Bledsoe or McNabb?

[Tass]

2 awesome years?

Look at their career averages.

I'm projecting here, dude. I think Bledsoe will be awesome these next two years with the weapons he's got...contingent upon the line protecting him, of course.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Funny ... I'd take the better QB with better weapons anytime, anyday.

well McNabb doesn't have the better weapons

 

[burmafrd]

Eddie- you always rate the boys lower even our pro bowlers. The point is that mcFlabb choked when it counted. Late in the SB- a chance to win- and he choked.

 

[dargonking999]

Bledsoe w/ TO over McNabb w/ Stinkston, no doubt

Actually the questoin was Who would you want QB YOUR team

So it would be Mcnabb THrowing to TO.

 

[burmafrd]

TO gives any QB a huge edge.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Actually the questoin was Who would you want QB YOUR team

So it would be Mcnabb THrowing to TO.

maybe, I'd have to give it to McNabb because he's shown he's been successful with TO, Bledsoe hasn't

 

[Vintage]

Career Averages

McNabb:
58.4%
6.60 ypa
2.03 TD per INT
84.1 rating

Bledsoe:
57.3% completion rate
6.64 ypa
1.23 TD per INT
77.3 rating


If McNabb is 8 years of crap, what is Bledsoe? A lifetime of crap?

 

[MossBurner]

Oooo

oooo

Let me guess!


Bledsoe wins!

And if you posted this on an Eagles site; McNabb would win.

I'll add to that. The only fan site where Bledsoe would win this poll would be here.

 

[Eddie]

I'm projecting here, dude. I think Bledsoe will be awesome these next two years with the weapons he's got...contingent upon the line protecting him, of course.

I hope so too. That would take us a long way. We've shown we can be a competitive team with adequate blocking ... even with Pettite in there.

 

[dargonking999]

Career Averages

McNabb:
58.4%
6.60 ypa
2.03 TD per INT
84.1 rating

Bledsoe:
57.3% completion rate
6.64 ypa
1.23 TD per INT
77.3 rating


If McNabb is 8 years of crap, what is Bledsoe? A lifetime of crap?

No lets see he's wat 13 years pro, and he had 3 good season two under parcells, and one with Price and moulds, so i would say 10 years of crap

 

[ABQCOWBOY]

Unfortunate that these are the only two options.

Oh well, I pick McNabb.

 

[burmafrd]

I cannot believe it- Eddie said we will be competitive!!!!
invasion of the body snatchers.

 

[burmafrd]

Considering that Mcflabb has had a better team for most of his career- those edges are not that great.

 

[Vintage]

I'll add to that. The only fan site where Bledsoe would win this poll would be here.

Apparently not.

He's not even winning here.

 

[Eddie]

I'll add to that. The only fan site where Bledsoe would win this poll would be here.

Yep. Same old story. I love the Cowboys, but the rose colored glasses are too much sometimes.

Bledsoe in his prime and McNabb in his prime are a closer comparison. But at the moment, Bledsoe is far down the rung of top QB's.

McNabb is a QB who can carry a team to a Super Bowl. Bledsoe is an adequate starter for an average NFL team.

 

[Eddie]

I cannot believe it- Eddie said we will be competitive!!!!
invasion of the body snatchers.

Don't lie. You missed me. You like having me around. Otherwise, nothing to talk about.

:laugh1:

 

[Vintage]

Yep. Same old story. I love the Cowboys, but the rose colored glasses are too much sometimes.

Bledsoe in his prime and McNabb in his prime are a closer comparison. But at the moment, Bledsoe is far down the rung of top QB's.

McNabb is a QB who can carry a team to a Super Bowl. Bledsoe is an adequate starter for an average NFL team.

Any QB can win a Super Bowl with the right cast around him.

Trent Dilfer did.

 

[dargonking999]

Apparently not.

He's not even winning here.

not anymore

 

[Tass]

I'll add to that. The only fan site where Bledsoe would win this poll would be here.

I just don't think McNabb is a good QB. I don't care what his numbers say. Something in his face, his attitude sometimes...he might put up GREAT numbers in a regular game but when the pressure turns up he wilts. Just my opinion. Bledsoe, Brady, Hasselbeck, McNair, Delhomme, Culpepper and P. Manning...I'd take all of them before McNabb.

 

[dargonking999]

Any QB can win a Super Bowl with the right cast around him.

Trent Dilfer did.

cough cough, and QB can win a SB with a great Def supporting him,

TRent Dilfer, and Brad Jhonson (I tihnk that was the QB of TB) did.