Best QB Game

[Eskimo]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 29+
Joe Montana 39
Steve Young 12
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 32
Roger Staubach 37
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 11-

 

[L-O-Jete]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 23-
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 29
Joe Montana 40+
Steve Young 12
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 32
Roger Staubach 37
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 11

 

[Carl23]

The homerism HAS to end.

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 23-
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 29
Joe Montana 40
Steve Young 13+
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31-
Roger Staubach 37
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 11

 

[Royal Laegotti]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 23-
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 29
Joe Montana 40
Steve Young 13
Tom Brady 19+
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 37
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 10-

I can't stand the Patriots or Brady but he SHOULD be well above 20 IMO even though they lost the superbowl.

 

[BehindEnemyLinez]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20-
John Elway 29
Joe Montana 40
Steve Young 13
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 37
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 11+

The Air Coryell Show was a thing of beauty and Favre...ehhh. He's tough & durable but I've never been too impressed by his game (except for his arm strength)!

 

[DallasFanSince86]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 28-
Joe Montana 41+
Steve Young 13
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 37
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 11

 

[Skinsmaniac]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 28
Joe Montana 42+
Steve Young 13
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 37
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 10-

 

[Champsheart]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 28
Joe Montana 42
Steve Young 12-
Tom Brady 19
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 38+
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 10

 

[Pukindog]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 28
Joe Montana 42
Steve Young 12
Tom Brady 18 -
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 39 +
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 10

 

[Chuck 54]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 29+
Joe Montana 42
Steve Young 12
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 39
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 9-


I think this game loses all legitimacy when Steve Young and Tom Brady are among the lowest QB's on this list. To be honest, Unitas and Graham would have a hard time making a modern team. Peyton Manning has had better RB's and Receivers than Brady his entire career...he's a great one, but I don't think he can carry Brady's jock. Steve Young was a truly great QB that Cowboys fans hated because of the 49ers...personally, I'd take him as my QB over Montana. Young won with teams that Joe could no longer win with, imo.

 

[The Panch]

Peyton Manning has had better RB's and Receivers than Brady his entire career...he's a great one, but I don't think he can carry Brady's jock.

B.S. Brady had just as good RB's if not better than Manning. Manning had better receivers and he's also had better numbers. And that whole argument about Brady having more SB wins than Manning is b.s., cause last time I checked, the Pats have been known as a defensive team until this past season, especially when they won their first SB holding "The Greatest Show on Turf" to 17 points while Brady only tagged up 13(the other 7 came from a Defensive touchdown). Manning didnt win his SB til he had a solid defense. It's no coincidence.

Steve Young was a truly great QB that Cowboys fans hated because of the 49ers...personally, I'd take him as my QB over Montana. Young won with teams that Joe could no longer win with, imo.

I think Steve doesnt get enough credit, but you're out of your mind. Joe couldn't win with what teams?? His last playing season in SF('90) he took them to a 14-1 record(they lost another 1 without him).

Then, he took the Chiefs to their first Conference championship since 69 and they havent won a playoff game since.

Young had one great post season stretch where he went to the SB and that's it. Montana is 4-0 in the SB and never threw an INT in one either.

 

[THUMPER]

Otto Graham 23-

It must be that you have no clue who Otto Graham was that you give him a negative number. The guy took his team to 10 consecutive championship games and won 7 of them. He was without a doubt the most dominant QB in any era. When he retired the Browns declined enough that they were able to draft Jim Brown the following year.

Damn kids :bang2: :bang2: :bang2: :bang2: :bang2:

 

[ajk23az]

It must be that you have no clue who Otto Graham was that you give him a negative number. The guy took his team to 10 consecutive championship games and won 7 of them. He was without a doubt the most dominant QB in any era. When he retired the Browns declined enough that they were able to draft Jim Brown the following year.

Damn kids :bang2: :bang2: :bang2: :bang2: :bang2:

Geesh, try not to lose sleep over it!

 

[LeonDixson]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24+
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 29
Joe Montana 42
Steve Young 11-
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 39
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 9

 

[DT101]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 29
Joe Montana 42
Steve Young 12+
Tom Brady 17-
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 40
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 9

 

[VietCowboy]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 29
Joe Montana 42
Steve Young 11-
Tom Brady 17
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 32+
Roger Staubach 40
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 9

 

[THUMPER]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 25+
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 29
Joe Montana 42
Steve Young 10-
Tom Brady 17
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 32
Roger Staubach 40
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 9

 

[Royal Laegotti]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 25
Brett Favre 20
John Elway 29
Joe Montana 42
Steve Young 10
Tom Brady 18+
Peyton Manning 25-
Troy Aikman 32
Roger Staubach 40
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 9

Manning 7 points ahead of Brady??? Do you folks watch football??? I mean I like Manning and all and really can't stand Brady but let's be realistic.

 

[Dhragon]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 25
Brett Favre 19-
John Elway 29
Joe Montana 42
Steve Young 10
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26+
Troy Aikman 32
Roger Staubach 40
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 9

 

[LeonDixson]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 25
Brett Favre 19
John Elway 29
Joe Montana 42
Steve Young 9-
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 32
Roger Staubach 41+
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 9