American Idol season 11

Tony33 · Apr 20, 2012

theogt;4514497 said:
The guy is clueless about pretty much everything. Sometimes I wonder if he's just a giant schtick -- someone acting like a ridiculous redneck with no taste or judgment. It's a great schtick if that's the case, if not over the top.

Wow. Somebody is full of himself and his self righteous opinion. You like teeny bopper, dime a dozen singers. I like singers with character, soul, and a unique presentation. For me Elise clearly is the best remaining for the girls and Phillip for the boys. The rest been there done that, I don't care for it.

Taylor Hicks, David Cook, Bo Bice, and Clay Aiken come to mind from years ago, I thought they were amazing.

I think if I was a redneck, I'd be all over Skylar. I don't care for her.

theogt · Apr 20, 2012

Tony33;4514741 said:
Wow. Somebody is full of himself and his self righteous opinion. You like teeny bopper, dime a dozen singers. I like singers with character, soul, and a unique presentation. For me Elise clearly is the best remaining for the girls and Phillip for the boys. The rest been there done that, I don't care for it.

Taylor Hicks, David Cook, Bo Bice, and Clay Aiken come to mind from years ago, I thought they were amazing.

I think if I was a redneck, I'd be all over Skylar. I don't care for her.

You misunderstood my post. I wasn't referring to you. But whatever.

Cajuncowboy · Apr 20, 2012

theogt;4514793 said:
You misunderstood my post. I wasn't referring to you. But whatever.

No, I think he has you pretty well pegged like most do. He understands you don't have to attack someone out of the clear blue to make a point. Unlike some do.

Wimbo · Apr 20, 2012

IMO, Elise's problem is that she is trying to beat the other girls by being the same, big note kind of singer that Jessica and Hollie are. Bad strategy. Elise is a sultry, rock & roll kind of singer... she should be trying to compete using her strength rather than trying to prove that she can hit the big notes. Philip does this well. He is a soulful, edgy singer in the Dave Matthews mold. He knows his strength & style, and he approaches every song that way. If he tried to go head to head with Joshua & sing in Joshua's style, he would be mediocre at best. He know this, so he won't do it.

Elise needs to learn this lesson... If she would sing things that are in her wheelhouse... Janis, Pat Benetar, Bonnie Raitt, Heart, Joan Jett, Blondie, along with more Led Zepplin & similar covers then I think she would be more successful.

pjtoadie · Apr 20, 2012

Wimbo;4514831 said:
IMO, Elise's problem is that she is trying to beat the other girls by being the same, big note kind of singer that Jessica and Hollie are. Bad strategy. Elise is a sultry, rock & roll kind of singer... she should be trying to compete using her strength rather than trying to prove that she can hit the big notes. Philip does this well. He is a soulful, edgy singer in the Dave Matthews mold. He knows his strength & style, and he approaches every song that way. If he tried to go head to head with Joshua & sing in Joshua's style, he would be mediocre at best. He know this, so he won't do it.

Elise needs to learn this lesson... If she would sing things that are in her wheelhouse... Janis, Pat Benetar, Bonnie Raitt, Heart, Joan Jett, Blondie, along with more Led Zepplin & similar covers then I think she would be more successful.

This ^

kristie · Apr 21, 2012

read this:

http://www.eonline.com/news/watch_w...tterfeed_celebrities_top_stories&dlvrit=79438

i've read the comments & there are some who think that the earth, wind & fire song may have doomed colton, not the lady gaga song.

kristie · Apr 21, 2012

for anyone here who knows something about gambling:

http://www.gamblingkingz.com/news/2012/04/16/sanchez-no-longer-american-idol-betting-favourite.asp

theogt · Apr 21, 2012

kristie;4516199 said:
read this:

http://www.eonline.com/news/watch_w...tterfeed_celebrities_top_stories&dlvrit=79438

i've read the comments & there are some who think that the earth, wind & fire song may have doomed colton, not the lady gaga song.

I don't think there's much need to decide which performance was worse. They were both some of the worst performances on the show this season. He sucked. Very generic voice. No originality at all. It was time for him to go.

Cajuncowboy · Apr 21, 2012

kristie;4516239 said:
for anyone here who knows something about gambling:

http://www.gamblingkingz.com/news/2012/04/16/sanchez-no-longer-american-idol-betting-favourite.asp

Someone lost money. LOL

But Elise being last is about right. She is the most erratic signer of the bunch and strays way to far from the songs that fit her. Anyone with any musical sense knows Colton shouldn't have went home but this is a competition where a small segment of America votes. America doesn't always get it right when it votes. If Elise would just stick to her range and incorporate it with her stage presence then she would be okay but she doesn't and that should doom her to the next elimination unless she does something else. But she won't lost much longer either way.

Gemini Dolly · Apr 21, 2012

Queen is the Theme.

Elise should do well with this. I like her. Hollie or Jessica could have a moment with "The Show Must go on"

kristie · Apr 21, 2012

Gemini Dolly;4516856 said:
Queen is the Theme.

Elise should do well with this. I like her. Hollie or Jessica could have a moment with "The Show Must go on"

i'm just hoping that nobody sings "bohemian rhapsody". i mean, i love the song, but i just don't think it should be attempted by anyone in the top 6.

Tony33 · Apr 21, 2012

Gemini Dolly;4516856 said:
Queen is the Theme.

Elise should do well with this. I like her. Hollie or Jessica could have a moment with "The Show Must go on"

I hope someone sings bicycle.

Holly and Jessica aren't going to do well. Jousha may be in trouble too, wonder what he will sing.

kristie · Apr 21, 2012

Tony33;4516915 said:
I hope someone sings bicycle.

Holly and Jessica aren't going to do well. Jousha may be in trouble too, wonder what he will sing.

oh god, i hope not. i hate that song.

Wimbo · Apr 21, 2012

Who gets to sing, "Fat Bottom Girls"?

kristie · Apr 22, 2012

Wimbo;4517263 said:
Who gets to sing, "Fat Bottom Girls"?

hopefully no one.

kristie · Apr 23, 2012

i feel bad for phillip:

http://www.aceshowbiz.com/news/view/00049910.html

even though i'm not a fan of his, i just hope his problem doesn't get to the point where he may have to quit the show.

Tony33 · Apr 23, 2012

kristie;4520675 said:
i feel bad for phillip:

http://www.aceshowbiz.com/news/view/00049910.html

even though i'm not a fan of his, i just hope his problem doesn't get to the point where he may have to quit the show.

Couldn't open it what did it say?

By the way

Bicycle, bicycle, bicycle

I want to ride my bicycle.

I want to ride my Bike!

:

kristie · Apr 23, 2012

Tony33;4520934 said:
Couldn't open it what did it say?

By the way

Bicycle, bicycle, bicycle

I want to ride my bicycle.

I want to ride my Bike! :

it talked about how phillip's health problem, kidney stones, are affecting him during the show so badly that his parents are asking people to pray for him.

my reaction to you quoting my least favorite queen song: :laugh1:

kristie · Apr 25, 2012

if colton dixon hadn't been eliminated, i think he probably would've sung this:

[youtube]2pMM4iwC-ag&ob=av2n[/youtube]

justbob · Apr 25, 2012

Just make it thru this night --I have never been a Queen fan

American Idol season 11

Benched

Surrealist

Preacher From The Black Lagoon

Active Member

Well known member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Surrealist

Preacher From The Black Lagoon

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Benched

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Benched

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Just taking it easy