tyke1doe;2500934 said:
And that matters because ?
Neither Ed Werder or BSPN own Valley Ranch, who'd probably were the ones who " might " have a right to complain legally. Maybe. If they wanted to do their job without being " bothered " they would have done what the did: MOVE.
CC has the right to do what he did, period.
Sigh.
Please follow the flow of conversation.
You said a person has a constitutional right to express his opinion in a public place as long as that person isn't threatening anyone.
I said, that's not exactly right. You don't have the right to expression your opinion in public places if, for example, you are so loud you're disturbing the peace.
Leon retorted did Ed Werder have a permit to assemble.
I said Ed Werder isn't shouting at anyone. And he wouldn't need a permit to assemble. (And, incidentally, he wouldn't need a permit to assemble because he's not bringing a large crowd of people. Usually permits to assemble are necessary so authorities can regulate the flow of traffic on the streets and in a particular public place.)
You asked "why does it matter."
It matters because the two issues aren't the same, that's why.
I don't know whether Ed Werder is on Valley Ranch property or not. He could be on a street or public area with Valley Ranch in the background.
As for CC having the right to do what he does, it's not a
PERIOD issue.
He has the right to free speech. But there are limitations even on free speech, which is why we have disturbing the peace ordinances, noise ordinances and other laws which regulate free speech to a certain degree.
The difference in this case is that ESPN isn't going to bother approaching the local law enforcement with this matter or file any disturbing the peace charges for a variety of reasons:
1. It would be too much trouble.
2. All ESPN would have to do is move, as you suggested.
3. That spot isn't necessarily a permanent fixture for ESPN.
But if I were having an assembly at that spot, and CC tried to shout and disturb my assembly, if I follow the proper legal protocol and file charges against him for disturbing the peace, he would have to comply.
It's not as clear-cut as you think it is. Then again, the real world is a lot more complicated and multi-dimensional than fantasy chat rooms are.