Dak or Romo?

[TheMarathonContinues]

lmao...the hell you can't! You can lose a game over a missed field goal. smh

Missed field goal is completely different than a dropped pass.

 

[calicowboy54]

A friend of mine asked me my thoughts on this subject. I asked a few friends and was a bit surprised by their reaponses. So I figured I’d ask the board. Who is the better QB?

Romo with MM and this roster would be amazing and in the superbowl.

 

[KMY_Amber]

Both

...because I remember Quincy Carter (bless his heart, he tried), Anthony Wright, Ryan Leaf, Clint Stoerner, Chad Hutchinson, Vinny Testaverde, Drew Hinson, and Drew Bledsoe.

 

[NeathBlue]

He had two incarnations of great offensive lines. IN 2007 he had Leonard Davis, Flozell, Adams, Andre Gurode, etc......and by 2014 he had Zack Martin, Tyron, etc. This narrative he never had a good OL is CRAP.

I never said he NEVER had a good OL…
But by the time he did have one, he’d already taken a battering.
The 2007 line was nowhere near as good as what he had towards the end of his career, it was no more than average… check out the amount of running for his life he had to do.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Has anybody seen @TheMarathonContinues blame dak for the two losses against SF in the playoffs?

If not, disregard his opinion

I'm one of the most truthful posters on this site. You don't have to ask anyone you can ask me. I've blamed Dak for every lost in the playoff he's had. Unlike y'all with Romo. Romo throws a pick y'all say "Oh he stepped on someones foot". Y'all come up with an excuse for every loss he has. I will tell you straight up a big reason we lost last year was because of Dak.

This is what y'all don't understand. You can talk about Romo or Dak needing this talent or not having this talent. At the end of the day you won't win in the playoffs unless your quarterback steps up. You can't get away with a pedestrian game from your quarterback. You can't hide your quarterback. Romo never played above his head in the playoffs and that's why he sits here with no rings and not many big game wins. In order for the Cowboys to win a SB this year Dak is going to have to play at a top level against the 49ers. There's no way around it no matter how good or bad the defense plays it will come down to Dak.

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

Dak probably has better talent and coaching, but Romo had injury problems. Availability is the best ability

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

I never said he NEVER had a good OL…
But by the time he did have one, he’d already taken a battering.
The 2007 line was nowhere near as good as what he had towards the end of his career, it was no more than average… check out the amount of running for his life he had to do.

How is your line average when Flozell, Gurode and Leonard Davis were Pro Bowlers lol? Man I'd kill for those guys on this line lol.

 

[DallasEast]

 

[WillieBeamen]

I'm one of the most truthful posters on this site. You don't have to ask anyone you can ask me. I've blamed Dak for every lost in the playoff he's had. Unlike y'all with Romo. Romo throws a pick y'all say "Oh he stepped on someones foot". Y'all come up with an excuse for every loss he has. I will tell you straight up a big reason we lost last year was because of Dak.

This is what y'all don't understand. You can talk about Romo or Dak needing this talent or not having this talent. At the end of the day you won't win in the playoffs unless your quarterback steps up. You can't get away with a pedestrian game from your quarterback. You can't hide your quarterback. Romo never played above his head in the playoffs and that's why he sits here with no rings and not many big game wins. In order for the Cowboys to win a SB this year Dak is going to have to play at a top level against the 49ers. There's no way around it no matter how good or bad the defense plays it will come down to Dak.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Dak probably has better talent and coaching, but Romo had injury problems. Availability is the best ability

It's funny Dak gets credit for having good coaching. Everyone in the country thinks McCarthy sucks but we give Dak credit for having it.

 

[zrinkill]

Tony Romo was a very Good QB ......... He became Great his last two years and had finally figured out how to play the position. Unfortunately his body was in such bad shape by that time that he could not even play golf without writhing on the ground with back spasms.

Dak is just as good as Romo was in most of his career ....... hopefully he reaches the same enlightenment that Romo had in his final two years before his body gives out.

Young Romo was a better passer, young Dak had better intangibles and patience.

That is my honest answer to this silly beaten up dead horse topic.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

SO you ask me a question and I guess you get proven wrong and now you just send laughing emojis. I mean it's predictable I'll say that lol.

 

[ElGatoGrande]

Thats cool.

Give me the QB that plus just as good on the road as he does at home and can figure out how to read a zone defense

Both QBs have strengths and weaknesses but Romo is the better QB by virtue of his ability to read and beat the coverages,,, no deer in the headlights moments! Mentally and emotionally he's got the edge. If Dak can ever get past that then he wins, he's already got the edge physically and charismatically.

 

[Cowboy4ever]

Dak. Dak is a better football player and leader than Romo ever was.

Where Romo failed is he wasn't a good leader. He cared more about golf than he did the NFL. Dak's #1 priority is football. It's why Dak was able to lead this team in 2016....soon as he stepped on that field these guys gravitated to him and it's why they never went back to Romo and why he essentially retired Romo.

If Romo couldn't win in 2014 he was never gonna win with this organization.

I am not getting into the who is better nonsense. But I wanted to say that in 2014, Romo played about as well as any QB has ever played and in the Divisional round game, he was pretty flawless. It was a fumble by 29 and a catch, no catch and a leaky D that cost the Team the chance to go to the NFCGC. If Dak plays as well this year in the Playoffs as Romo did in 2014, we will be very tough out for any team we face and could very likely win the SB. We have all seen Dak play lights out, especially this year, But it is gut check time, will Dak keep it going? If he does, watch out NFL.

 

[America's Cowboy]

Answer my question, or shut up, one or the other.

What's your question, baby cakes? lol

 

[WillieBeamen]

SO you ask me a question and I guess you get proven wrong and now you just send laughing emojis. I mean it's predictable I'll say that lol.

Because youre lying. If someone credible comes in and cosigns you blaming Dak for the losses, ill admit i was wrong

 

[DallasEast]

Any Prescott and/or Romo thread.

 

[Buffalocowboy]

ROMO

 

[WoodysGirl]

Both....

 

[KJJ]

Romo w this team is sitting 14-2 right now

With this team and OL and lack of a running game, Romo would have never made it to November before being out for the season with an injury.