CBS: 2023 QB Power Rankings

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Looks like the AFC got the power...

when you have allen, burrows and mahomes. you have the power

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Hurts should not be that high. And neither should Jackson.
Nor Rodgers based on last season.

hurts played in the superbowl, so he is the darling. I wouldn't put him that high and above allen.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Do you think our league-interception-leading QB deserves better than 16th place?

yes, I do.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Hurts had a MVP type year last year, finishing 2nd to Mahomes.

Based on last year, yeah, him in the Top 3 isn't that eye opening. Let's see how he does in his second full season.

Watson at 10 is the real howler.

he also had one of the most strong supporting cast. and a top notch defense.

 

[PA Cowboy Fan]

he also had one of the most strong supporting cast. and a top notch defense.

and they couldn't win a game without him. Us on the other hand....

 

[817Gill]

This is a great way to look at QBs.

Appreciate it!

 

[Nav22]

This is just a prelude to Dak's haters eating more filth and looking even more stupid.

Once again, they SWORE he wouldn't be considered a top 10 QB this offseason.

And once again, players, coaches, scouts and execs will continue to rank Dak as a top 10 QB.

So that means those who are paid to know this sport... think Dak's haters are a bunch of know-nothing dunces.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

and they couldn't win a game without him. Us on the other hand....

They lost to us on the other hand

 

[J-man]

Rankings here

Not a bad shot at it. But Hurts at #3? Really?

I see some serious issues here. Red too high, Green to low, Blue is about right.

1) Patrick Mahomes
2) Joe Burrow
3) Jalen Hurts
4) Josh Allen
5) Justin Herbert
6) Aaron Rodgers
7) Lamar Jackson
8) Trevor Lawrence
9) Dak Prescott
10) Deshaun Watson
11) Kirk Cousins
12) Brock Purdy
13) Jared Goff
14) Geno Smith
15) Daniel Jones
16) Justin Fields
17) Tua Tagovailoa
18) Matthew Stafford
19) Russell Wilson
20) Kyler Murray
21) Bryce Young
22) Derek Carr
23) Jimmy Garoppolo
24) Jordan Love
25) Ryan Tannehill
26) Anthony Richardson
27) C.J. Stroud
28) Kenny Pickett
29) Mac Jones
30) Baker Mayfield
31) Desmond Ridder
32) Sam Howell

 

[Reverend Conehead]

yes, I do.

Then we'll have to respectfully disagree. IMO no QB that leads the lead in interceptions deserves to be considered elite. IMO Dak must perform much, much better this season, or the team should move on from him. I love the guy as a human being. I think he has a great attitude, is a humanitarian, and is someone I would like to meet. However, I think he owes this team a much better performance this season than last season.

I respect your right to your opinion. I just don't think it's accurate.

 

[J-man]

My list would go:

1) Patrick Mahomes
2) Joe Burrow
3) Josh Allen
4) Aaron Rodgers
5) Trevor Lawrence
6) Justin Herbert
7) Jalen Hurts
8) Matthew Stafford
9) Lamar Jackson
10) Dak Prescott
11) Russell Wilson
12) Tua Tagovailoa
13) Kirk Cousins
14) Deshaun Watson
15) Jared Goff
16) Geno Smith
17) Justin Fields
18) Derek Carr
19) Jimmy Garoppolo
20) Kyler Murray
21) Brock Purdy
22) Bryce Young
23) Baker Mayfield
24) Daniel Jones
25) Ryan Tannehill
26) Mac Jones
27) Kenny Pickett
28) Anthony Richardson
29) Jordan Love
30) C.J. Stroud
31) Sam Howell
32) Desmond Ridder

 

[big dog cowboy]

There’s 1 super elite win with whatever QB (Mahomes)
1 guys who’s another deep playoff season away from being a super elite win with whatever guy (Burrow)
4* guys with the all around talent to be in that Mahomes tier (Allen, Herbert, Lawrence, *Rodgers if you believe he hasn’t fallen off much physically)
3 guys who are superior athletes with the ability to throw but not quite elite throwers yet (Hurts, Jackson, Watson)
5 guys who are good to very across the board but not really elite at anything (Dak, Cousins, Geno, Goff, Carr)
4 guys who have some elite qualities but due to size, injury, and/or fall-off are now question marks (Murray, Wilson, Tua, Stafford)
4 outside looking in (Daniel Jones, Garrapolo, Tannehill, Mac Jones)

18 total guys you can win with, they just need varying levels of support. 4 guys who if you squint could do it, but they need it all to be absolutely perfect. Anyone not named above is not a starting caliber guy for more than a year or so, excluding Rooks obviously.

I find that it’s not necessarily a ranked order, just different tiers of support needed to win.

 

[Havic]

Deshaun is way too high imo and not judged off his most recent play. Lamar is a joke at his rank. Dak is about right. Any rookies who haven’t taken a nfl snap should be at the bottom.

 

[TexasHillbilly]

It starts out okay but goes off the rails at 3. No way Hurts is the 3rd best QB in the league. Just stop. Someone did this ranking by media attention not by watching them play.

I'm so not an Eagles fan but Mr. Hurts did get to the SB last year and played some really good and consistent football last year. Top 5 in my estimate but what do I know. I am after all just a couch coach. No offense to our illustrious MOD.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Then we'll have to respectfully disagree. IMO no QB that leads the lead in interceptions deserves to be considered elite. IMO Dak must perform much, much better this season, or the team should move on from him. I love the guy as a human being. I think he has a great attitude, is a humanitarian, and is someone I would like to meet. However, I think he owes this team a much better performance this season than last season.

I respect your right to your opinion. I just don't think it's accurate.

Who is considering Dak elite. That's not even in the.conversation. but if you think geno Smith is better than dak then I get your agenda.

BTW, Stafford led the league in interceptions couple of years ago. He is not elite?

 

[DeaconMoss]

Generally curious.

If the Chargers GM got drunk and offered you a trade - Herbert for Dak - straight up, who wouldn't take that deal?

Id also give them Gallup Gholston Gallimore and Joseph as a sweetener

 

[CouchCoach]

Rankings here

Not a bad shot at it. But Hurts at #3? Really?

1) Patrick Mahomes
2) Joe Burrow
3) Jalen Hurts
4) Josh Allen
5) Justin Herbert
6) Aaron Rodgers
7) Lamar Jackson
8) Trevor Lawrence
9) Dak Prescott
10) Deshaun Watson
11) Kirk Cousins
12) Brock Purdy
13) Jared Goff
14) Geno Smith
15) Daniel Jones
16) Justin Fields
17) Tua Tagovailoa
18) Matthew Stafford
19) Russell Wilson
20) Kyler Murray
21) Bryce Young
22) Derek Carr
23) Jimmy Garoppolo
24) Jordan Love
25) Ryan Tannehill
26) Anthony Richardson
27) C.J. Stroud
28) Kenny Pickett
29) Mac Jones
30) Baker Mayfield
31) Desmond Ridder
32) Sam Howell

Ws any QB more effective with running the ball within his offensive game plan than Hurts?

 

[Creeper]

I'm so not an Eagles fan but Mr. Hurts did get to the SB last year and played some really good and consistent football last year. Top 5 in my estimate but what do I know. I am after all just a couch coach. No offense to our illustrious MOD.

He had an all-star team behind him. Mahomes for example, had a banged up team, and was banged up himself, and beat the Eagles. That's the difference between the two QBs.

I am not saying he is a bad QB, I am just saying ranking him top 5 is so knee-jerky.

 

[Reverend Conehead]

Who is considering Dak elite. That's not even in the.conversation. but if you think geno Smith is better than dak then I get your agenda.

BTW, Stafford led the league in interceptions couple of years ago. He is not elite?

Dak lead the league in picks, plus was horribly inconsistent. He's made some decisions that make him look worse than a rookie. In the Washington game, he through a boneheaded pass that should have been a pick 6. The only reason it wasn't was dumb luck. The Washington player dropped it, even though it went right to him. Then, on the very next play, Dak made the exact same error on the same play, but this time Washington didn't screw it up; it was a pick 6.

I remember the Cowboys' elite quarterbacks, Staubach, Aikman, Danny White, and even Bernie Kosar. Dak's not even in the same neighborhood as those guys. Even very good quarterbacks like Don Meredith and Craig Morton were better. Yeah, this guy's got to get a lot better. To be honest, I haven't paid any attention to Geno Smith. If you say Dak is better than he is, you're probably right. But Dak still needs to improve. We'll see if he reduces his number of picks. If he does, then I'll give him credit.

 

[5Stars]

Just like the many in here, they failed to mention Dak had no weapons last year, plus an oft-injured Oline. Heck, Aaron Rodgers faired worse for the same reasons, yet they have him ranked higher? It's all personal bias rankings. So obvious.

You always come with this "Dak had no weapons". Then how did the team manage to win 12 games this past season? If someone says something bad about Dak, the other side of you mouth you come with, hey, he won 12 games two years in a row.

Then the other side of your mouth when Dak screws up in the playoffs because he is mental, well, "Dak had no weapons". How did he get to the playoffs without any weapons? When the team wins, Dak has weapons enough to win 12 games but when he fails in big games, he has no weapons. The excuses you give him are totally insane.

Dak has weapons to win 12 games, playoff loss, he has no weapons. Rinse and repeat out of both sides of your mouth. How embarrassing!