Video: Chris Simms: Dak is not Top 5

cowboyed

cowboyed

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,765
Reaction score
1,752
HotDog37 said:
Dak can play some ball but he also throws to ankles and angels at times when it counts.
Click to expand...

Human quarterbacks aren't ball dispensing robotic machines. Even the best of the best quarterbacks throw bad passes at critical times.
 
Creeper

Creeper

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,188
Reaction score
20,530
acr731 said:
All you have to do is watch this.....



Or this....


But this was the best...

Click to expand...


Watching these games again a couple of things stood out to me. Against the Jets and Saints, the Cowboys clearly got some bad calls from the refs, but caught a few breaks too.

Amari Cooper did not look like a $20 million WR. Cooper looks like he does not fight for the football or for position. Gallup drops too many passes. Zeke is a good RB.

Quinn is a good pass rusher, but not much help against the run.

Tyron Smith struggles at times against good DEs.

All three opposing QBs looked like HoFers against the Cowboys defense. The Jets QB had his best game of the year.

Dak was not the reason they lost to the Jets and Saints. But he was a big part of the loss to the Eagles.

The offensive line is good but not consistent, but they will miss Travis Frederick. I am worried about Tyron Smith.
 
IceStar-D7

IceStar-D7

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,160
Reaction score
9,091
CATCH17 said:
Yeah.. Pay those elite guys..

Don’t pay the bus drivers more then elite guys because other teams screwed up the market.

We have Dalton to get us through a year who will get Dak like results. Now go draft a guy.
Click to expand...
LMAO as I type. Dalton is way worse then Dak. Like I said go to Utube and look at a ROOKIE Dak versus an all pro ..LMAO...Andy Dalton. As the old saying goes" be careful for what you wish because it might come true". In all seriousness. Dalton IMO isn't even in Dak's league. He's being run out of Cincy by an unproven hopeful. If Dalton was all that. I believe Cincy would of kept him. Don't believe me? Ask any Bengal fan you run into. They couldn't wait for Dalton to leave.
 
jday

jday

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,321
Reaction score
13,284
Creeper said:
Watching these games again a couple of things stood out to me. Against the Jets and Saints, the Cowboys clearly got some bad calls from the refs, but caught a few breaks too.

Amari Cooper did not look like a $20 million WR. Cooper looks like he does not fight for the football or for position. Gallup drops too many passes. Zeke is a good RB.

Quinn is a good pass rusher, but not much help against the run.

Tyron Smith struggles at times against good DEs.

All three opposing QBs looked like HoFers against the Cowboys defense. The Jets QB had his best game of the year.

Dak was not the reason they lost to the Jets and Saints. But he was a big part of the loss to the Eagles.

The offensive line is good but not consistent, but they will miss Travis Frederick. I am worried about Tyron Smith.
Click to expand...
I'm pretty sure Dak was playing through an injury in the Eagles game. Probably should not have played but they had to win.
 
CATCH17

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,859
Reaction score
86,654
IceStarD54 said:
LMAO as I type. Dalton is way worse then Dak. Like I said go to Utube and look at a ROOKIE Dak versus an all pro ..LMAO...Andy Dalton. As the old saying goes" be careful for what you wish because it might come true". In all seriousness. Dalton IMO isn't even in Dak's league. He's being run out of Cincy by an unproven hopeful. If Dalton was all that. I believe Cincy would of kept him. Don't believe me? Ask any Bengal fan you run into. They couldn't wait for Dalton to leave.
Click to expand...

Dalton isn't way worse than Dak.

Dak is a little better.

Maybe Dalton can teach Dak how to complete a back shoulder throw while he is here.
 
plasticman

plasticman

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,815
Reaction score
18,036
CowboysBravesSpurs said:
So Dak is a top 5 QB in 2024? Do you know how dumb you sound? I like Dak & hope we sign him, but his fanboys are the most weirdest MFs around.
Click to expand...
Your impeccable logic cannot be defeated in debate. The array of information you provided coupled with your persuasive argument has forced my capitulation. I have learned so much from you today and consider myself far more informed on the subject. Thank you..
 
Last edited:
jday

jday

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,321
Reaction score
13,284
CATCH17 said:
Dalton isn't way worse than Dak.

Dak is a little better.

Maybe Dalton can teach Dak how to complete a back shoulder throw while he is here.
Click to expand...
I think Dak is better too....

But...

That offense is set up for any starting-caliber QB to succeed and do so very convincingly....

So I'm all for Dak getting paid fairly, but he better sign something...:grin:
 
sulu1701

sulu1701

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,296
Reaction score
4,600
Creeper said:
Watching these games again a couple of things stood out to me. Against the Jets and Saints, the Cowboys clearly got some bad calls from the refs, but caught a few breaks too.

Amari Cooper did not look like a $20 million WR. Cooper looks like he does not fight for the football or for position. Gallup drops too many passes. Zeke is a good RB.

Quinn is a good pass rusher, but not much help against the run.

Tyron Smith struggles at times against good DEs.

All three opposing QBs looked like HoFers against the Cowboys defense. The Jets QB had his best game of the year.

Dak was not the reason they lost to the Jets and Saints. But he was a big part of the loss to the Eagles.

The offensive line is good but not consistent, but they will miss Travis Frederick. I am worried about Tyron Smith.
Click to expand...
That's why they signed Cameron Erving, as a swing tackle he at least has experience, because it's not a matter of if Smith will get hurt, but when
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top