Bledsoe or McNabb?

[Vintage]

I just don't think McNabb is a good QB. I don't care what his numbers say. Something in his face, his attitude sometimes...he might put up GREAT numbers in a regular game but when the pressure turns up he wilts. Just my opinion. Bledsoe, Brady, Hasselbeck, McNair, Delhomme, Culpepper and both P. Manning...I'd take all of them before McNabb.

I don't think McNabb is great.

But if he is 8 years of crap; Bledsoe is a lifetime supply of it.

 

[Givincer]

What pressure did Bledsoe handle? He lost the same number of Super Bowls as McNabb has.

Take your Cowboy bias out of this and look at it from the stand point of an NFL GM or even as a casual fan.

McNabb wins hands down. If both were available to any team in the NFL for the same price ... McNabb would get it 32 out of 32 times.

I don't know he only lead 3 game winning drives against San Diego, San Fransisco and Kansas City.

 

[burmafrd]

Eddie - if you put on rose colored glasses THEN YOU MIGHT BE IMPARTIAL. As it is now you are about as bad as a troll from ES.

 

[Vintage]

cough cough, and QB can win a SB with a great Def supporting him,

TRent Dilfer, and Brad Jhonson (I tihnk that was the QB of TB) did.

Brad could actually win you some games with his arm.

Dilfer....well lets just say Dilfer was at his best when he had to hand the ball off to Jamal Lewis.

 

[wileedog]

What pressure did Bledsoe handle? He lost the same number of Super Bowls as McNabb has.

McNabb would have choked in more had he not choked in so many NFC Championship games.

Take away McNabbs one good season with TO and the rest of his numbers are really not all that much better than Bledoe's. And he's played with a solid O-line for his whole career, and more than a few seasons when his team was the best in the division by far.

McNabb is horribly over-rated.

That being said, with our O-line, I'd take him over Bledsoe.

 

[dargonking999]

I just don't think McNabb is a good QB. I don't care what his numbers say. Something in his face, his attitude sometimes...he might put up GREAT numbers in a regular game but when the pressure turns up he wilts. Just my opinion. Bledsoe, Brady, Hasselbeck, McNair, Delhomme, Culpepper and both P. Manning...I'd take all of them before McNabb.

So you say Mcnabb chokes in big games, but then You'd say you take the biggest choker of them all over him. Dude this guy cant win a big game for nothing, they finally lucked out and didnt have to play the Pat's and then they went off, and still threw the game away, even when Pit, and The Refs gave them the game.

 

[burmafrd]

Just how many years has Bledsoe really had a good team around him? 2-3 years at the Pats- and since then? McFlabb has had a good team from almost the start- that makes a big difference.

 

[Vintage]

I don't know he only lead 3 game winning drives against San Diego, San Fransisco and Kansas City.

2 of those, I will give you credit for.

But please, NEVER, use a "game winning drive against San Francisco" in an arguement.

Its embarassing.

 

[dargonking999]

I don't know he only lead 3 game winning drives against San Diego, San Fransisco and Kansas City.

Umm might wanna add in phili,carolina

And dont forget he also chocked agaisnt Seattle, and Commanders

 

[Doomsday101]

It seems these discussion always go down hill, people feel the need to boost 1 guy and trash the other. You get right down to it Dallas has a good QB in Bledsoe but McNabb has done a very good job in Philly even before TO got there. I agree he has choked in the NFC Championship games but the fact remains he was a big part of why they were even in the Championship game to begin with.

 

[Vintage]

Just how many years has Bledsoe really had a good team around him? 2-3 years at the Pats- and since then? McFlabb has had a good team from almost the start- that makes a big difference.

Yeah, but you could argue that Bledsoe has had better options than McNabb has had.

McNabb has had 1 year of T.O. 1.5 years; actually. And then the likes of Pinkston and co.

Bledsoe has had Terry Glenn, Ben Coates, Eric Moulds, Peerless Price, Terry Glenn again, Keyshawn Johnson, Jason Witten, and now Owens.

 

[Vintage]

Umm might wanna add in phili,carolina

And dont forget he also chocked agaisnt Seattle, and Commanders

Carolina; yes.

Philly; no. Roy saved the day.

 

[dargonking999]

Carolina; yes.

Philly; no. Roy saved the day.

And if he didnt toss that TD pass to Terry glenn, the drive before, then Roy INT would have done nothing, but saved us from a more embrassing defeat

 

[burmafrd]

Bledsoe made a lot more good plays then bad last year- that is what matters.
With Bledsoe it has always been how good protection he has had. That is McFlabbs biggest edge- his mobility. BUT the way he chokes....

 

[Givincer]

Umm might wanna add in phili,carolina

And dont forget he also chocked agaisnt Seattle, and Commanders

Carolina for sure, Philly I guess you can give him some credit for, but its not like he won the game for the team, sure he set it up for the win, but I don't consider it a game winning drive.

 

[Tass]

I don't think McNabb is great.

But if he is 8 years of crap; Bledsoe is a lifetime supply of it.

Once again, I was projecting. I think without his star WR McNabb is going to be crap. I mean do you see McNabb getting better?

 

[Vintage]

And if he didnt toss that TD pass to Terry glenn, the drive before, then Roy INT would have done nothing, but saved us from a more embrassing defeat

Well, ****.

Then include every close game, bec. at some point Bledsoe probably threw a TD, and if he hadn't we'd have lost.

 

[Givincer]

2 of those, I will give you credit for.

But please, NEVER, use a "game winning drive against San Francisco" in an arguement.

Its embarassing.

Well if he didn't lead the game winning drive against San Fransisco we'd be dealing with something even more embarassing, a loss to San Fransisco, so he still had to do it and he did it, give him credit for it. Its not like we were ouptplayed or anything but we still needed to orchestrate a comeback and Bledsoe did just that.

 

[Vintage]

Once again, I was projecting. I think without his star WR McNabb is going to be crap. I mean do you see McNabb getting better?

Yes, because he didn't do anything in the 6.5 years as a starter in which he didn't have a star WR.

 

[wileedog]

Yeah, but you could argue that Bledsoe has had better options than McNabb has had.

McNabb has had 1 year of T.O. 1.5 years; actually. And then the likes of Pinkston and co.

Bledsoe has had Terry Glenn, Ben Coates, Eric Moulds, Peerless Price, Terry Glenn again, Keyshawn Johnson, Jason Witten, and now Owens.

I think Bledsoe would have traded some of those revievers for a decent O-lineman or two. He's played behind some of the worst lines in recent memory in Buffalo and Dallas.

Not to mention McNabb plays in an offense where running the ball is the thing you do when McNabb's arm needs a rest.

I think he's better, but I would still take the mental side of Drew's game any day, and think Bledsoe would outproduce McNabb given the right weapons and blocking.

But short of that ideal situation, yeah I'd take McNabb. But not with that contract he has, no way.