RonnieT24
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 14,395
- Reaction score
- 22,788
You do realize that ranking in the upper third of the league is above average by definition right?Dak is about right imo. Average as usual
You do realize that ranking in the upper third of the league is above average by definition right?Dak is about right imo. Average as usual
Well, if your only counting 22 QBs...Math might not be for you.
Ummm, can you show your work on this math problem?Dak is about right imo. Average as usual
No not joking. I know my answer. I asked him what he thinks.Please be joking.
Sapp is an idiot!! Among other thingsDidn't Warren Sapp say Tyler Smith doesn't belong in the NFL?
Or maybe he's struggling with the new scheme.This confirms what my eyes have been telling me about Steele. I don't think he's 100 percent past that knee injury after all.
I have a different rating system. 1-5 elite. 6-10 above average 11-15 average. 16-20 belie average and the rest are scrubs lol.You do realize that ranking in the upper third of the league is above average by definition right?
Well wecant take awag any game. Lets hope the next game evens it out.Grade school level math suggests that if Dak was "average" among the 35 quarterbacks qualifying for these grades he would be anywhere in the 17-25 range and not 11th; which is his actual grade.
And if we take away the three interception game against the 49ers (I know we can't) he would easily have a grade higher than 11th.
you have a diferent rating system based off of PFF's rating system? not to nitpick but why not just say Dak is not ranked 11 in my system he is more like 15th..I have a different rating system. 1-5 elite. 6-10 above average 11-15 average. 16-20 belie average and the rest are scrubs lol.
Again....you must not understand math either. How big is the subset? Give us the equation.Well, if your only counting 22 QBs...
What the range of the subset? Only plus or minus two?you have a diferent rating system based off of PFF's rating system? not to nitpick but why not just say Dak is not ranked 11 in my system he is more like 15th..
Do you have defense? Thanks for posting. (Edit - nevermind, found it, thanks)Starters in bold
- Tyler Smith – 84.2 (265 snaps) #2 out of 81 OG
- CeeDee Lamb – 77.6 (308 snaps) #21 out of 112 WR
- Tyron Smith – 76.5 (239 snaps) #11 out of 73 OT
- Dak Prescott – 75.8 (385 snaps) #11 out of 35 QB
- KaVontae Turpin – 75.1 (54 snaps)
- Zack Martin – 75.0 (290 snaps) #7 out of 81 OG
- Rico Dowdle – 70.5 (64 snaps)
- Asim Richards – 70.1 (22 snaps)
- Jake Ferguson – 70.1 (278 snaps) #12 out of 69 TE
- Tony Pollard – 66.4 (285 snaps) #31 out of 49 RB
- Tyler Biadasz – 62.8 (295 snaps) #19 out of 38 C
- Hunter Luepke – 62.0 (58 snaps) #4 out of 11 FB
- Jalen Tolbert – 61.2 (150 snaps) #71 out of 112 WR
- Brock Hoffman – 61.1 (115 snaps)
- Chuma Edoga – 60.8 (256 snaps) #42 out of 73 OT
- Brandin Cooks – 59.7 (230 snaps) #76 out of 112 WR
- Michael Gallup – 59.6 (280 snaps) #77 out of 112 WR
- Sean McKeon – 56.5 (32 snaps)
- Jalen Brooks – 56.1 (20 snaps)
- Cooper Rush – 50.7 (24 snaps)
- T.J. Bass – 50.6 (159 snaps) #63 out of 81 OG
- Terence Steele – 50.3 (410 snaps) #64 out of 73 OT
- Deuce Vaughn – 43.8 (48 snaps)
- Peyton Hendershot – 41.0 (96 snaps)
- Luke Schoonmaker – 40.7 (143 snaps) #65 out of 69 TE
I really appreciate your PFF #s posts.Starters in bold
- Tyler Smith – 84.2 (265 snaps) #2 out of 81 OG
- CeeDee Lamb – 77.6 (308 snaps) #21 out of 112 WR
- Tyron Smith – 76.5 (239 snaps) #11 out of 73 OT
- Dak Prescott – 75.8 (385 snaps) #11 out of 35 QB
- KaVontae Turpin – 75.1 (54 snaps)
- Zack Martin – 75.0 (290 snaps) #7 out of 81 OG
- Rico Dowdle – 70.5 (64 snaps)
- Asim Richards – 70.1 (22 snaps)
- Jake Ferguson – 70.1 (278 snaps) #12 out of 69 TE
- Tony Pollard – 66.4 (285 snaps) #31 out of 49 RB
- Tyler Biadasz – 62.8 (295 snaps) #19 out of 38 C
- Hunter Luepke – 62.0 (58 snaps) #4 out of 11 FB
- Jalen Tolbert – 61.2 (150 snaps) #71 out of 112 WR
- Brock Hoffman – 61.1 (115 snaps)
- Chuma Edoga – 60.8 (256 snaps) #42 out of 73 OT
- Brandin Cooks – 59.7 (230 snaps) #76 out of 112 WR
- Michael Gallup – 59.6 (280 snaps) #77 out of 112 WR
- Sean McKeon – 56.5 (32 snaps)
- Jalen Brooks – 56.1 (20 snaps)
- Cooper Rush – 50.7 (24 snaps)
- T.J. Bass – 50.6 (159 snaps) #63 out of 81 OG
- Terence Steele – 50.3 (410 snaps) #64 out of 73 OT
- Deuce Vaughn – 43.8 (48 snaps)
- Peyton Hendershot – 41.0 (96 snaps)
- Luke Schoonmaker – 40.7 (143 snaps) #65 out of 69 TE
You seem to think the subsets are "Elite, Average, and Poor".Again....you must not understand math either. How big is the subset? Give us the equation.
Nope...but that is exactly my point....everyone has a different range.You seem to think the subsets are "Elite, Average, and Poor".
Well then, why insult me with the "must not know how to do math" comment?Nope...but that is exactly my point....everyone has a different range.
It actually doesnt matter tome if dak is ranked low elite high average.
...whatever!. I just found it intetesting people got their thor hammer out over a handful of spots....like actually wanna fight about it.
That's fine if it's your system but the mathematical and statistical definitions disagree with you. My standard has always been the top 10% is elite.. so 3.5 out of 35.. round it to 4.. Anything in the upper 20% would have to be considered at "very good." So that's the top 7 or 8. Currently this system has Dak graded around the top 30%. Which I would consider above average to good. And we all know that ranking is being dragged down by one game. If he strings together a couple more games like his last one he will likely climb into that top 7 o r 8 realm which frankly is about where he belongs. Not creme of the crop but certainly above most of his peers. Time will tell.. THAT's why the play the games!I have a different rating system. 1-5 elite. 6-10 above average 11-15 average. 16-20 belie average and the rest are scrubs lol.