Dak or Romo?

[Blackrain]

Make up your mind. Are we comparing them when they were veterans or what?

Ill leave it here.

Romo 2014:
12-3 Record (8-0 on the road)
69.9 % completion
3705 yrds
34 tds
9 ints
113 passer rating
79 QBR
AP2
*first QB to lead league in regular season and post season passer rating

Dak 2023:
11-5 record (8-0 at home)
68.4% completion
4237 yrds
32 tds
8 ints
104 rating
70.5 QBR


Seems clear cut to me

That's because you're not telling the whole story just the part you want to tell.

Show the rest of the research

Show the Dak has 242 rushing yards this year two touchdowns 21 first downs rushing and only four fumbles.

Conversely Romo only had 61 rushing yards 0 rushing touchdowns only six first downs from rushing and seven fumbles.

He had way less rushing yards and way more fumbles.

That equals heartbreaker he would have us needing one game to make the playoffs and he would either fumble or throw some gut-wrenching interception at the worst time when it could not be overcome.
Ruining everyone's best efforts because he was in love with his arm refuse to run past the line of scrimmage and didn't know when to give up on a play

 

[WillieBeamen]

That's because you're not telling the whole story just the part you want to tell.

Show the rest of the research

Show the Dak has 242 rushing yards this year two touchdowns 21 first downs rushing and only four fumbles.

Conversely Romo only had 61 rushing yards 0 rushing touchdowns only six first downs from rushing and seven fumbles.

He had way less rushing yards and way more fumbles.

That equals heartbreaker he would have us needing one game to make the playoffs and he would either fumble or throw some gut-wrenching interception at the worst time when it could not be overcome.
Ruining everyone's best efforts because he was in love with his arm refuse to run past the line of scrimmage and didn't know when to give up on a play

Now yall wanna include rushing. If thats the case, Hurts > Dak

 

[Blackrain]

Tony romo's career was like the cow that gave a full bucket of milk and then kicked it over.

Dak still has time and enough career left to make his place in cowboy history best yet it could happen this year.

Go Dak bring us home!!!!

 

[Blackrain]

Now yall wanna include rushing. If thats the case, Hurts > Dak

Please stay on topic we are comparing Dak and Romo

You need to support your opinion with more facts not bring the eagles quarterback into the conversation he has nothing to do with what we're talking about.

 

[Blackrain]

Romo and his counterpart Garrett are finally where they belong analyzing football instead of playing or coaching it bsing the public instead of bsing Jerry into thinking they could actually do something.

Those two mediocre wannabes kept this franchise in a holding pattern of NFL purgatory for a decade not good enough to make the playoffs and not bad enough to draft well.

Now we at least have a coach and a quarterback that can get us 12 wins and into the playoffs giving us a punchers chance at a title

 

[WillieBeamen]

Please stay on topic we are comparing Dak and Romo

You need to support your opinion with more facts not bring the eagles quarterback into the conversation he has nothing to do with what we're talking about.

I am on topic. When discussing quarterback play and me saying Romo was a WAY better passer, why are we discussing RUSHING?

 

[1972COWBOY]

The new Romo after his surgery seemed to be quite good. Unfortunately he was not given a chance even though he proved his worth smoking the Eagles in that last game only to have Dak come back on to lose the game.

 

[Blackrain]

I am on topic. When discussing quarterback play and me saying Romo was a WAY better passer, why are we discussing RUSHING?

The thread is Dak or Romo.
Implies who's the better quarterback not who's the better passer there's more to being a quarterback than just passing.

Granted that's really all Romo concentrated on. While Dak uses his whole skill set to make us successful and lead the team.

It's all part of it passing running leadership availability being able to actually be tackled and get up and continue to lead the team.

Romo could pass the ball but he didn't understand risk versus reward was in love with his arm and never realized that sometimes less was more.
As a result his career never realized it's potential Dak still has time to attain the greatest achievement in sports because he is not a one-dimensional player and will do everything in his skill set to win

 

[WillieBeamen]

The thread is Dak or Romo.
Implies who's the better quarterback not who's the better passer there's more to being a quarterback than just passing.

Granted that's really all Romo concentrated on. While Dak uses his whole skill set to make us successful and lead the team.

It's all part of it passing running leadership availability being able to actually be tackled and get up and continue to lead the team.

Romo could pass the ball but he didn't understand risk versus reward was in love with his arm and never realized that sometimes less was more.
As a result his career never realized it's potential Dak still has time to attain the greatest achievement in sports because he is not a one-dimensional player and will do everything in his skill set to win

I dont know wat you are arguing at this point. Ive clearly showed my stance and backed it up with numbers.

He is a better passer and had superior passing numbers in his best season. He was also an all pro when Brady, Brees, and Rodgers were still around. Dak cant beat out Lamar Jackson or Brock Purdy for an all pro nomination.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Now yall wanna include rushing. If thats the case, Hurts > Dak

sorry this is a QBs discussion not RBs. there is a different thread on comparing RBs

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Many call it a neanderthal game right now.

That said Romo running in a preseason game that means absolutely nothing after having back surgery definitely qualifies him for the short bus

You’ve got a point there.

 

[Jarntt]

Just saw this stat and didn't want to start a new thread so seemed to fit here

 

[Coogiguy03]

A friend of mine asked me my thoughts on this subject. I asked a few friends and was a bit surprised by their reaponses. So I figured I’d ask the board. Who is the better QB?

Thoughts, what are thoughts????

 

[BoysForLife]

Just saw this stat and didn't want to start a new thread so seemed to fit here

Russ Wilson?

Say it ain't so!

I was eviscerated in another thread for suggesting Wilson at half Daks price might be a winning proposition for this team

 

[Motorola]

The new Romo after his surgery seemed to be quite good. Unfortunately he was not given a chance even though he proved his worth smoking the Eagles in that last game only to have Dak come back on to lose the game.

If you're referring to the 2016 season finale___Mark Sanchez replaced Romo at quarterback after the Cowboys went ahead; he was the QB the rest of the way.
Prescott never returned to game after Romo replaced him in the first half.

 

[RJ_MacReady]

Dak

 

[rynochop]

If there's 2 minutes, no timeouts and you need a td. Romo, no doubt.

I also think Romo in his prime avoids a lot of the sacks Dak has taken this year

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Russ Wilson?

Say it ain't so!

I was eviscerated in another thread for suggesting Wilson at half Daks price might be a winning proposition for this team

Lol What makes you think such a thing?

 

[Blackrain]

I dont know wat you are arguing at this point. Ive clearly showed my stance and backed it up with numbers.

He is a better passer and had superior passing numbers in his best season. He was also an all pro when Brady, Brees, and Rodgers were still around. Dak cant beat out Lamar Jackson or Brock Purdy for an all pro nomination.

First off we don't know what Daks best season will be because his career is not over yet.

Here's what we do know his completion percentage for his career so far is better than romos and his interception percentage so far is better than romos .

So Romo is not statistically a better passer

 

[BoysForLife]

Lol What makes you think such a thing?

Think what?