aikman better than Dan Marino since Aikmans team won more playoff games?

Dak could not complete or make clutch his passes like the one below in the divisional round playoff game

 

[Legend]

Its was the goat Tom Brady. Supporting cast doesnt matter according to you. Tom Brady against Dak Prescott.

QBs win games and QBs have records right?

It was a bad Bucs team.

 

[Legend]

He would have won two playoff games if he had Aikmans supporting cast.

Is this sinking in yet? Im still getting the feeling you aren't getting it.

So is Aikman better than Dan Marino since Aikmans team won more playoff games?

Aikman was the better QB in the 1990s than Dan Marino.

Aikman’s peers were Young, Favre, Elway, and Kelly.

 

[Legend]

He would have won two playoff games if he had Aikmans supporting cast.

Is this sinking in yet? Im still getting the feeling you aren't getting it.

So is Aikman better than Dan Marino since Aikmans team won more playoff games?

No one would ever know.

The only thing that matters is what happened.

Aikman went 10-1 in his first 11 playoff starts with 3 SBs and 1 SB MVP.

Aikman was 6-0 with 2 SBs and 1 SB MVP.

While Dak has went 2-4 in the playoffs. 0 SBs and 0 SB MVPs.

All of your excuses for Dak’s playoff performances are like rear end holes. Everyone has one.

 

[Mr Cowboy]

What does it matter? What has dumb Dak done in 7 years?

I'm not comparing him to Dak, you are. I'm just saying that people like you would have killed had this forum been around back then!

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Dak in the wild card game versus a 8-9 Tampa team
25/33 305 yards 4 TDs

Aikman in the 1992 NFC Championship game against the 14-2 49ers

24/34 322 yards 2 TDs

Aikman the following game in the Super Bowl

22/30 273 yards 4 TDs

Did you watch Aikman play live during the Cowboys SB run?

Dak had 5 touchdowns….

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Dude, seriously. You were like.... five years old during Aikman's heyday.

I was a wise 5 year old…..I remember the greats from the 90s. I don’t remember Aikman having 5 TDS…