reddyuta;2136004 said:
I think rugby kickers would make excellent NFL kickers since they seem to hit it farther and from impossible angles -I wonder why we havent seen that.
Good question! Maybe it's question of timing for the kickers. A placekicker has to be accurate and get the kick off shortly after the ball is snapped. That's a skill which could be taught to most soccer players, but maybe not for all.
UKCowboysFan;2136010 said:
If you used athletics (Track & Field) as a tool to compare the two.
Football would be like the Sprints (more explosive) and the throwing events (more technical and strength related).
Soccer is more like long distance running, whereby great endurance is required. These guys play 90 mins with only one break at the half.
If both sports were noncontact, I could see comparing the two, but both are not. American football certainly is FAR from being noncontact. The enormous physical wear-and-tear which a football player endures during the violent collisions of blocking and tackling in a game must be included with the running aspect.
UKCowboysFan;2136010 said:
Both sports require their own unique ball skills. I guess the main difference is that soccer players are required to be more multi talented, where as football players can (generally) specialise in one position.
All soccer players on the field must be talented enough to directionally kick or bounce a
circular ball, which is very aerodynamically shaped even though it remains on the ground for the vast majority of a game, using various parts of their bodies. That is impressive. However, you're incorrect about it being a 'specialized one position' in football.
Quarterbacks must throw an oval-shaped ball to designated areas of the field based on pre-reads and after-reads of defensive alignments and/or personnel each and every play. Footballs are nicely aerodynamic, but only if they are thrown perfectly.
Wide receivers must have excellent hand, eye and body coordination in order to just have a chance to catch the ball. Additionally, they must have firm hands and strong arms to retain the ball upon reception.
Placekickers and punters' ball skills are not even questionable in this particular discussion, imo. They directionally and accurately kick (again) an
oval shaped ball extremely high and long. If a soccer player even attempted to do the same with a similar shaped ball, scoring would practically be nil.
UKCowboysFan;2136010 said:
One other thing with soccer is that as it is generally a very low scoring game (imagine football as 1 pt for a TD and no FG's or XP's), a single mistake can easily be the difference between winning & losing. This means the players (although fatigued) have to keep their concentration to the very end of the game.
For me, low scoring is acceptable for a sport like baseball. The reward for a run crossing the plate matches that of the sporadic pace of the game. Soccer is such a perpetually moving sport that I would think that points made would be 'more gracious'. However, it's one point per goal. Seems like a lot of work for practically no benefit. Of course, if your opponent also works as hard or harder for less, it all evens out, I guess...
UKCowboysFan;2136010 said:
For me, I love both sports but having grown up with soccer it will always have the edge.
The other thing that give's it the edge is the fact that we can unite as a country behind our national team.
The one advantage which the average American football fan has over the average world soccer fan is more exposure to both sports, even though soccer still hasn't become as popular in this country as it is has throughout the world. The same cannot be said vice versa, even with the opportunity of European fans to experience NFL Europe, for example.
I will not even attempt to debate the fanaticism which soccer fans have for their sport. American football fans love their sport to a certain point. On the other hand, world soccer fans have exhibited fanatic behavior for their teams which has ended with hundreds of thousands of injuries and deaths just in the past half century. Yep, in that concept of identifying with a favorite team, there's no debate whatsoever. Soccer wins by a landslide.