Dak is 9th-best QB in NFL per coaches, scouts and execs

[TheMarathonContinues]

49ers beat us convincingly both years. They knew our plays and dominated the line of scrimmage.

They were the better team. Hopefully this year our improvements will get us over the hump.

We are talking about Herbert right?

 

[leeblair]

Think about all the Anti-Dak Cult Members who have called Dak "trash" or "average" all offseason....

And now the rest of us can officially point and laugh at them.


Nobody on this board knows better than actual NFL personnel. Go argue with a wall.

The Anti-Dakkers lose yet again, because losers lose.

Top 10 List:​

1. Patrick Mahomes – Kansas City Chiefs
2. Joe Burrow – Cincinnati Bengals
3. Josh Allen – Buffalo Bills
4. Aaron Rodgers – New York Jets
5. Justin Herbert – Los Angeles Chargers
6. Jalen Hurts – Philadelphia Eagles
7. Lamar Jackson – Baltimore Ravens
8. Trevor Lawrence – Jacksonville Jaguars
9. Dak Prescott – Dallas Cowboys
10. Matthew Stafford – Los Angeles Rams

Honorable Mention:​

• Deshaun Watson – Cleveland Browns
• Kirk Cousins – Minnesota Vikings
• Jared Goff – Detroit Lions
• Derek Carr – New Orleans Saints
• Tua Tagovailoa – Miami Dolphins

Additional Votes:​

• Kyler Murray – Arizona Cardinals
• Daniel Jones – New York Giants
• Justin Fields – Chicago Bears

https://brobible.com/sports/article...-according-to-executives-players-coaches/amp/

That's why the NFL isn't top tier anymore. The coaching, scouting and execs no longer know football. Nepotism and sales hype have ruined the league.

 

[McKDaddy]

The post I quoted you in has nothing but numbers, nothing in the post speaks of any attributes.

but the thread of comments concerning Herbert does.

 

[kskboys]

The edge goes to the haters. Most of Daks fans will rank him close to where league executives have. Haters will make him out to be a back up scrub.

W/ a ton of hyperbole and hoopla said just to yank the chains of the other side. Disagree that either side has an edge, tho!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Strykerscm]

As always, there’s a hmmmm certain narrative about Dak and ummmm his blindly loyal supporters regardless of actual football play. It reminds me ummmmmm hmmm of a certain segment that repeatedly sees no improvement but continually follow people who just point and laugh at them.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

No one cares. Win something, unless you get off on useless rankings and a bunch of laugh emojis.

Sometimes this fan base makes me wish I was never a fan of this team. Clown show, some of you.

and you are in the circle, with the rest of the clowns. except you don't have a mirror to see yourself. everyone is a clown.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

As always, there’s a hmmmm certain narrative about Dak and ummmm his blindly loyal supporters regardless of actual football play. It reminds me ummmmmm hmmm of a certain segment that repeatedly sees no improvement but continually follow people who just point and laugh at them.

as opposed to ummm, hmmmm Bash Dak cult, that hmmm, ummmm despite any facts presented...sort of hmmm, hmmm refuses to accept that he is not trash, and above average QB....hmmmm, ummmm we have seen this team without Dak plenty of times and offense just hasn't been as good...hmmm, ummmm the amount of hatred for Dak from the dak haters is sometimes astounding

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

That's why the NFL isn't top tier anymore. The coaching, scouting and execs no longer know football. Nepotism and sales hype have ruined the league.

what is football? and what is it that they don't know? how is it any different than the old days you are referencing and how is it worse or better?

this is an utterly stupid statement. you sound like an 89 year old man who is gripe against everything in the world and why things aren't like when he was a little boy.

btw, in case you missed it, which you did. NFL is the most popular sport today than any other sport. by a wide margin....

 

[kskboys]

what is football? and what is it that they don't know? how is it any different than the old days you are referencing and how is it worse or better?

this is an utterly stupid statement. you sound like an 89 year old man who is gripe against everything in the world and why things aren't like when he was a little boy.

btw, in case you missed it, which you did. NFL is the most popular sport today than any other sport. by a wide margin....

If there's no limbs being torn off, the game sucks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[DeaconMoss]

And that may be true... but you still haven't answered my questions.

I only saw one question. No I did not think that about Peyton Manning. Andrew Luck, Trevor Lawrence and PM were the most complete can't miss QB prospects ever. Rogers had to wait his turn for like 3 years but as soon as he took the field you could tell he was a Boss. Brees had the whole trade thing to get past but Brees could always hit a gnat off a tadpole with ease. Comparing Statscott to these guys is embarrassing. Gin ur a decent poster but this is a bad look for you.

 

[DeaconMoss]

W/ a ton of hyperbole and hoopla said just to yank the chains of the other side. Disagree that either side has an edge, tho!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I don't care if they rank him first. He is not worth his contract and not winning rings. Cut bait this year.

 

[Strykerscm]

as opposed to ummm, hmmmm Bash Dak cult, that hmmm, ummmm despite any facts presented...sort of hmmm, hmmm refuses to accept that he is not trash, and above average QB....hmmmm, ummmm we have seen this team without Dak plenty of times and offense just hasn't been as good...hmmm, ummmm the amount of hatred for Dak from the dak haters is sometimes astounding

No facts except ya know, results on the field. I know that doesn’t carry as much weight to folks like you. Obscure polls based off subjectivity outweighs the real stuff.

 

[Momanpr100]

but the thread of comments concerning Herbert does.

His attributes is he's tall and has a big arm. Plenty of those types of Qbs crashed out in the NFL. Garret Jr is gonna make him regress.

 

[G2]

No one cares. Win something, unless you get off on useless rankings and a bunch of laugh emojis.

Sometimes this fan base makes me wish I was never a fan of this team. Clown show, some of you.

Strangers on the internet get you bent?

 

[Kevinicus]

Well you said you don't take the nfl execs, coaches and players rankings at face value. What sources do you trust?

I don't trust any source blindly, especially with no details provided. No intelligent person should.

 

[kskboys]

His attributes is he's tall and has a big arm. Plenty of those types of Qbs crashed out in the NFL. Garret Jr is gonna make him regress.

Sees the field well, is humble, very cerebral, and is a top notch leader.

Man, if you can't see the talent in Herbert, you either just don't want to or really don't get NFL football.

How did you miss that he's the first player ever to throw for 4,000 yds in his first 3 seasons? He's changing the record books. This cat is a freakshow on O.

 

[kskboys]

I don't trust any source blindly, especially with no details provided. No intelligent person should.

No doubt. Especially when you consider the obvious bias most coaches and players show toward guys on their own team.

 

[GINeric]

I only saw one question. No I did not think that about Peyton Manning. Andrew Luck, Trevor Lawrence and PM were the most complete can't miss QB prospects ever. Rogers had to wait his turn for like 3 years but as soon as he took the field you could tell he was a Boss. Brees had the whole trade thing to get past but Brees could always hit a gnat off a tadpole with ease. Comparing Statscott to these guys is embarrassing. Gin ur a decent poster but this is a bad look for you.

With all that said about these guys.... none of them won Superbowls and all of that other stuff in 6 years of playing and this is my point.

You're explaining how special they were and rightfully so. But how can you say it's time to get rid of Dak after 6 full healthy seasons of playing because he didn't do this or that....

But those other very good quarterbacks didn't do it either within the SAME EXACT time frame..... You didn't say they should be released or traded or the time is up for them did you?

Do you see the the hypocrisy dripping off your statement?

This is not a good look for YOU.

As a matter of fact, your argument made you look worse, and here's why.

Those quarterbacks are great quarterbacks.... yet they didn't go to championship games and Superbowls within their first 6 seasons. You made excuses for them. But when Dak didn't do it within the same time frame, you claim its time for him to go.....

Again.... do you see the hypocrisy??

 

[CWR]

W/ a ton of hyperbole and hoopla said just to yank the chains of the other side. Disagree that either side has an edge, tho!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The worst part is being rational and ranking/appreciating him appropriately and then ending up defending your stance, while being painted as a hater or lover. This board ain't about middle ground.

 

[FuzzyLumpkins]

I don't trust any source blindly, especially with no details provided. No intelligent person should.

So no one comes to mind that you do trust?