American Idol season 10
- Thread starter kristie
- Start date
Cajuncowboy
Preacher From The Black Lagoon
- Messages
- 27,499
- Reaction score
- 81
Bottom three...
Jacob, Hailey and Casey.
I am so tired of his growling act on EVERY FREAKIN' SONG.
GEez, get a shot or something for the pain, man!
Top three are Scotty, Lauren and James. I don't think any of them has ever been in the bottom three.
Jacob, Hailey and Casey.
I am so tired of his growling act on EVERY FREAKIN' SONG.
GEez, get a shot or something for the pain, man!
Top three are Scotty, Lauren and James. I don't think any of them has ever been in the bottom three.
Hostile
The Duke
- Messages
- 119,565
- Reaction score
- 4,544
To me the bottom three is Jacob and the 2 girls. Jacob is gone. The suit was a wreck and he did nothing really new. Same old stuff every week. He can sing, but he doesn't entertain.
James owned the show. Flat out took the pink slip.
Scotty was the runner up. He took a risk and it paid off big. His only sin was sharing a stage with James who ought to finally win one of these for the rockers.
Casey is flat out entertaining every single time I see him. Taylor Hicks was too. I feel like that is why he won the year he did. Casey won't win, but he'll be in it for a while.
Lauren came out of her shell a little bit, but stayed in it part way. I want her to pull a Carrie Underwood and sing something like Carrie did with "Alone" by Heart and let loose. Once she did that she was out of her shell and won it all. Lauren has the voice, but lacks the kill.
Haley is a stunner, but she needs perfect song choices to measure up to the others.
James owned the show. Flat out took the pink slip.
Scotty was the runner up. He took a risk and it paid off big. His only sin was sharing a stage with James who ought to finally win one of these for the rockers.
Casey is flat out entertaining every single time I see him. Taylor Hicks was too. I feel like that is why he won the year he did. Casey won't win, but he'll be in it for a while.
Lauren came out of her shell a little bit, but stayed in it part way. I want her to pull a Carrie Underwood and sing something like Carrie did with "Alone" by Heart and let loose. Once she did that she was out of her shell and won it all. Lauren has the voice, but lacks the kill.
Haley is a stunner, but she needs perfect song choices to measure up to the others.
Khartun
AmarilloCowboyFan
- Messages
- 3,133
- Reaction score
- 1,682
Seems almost pre-determined to me that James is gonna win. He get great reviews all the time and I just don't see it. He is ok but not as good as they make him out to be. Plus, how the hell did he get Zakk Wylde to come out with him?
I hope Lauren doens't go home. I think she is terrific she just needs some more experience. I definitely think she has the best voice left in the competition and will probably have the best career.
I'm really pulling for Casey. I like him a lot.
I hope Lauren doens't go home. I think she is terrific she just needs some more experience. I definitely think she has the best voice left in the competition and will probably have the best career.
I'm really pulling for Casey. I like him a lot.
Gemini Dolly
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 7,391
- Reaction score
- 1,400
Its coming down to Scotty vs James. I still say Scotty wins this.
Lauren is frustrating me. Does she really not know how good a voice she has? Why has she lost so much confidence in herself. ITs so frustrating.
I don't care for Jacob or Casey's style.
Haley, Jacob, Casey in the B3.
Bye bye Jacob.
Lauren is frustrating me. Does she really not know how good a voice she has? Why has she lost so much confidence in herself. ITs so frustrating.
I don't care for Jacob or Casey's style.
Haley, Jacob, Casey in the B3.
Bye bye Jacob.
Cajuncowboy
Preacher From The Black Lagoon
- Messages
- 27,499
- Reaction score
- 81
Yay! No more grunting and growling in the middle of a song.
I like Casey but he needs to stop with the campiness of that shtick.
I said from the beginning I thought Lauren, Scotty and James would be the top three. I am pretty sure that's the way it will play out.
I am surprised though that Jacob is still there.
I like Casey but he needs to stop with the campiness of that shtick.
I said from the beginning I thought Lauren, Scotty and James would be the top three. I am pretty sure that's the way it will play out.
I am surprised though that Jacob is still there.
Gemini Dolly
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 7,391
- Reaction score
- 1,400
I LOVE LOVE LOVE BRUNO MARS 
IM cool with Casey leaving. His style never pleased me. The worst singer that was left.
Way to go Haley. I didnt think she stood a chance to make it this far after the way the girls were dropping like flies, but she has picked up steam and sticking around.
IM cool with Casey leaving. His style never pleased me. The worst singer that was left.
Way to go Haley. I didnt think she stood a chance to make it this far after the way the girls were dropping like flies, but she has picked up steam and sticking around.
kristie
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 8,504
- Reaction score
- 804
CATCH17
1st Round Pick
- Messages
- 67,807
- Reaction score
- 86,471
After watching Thursdays elimination show and how they were acting towards Haley I think the light bulb has finally popped on for the judges.
I expect the judges to make a major push for her this Thursday regardless of how good or bad her performance is because I think they are starting to realise what I already knew.. She is amazing.
I expect the judges to make a major push for her this Thursday regardless of how good or bad her performance is because I think they are starting to realise what I already knew.. She is amazing.
