Best QB Game

[DallasEast]

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 26
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36 +
Dan Marino 24
Terry Bradshaw 5
Jim Kelly 2 -
Dan Fouts 16

 

[DWhite Fan]

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 23
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 26
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18-1
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 24
Terry Bradshaw 5+1
Jim Kelly 2
Dan Fouts 16

 

[THUMPER]

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 24 +
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 26
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 24
Terry Bradshaw 4 -
Jim Kelly 2
Dan Fouts 16

 

[BigWillie]

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 26
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 25+
Terry Bradshaw 3 -
Jim Kelly 2
Dan Fouts 16

 

[Hostile]

Johnny Unitas 23
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 27 +
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 3
Jim Kelly 1 -
Dan Fouts 16

 

[danny0812]

Johnny Unitas 24 +
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 27
Joe Montana 35 -
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 3
Jim Kelly 1
Dan Fouts 16


sorry but im tired of the joe montana love here. seriously think the others on this list wouldnt have thrived with rice and taylor and the dink and dunk west coast offense? JMO:blind:

 

[jackrussell]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 27
Joe Montana 36+
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 3
Jim Kelly 0-
Dan Fouts 16

Toss up with Kelly and Bradshaw...so I went with the rings.

I'll be Brucing it in Buffalo tonight, so I'll be away til tomorrow afternoon. Would appreciate anyone keeping the list straight.

To the person who said to keep the symbols consistant and correct, the above way is the way that was explained on how to do this.

 

[jackrussell]

Revised correct list as of 6AM EST...with Kelly removed.

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 27
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 3
Dan Fouts 16

 

[DallasEast]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 27
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 23
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 2-
Dan Fouts 17+

I'm sorry, but... I don't know how the hell Bradshaw has lasted on the list this long, so I'm subtracting from him again. The man directly benefitted from his team fielding one of the best defensive units of all-time; AND having a very good wide receiver in Swann and a great wide receiver in Stallworth (sp?). Basically, Bradshaw was the 1970's version of Jake Delhomme with better D, one more good wideout to throw deep to, and a little more luck.

"Dan Fouts below a 20???" You guys have got to be kidding me! :laugh2:

 

[Dhragon]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 27
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 24+
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 1-
Dan Fouts 17

 

[jzcowboy]

This will be fun!!!

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 27
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 15
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 25 +1
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 25
Terry Bradshaw 0 -1
Dan Fouts 17

Bye bye Terry!

 

[boba5555]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 27
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 14-
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 25
Troy Aikman 32+
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 25
Dan Fouts 17

 

[Big Country]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 28+
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 14
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 25
Troy Aikman 32
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 25
Dan Fouts 16-

 

[pancakeman]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 28
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 14
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26+
Troy Aikman 31-
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 25
Dan Fouts 16

 

[dboyz]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 28
Joe Montana 36
Steve Young 14
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 26+
Dan Fouts 15-

 

[ElPanadero]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 28
Joe Montana 37+
Steve Young 14
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 14-

 

[Luther]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 28
Joe Montana 38+
Steve Young 14
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 13-

 

[ajk23az]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 28
Joe Montana 39 +
Steve Young 14
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 36
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 12 -

 

[Rackat]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 28
Joe Montana 39
Steve Young 13-
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 31
Roger Staubach 37+
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 12

 

[TellerMorrow34]

Johnny Unitas 24
Otto Graham 24
Brett Favre 21
John Elway 28
Joe Montana 39
Steve Young 12-
Tom Brady 18
Peyton Manning 26
Troy Aikman 32+
Roger Staubach 37+
Dan Marino 26
Dan Fouts 12



Edit: And just to note...the crack on Montana about having Rice and Taylor...yeah as if he NEVER won without them....oh wait, he did.

I guess Roger should be off this list cause he had Pearson...or Maybe we should remove Aikman cause he had Irvin, Harper, and Jay?