Vintage
The Cult of Jib
- Messages
- 16,695
- Reaction score
- 4,876
TheCount;5007540 said:Now why didn't we think of that?
We tried. Brewster. He didn't pan out.
TheCount;5007540 said:Now why didn't we think of that?
InmanRoshi;5007521 said:What would be sarcastic? That Warmack is short, fat slow footed phone booth guy? He's all those things. He's 6'2", plays with a huge gunt hanging over his belt and he ran a 5.5 among the slowest of all offensive linemen at the Combine. He's going to struggle in the NFL in space blocking athletic linebackers on the 2nd level, he's going to probably be a liability in the screen game and he's going to be a bad fit in any zone blocking system. He's not nearly the all around player that Steve Hutchinson was who could dominate in-line and on the move. Again, those phonebooth blocker skillsets are just generally not that rare. You can take a big slow college RT and move him inside and provide that skillset. The Ravens have bookend guards doing exactly that.
InmanRoshi;5007521 said:What would be sarcastic? That Warmack is short, fat slow footed phone booth guy? He's all those things. He's 6'2", plays with a huge gunt hanging over his belt and he ran a 5.5 among the slowest of all offensive linemen at the Combine. He's going to struggle in the NFL in space blocking athletic linebackers on the 2nd level, he's going to probably be a liability in the screen game and he's going to be a bad fit in any zone blocking system. He's not nearly the all around player that Steve Hutchinson was who could dominate in-line and on the move. Again, those phonebooth blocker skillsets are just generally not that rare. You can take a big slow college RT and move him inside and provide that skillset. The Ravens have bookend guards doing exactly that.
burmafrd;5007569 said:so you are smarter then all those PROs that say Warmack is a top player. Congratualtions on the days HUBRIS award
InmanRoshi;5007627 said:I don't care about what internet draft dorks say about him, I care about what NFL front offices say about him, and they're going to say that a limited athlete guard who couldn't play tackle in his wildest dreams isn't worth a Top 20 pick ... just like they did with DeCastro last year, despite your insistence that "Pros" thought he was the bestestest guard who ever guarded in the history of the draft.
Vintage;5007556 said:We tried. Brewster. He didn't pan out.
Idgit;5007747 said:Why is everybody getting so worked up over one poster's take on a player not even likely to ever be on our team? There are high picks every season who never make it in the NFL. He's making a good argument, even if you don't agree. What's the big deal?
InmanRoshi;5007627 said:I don't care about what internet draft dorks say about him, I care about what NFL front offices say about him, and they're going to say that a limited athlete guard who couldn't play tackle in his wildest dreams isn't worth a Top 20 pick ... just like they did with DeCastro last year, despite your insistence that "Pros" thought he was the bestestest guard who ever guarded in the history of the draft.
Rack Bauer;5007762 said:If you're saying he won't be drafted in the top 20, I'll take that bet.
Idgit;5007747 said:Why is everybody getting so worked up over one poster's take on a player not even likely to ever be on our team? There are high picks every season who never make it in the NFL. He's making a good argument, even if you don't agree. What's the big deal?
TheCount;5007758 said:Because it's draft season? What else is there to talk about?
Don't look now but 99% of the players being discussed on these forums will not be on the Cowboys next year.
Gaede;5007808 said:Happens every year.
Most people get caught up on one or two players, and then anyone who comes around and challenges the group-think is called out.
Pretty silly. IR is absolutely right about the guards.
More than likely, they will be there for us. Teams don't take guards in the top 15 unless they're truly exceptional or capable of playing tackle.
Idgit;5007820 said:I'm not commenting on the topic. I'm asking why so much vitriol aimed at IR who simply thinks the guy's overrated?
Idgit;5007747 said:Why is everybody getting so worked up over one poster's take on a player not even likely to ever be on our team? There are high picks every season who never make it in the NFL. He's making a good argument, even if you don't agree. What's the big deal?
InmanRoshi;5008087 said:It was the same thing with the Cult of DeCastro last year. The hivemind mentality and groupthink on these guards is unreal.
tm1119;5008329 said:See I'm not arguing that people are over reacting as to where the guards will get drafted. If you look at my posts I've been saying the idea that both guards will go in the top 18 is just silly. I only had a problem with your assessment of Warmack. It was misguided and quite frankly flat out ignorant. Why the heck would you care what your guard looks like in underwear or what his 40 time is? Not sure I can think of 2 more irrelevant things when assessing a guard. Watch the actual position drills at the combine and more importantly watch the game tape. Warmack does just about everything well that you could ask from a guard. Not saying he's going to be an all world player and hes certainly not the top 10 pick some people are making him out to be, but to call him stubby, fat, and a phone booth player is just flat out wrong.