Broaddus take on Garrett being fired after this season

[CrownCowboy]

We're not as bad as you think. We just need to turn the corner. Some solid front office moves should accomplish just that.

Yeah, we are that bad...

This defense isn't anywhere close. If you have watched this defense and felt at any time that they we were about to turn the corner then something is wrong.

I mean, I know our owner thinks that, thus the last 17 years.

 

[burmafrd]

This D is HISTORICALLY BAD! amazing how many here refuse to face that

 

[big dog cowboy]

This D is HISTORICALLY BAD! amazing how many here refuse to face that

Really? You honestly don't believe everyone in here knows how bad our defense is?

 

[ScipioCowboy]

This D is HISTORICALLY BAD! amazing how many here refuse to face that

Are you sure about that?

 

[wileedog]

Reid got a better QB.
Harbaugh got a better QB.
Carroll got a better QB.
Kelly got a better QB.
.

Reid had hot garbage at QB.
Harbaugh had hot garbage at QB.
Carroll had hot garbage at QB.
Kelly had hot garbage at QB.

Whatever you think of Romo, implying that he is anywhere near the same class as the Matt Cassels or Tarvaris Jacksons of the world is just flippin' ignorant.

Furthermore, Reid's "new" QB is Harbaugh's "old" QB, so what the heck are you even talking about?

 

[burmafrd]

Really? You honestly don't believe everyone in here knows how bad our defense is?

look at how many are trying to blame the offense. They refuse to admit this D is really that bad

 

[Stash]

look at how many are trying to blame the offense. They refuse to admit this D is really that bad

Just as many want to give Kiffin and the efense a pass based solely on 'injuries'.

Not saying they're not a factor, but they're not reason enough to excuse this level of ineptitude.

 

[wileedog]

Just as many want to give Kiffin and the efense a pass based solely on 'injuries'.

Not saying they're not a factor, but they're not reason enough to excuse this level of ineptitude.

Half the defense was in the tub last year too. Didn't stop Ryan from being railroaded out of town.

 

[Stash]

Half the defense was in the tub last year too. Didn't stop Ryan from being railroaded out of town.

Exactly right. But it doesn't stop some from attempting to make the case for a double-standard.

Then again, that happens a lot around here.

 

[SultanOfSix]

We're not as bad as you think. We just need to turn the corner. Some solid front office moves should accomplish just that.

Sure, but who do we have to make these "solid front office moves"?

Therein lies the problem, year in and year out.

 

[Super_Kazuya]

Yeah, except not every team is stagnant, year in/year out.

Are the Patriots stagnant?

 

[Galian Beast]

Yeah, we are that bad...

This defense isn't anywhere close. If you have watched this defense and felt at any time that they we were about to turn the corner then something is wrong.

I mean, I know our owner thinks that, thus the last 17 years.

The defense was entirely based on a defensive line that we no longer have...

I believe Ratliff was making 5 million, both Ware and Spencer 10 million. So you have 25+ million tied in just the defensive line... And we got nothing out of that.

Is the defense good? No, but you have to identify the reason why it's not good.

 

[CrownCowboy]

The defense was entirely based on a defensive line that we no longer have...

I believe Ratliff was making 5 million, both Ware and Spencer 10 million. So you have 25+ million tied in just the defensive line... And we got nothing out of that.

Is the defense good? No, but you have to identify the reason why it's not good.

Oh I agree with you.

We have money tied up in guys yielding no return. That and the lack of talent and horrible scheme and gameplans are only part of the problem.

If only our GM could agree as well.

 

[Galian Beast]

Oh I agree with you.

We have money tied up in guys yielding no return. That and the lack of talent and horrible scheme and gameplans are only part of the problem.

If only our GM could agree as well.

Well we will see what he does. Either he was restructure Ware, ask him take a pay cut, ask him to take a pay cut and restructure him, or release him.

There really is no status quo at this point.

 

[Beast_from_East]

Reid had hot garbage at QB.
Harbaugh had hot garbage at QB.
Carroll had hot garbage at QB.
Kelly had hot garbage at QB.

Whatever you think of Romo, implying that he is anywhere near the same class as the Matt Cassels or Tarvaris Jacksons of the world is just flippin' ignorant.

Furthermore, Reid's "new" QB is Harbaugh's "old" QB, so what the heck are you even talking about?

Yea, I was scratching my head when I read that as well....................kinda blows that guys point out of the water..................LOL

 

[Beast_from_East]

Half the defense was in the tub last year too. Didn't stop Ryan from being railroaded out of town.

Exactly.............funny how the same guys that had the pitchforks out for Ryan screaming "no excuses" now all of a sudden are saying "Garrett needs more time, there are just too many injuries for him to be successful".


Hypocrisy at its finest.

 

[Risen Star]

Cool. Let's start with the GM and his moron son.

Would you settle for them acknowledging they've made mistakes in the past? Because that's about as accountable as they'll ever be.

 

[Don Corleone]

Jerry has also said on the radio, "What do you expect me to say about the coach's future?" Meaning that of course he isn't going to tell the truth until the season is over.

 

[jobberone]

Exactly right. But it doesn't stop some from attempting to make the case for a double-standard.

Then again, that happens a lot around here.

Oh, BS. Get off your agenda and debate fairly. Many have said the firing of Ryan wasn't just based on scheme and performance. That's not fiction. And there has more injuries this year esp to start with. Neither of those two statements is non-factual.

 

[Coy]

Reid got a better QB.
Harbaugh got a better QB.
Carroll got a better QB.
Kelly got a better QB.

See the trend yet?
If Garrett is fired, and we keep the same QB, nothing will change much.

And ... I don't think too much of our HC either. But the biggest problem here is injuries and talent acquisition. And we all know that our HC is only marginally involved in talent acquisition.

Ridiculous, it's the other way around, just imagine Romo with either Reid, Harbaugh or Carroll.
Garrett is the problem in Dallas (of course it's on Jerry for hiring him)