Nah what's crazy is the doubling down and your myopic view of the Giants.
NY:
lost a better player than anyone who left Dallas.
Signed an aging player at a position that doesn't age well. A player who has a history of locker room troubles. And has bashed his new teammates. Who will demand the ball. Who is coming off his worst season. And has literally already scheduled his retirement. (This signing was classified as great)
Signed a bust coming from one of the worst position groups in the league. Who's team said they'd replace him in the draft. In a draft that was historically poor for OL. And is currently a backup. (This signing was classified as great)
Signed a backup TE. Who has 51 career catches. And had nine last season. (This signing was classified as great)
Lost two of their better run defenders with two starters in their front seven.
Have two gaping roster holes on the OL and at linebacker that they failed completely to address.
And had the scoring margin of a 7 win team last year.
aww looks like yet again somebody doesnt like me. That is all I get here. Just like when you guys told me atlanta wasnt any good.
anyway. You don't seem to be comprehending how they are building their roster and maybe not how we are either.
The giants kept the better of their two DT's. They have jay bromley and the rookie from alabama to make up for the guy you are calling better than anyone that left Dallas which I do not agree with. I think Church and Carr were as good if not better.
On Brandan Marshall yes he has attitude problems and could be explosive if they are losing. On the flip side he has signed their to be a piece and not the focal point. Also they have a deep talented speedy group at wr. Marshall is going to give them an element they have not had in a while which is a big physical guy.
On Ellison the fact that you are talking about his catches already tells me you do not understand his role. They have engram and ellison/adams to play the H back? Y tight end role blocking on the line of scrimmage. This is something they were severely missing. Go back and watch a giants game from the last 3 years there Tight ends could not block anyone and it affected how they approached running the ball. Ellison and the possible development of adams takes care of that.
Their linebackers are just guys. Their defensive line has 3 studs and allows the just guys to get to the football.
on the offensive line. If flowers doesn't improve then they will have an issue. With that said their starting five are not bad and pugh and rich burg are very good. I am not sure because I have not seen anyone there say where fluker can go but dismissing him because san diego did makes no sense. he is very big and very talented. if he gets on the line they are very big and very powerful, whether thats at guard or tackle nobody knows yet.
It's basically very similar to Dallas Signing Leonard Davis in 07 free agency. He was given a big contract and the people in Arizona couldn't wait to get rid of him because he was a poor left tackle. I bet you didn't discount the davis signing when Arizona said they had to replace him and especially once late in camp he settled in at guard and really looked powerful especially against the colts in the preseason game. Looked like he was going to kill somebody he was so powerful.
as far as scoring margin goes, who cares? They could not run the ball last year because of issues on the line especially with terrible blocking from tight ends, a struggling left tackle and an injured pugh. There whole running game was the draw and hope the back could make someone miss. They are going to run the ball better this year.
Its odd how upset you get when I talk about the other good teams in the division. I have news for you NY, Washington and Dallas are all pretty similar and all should have outstanding offenses and NY has the best Defense of the bunch. I do think NY's defense will not be as good but still the best in the division which is what this is all about winning the division. Maybe you should start a fan club.
btw the Giants went 11-5 beat Dallas twice and lost to the same team Dallas did to end their season last year and you told me they would be terrible. How do you get to take this stance on me?