Dak or Romo?

[gimmesix]

All Dak has to do is win one playoff game to have more playoff wins and appearances than Romo, and if he makes it the Championship game, which looks like a real possibility if we keep the 2nd seed, then I don't see how anyone can say Romo was better. Y'all seriously overrate Romo. As of right now, I think they're pretty much the same QB but Dak has time to pass him

I think they will be pretty much the same quarterback throughout their careers, having bad years, good years and even great years depending on the team around them, the coaches, etc. Quarterbacks don't quarterback in a vacuum.

Both have played good enough at times in their careers for the team to win Super Bowls, but the team/coaching wasn't good enough. Maybe this year that will be different.

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

It's funny Dak gets credit for having good coaching. Everyone in the country thinks McCarthy sucks but we give Dak credit for having it.

It’s relative. You can criticize McCarthy but still acknowledge he’s a substantially better HC than Wade

 

[5Stars]

SO you ask me a question and I guess you get proven wrong and now you just send laughing emojis. I mean it's predictable I'll say that lol.

I think he is laughing at the "I'm one of the most truthful posters on this site". lmao also.

 

[stilltheguru]

Dak has 4 years with Mccarthy. Romo had 4 years with Parcells. Rest with garrett for both with a little Wade sprinkled in. Maybe if Romo listened to Parcells he would've had a better career. Instead soon as Bill leaves the beta started chasing celebrity women

Dak probably has better talent and coaching, but Romo had injury problems. Availability is the best ability

 

[gimmesix]

With this team and OL, Romo would have never made it to November before being out for the season with an injury.

Depends on the year. You are correct if we're talking about 2015-2016 Romo. He was broken by then. Before that he started at least 15 games in six of eight seasons (and 13 in one of the other two). If we're talking about present-day Romo, I'm not sure he'd survive practice.

 

[DallasEast]

 

[5Stars]

What's your question, baby cakes? lol

Romo

 

[DallasEast]

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Because youre lying. If someone credible comes in and cosigns you blaming Dak for the losses, ill admit i was wrong

I've said it all year that Dak was why we lost to the 49ers last year why would I lie about that now? So you accuse me of being a liar but you have nothing to prove I'm lying? Despite me admitting yet again they lost because of his play in that game? That's when you'll admit you're wrong? It's cool lol. Stand on what you believe.

 

[WillieBeamen]

I've said it all year that Dak was why we lost to the 49ers last year why would I lie about that now? So you accuse me of being a liar but you have nothing to prove I'm lying? Despite me admitting yet again they lost because of his play in that game? That's when you'll admit you're wrong? It's cool lol. Stand on what you believe.

Show me those posts

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

I am not getting into the who is better nonsense. But I wanted to say that in 2014, Romo played about as well as any QB has ever played and in the Divisional round game, he was pretty flawless. It was a fumble by 29 and a catch, no catch and a leaky D that cost the Team the chance to go to the NFCGC. If Dak plays as well this year in the Playoffs as Romo did in 2014, we will be very tough out for any team we face and could very likely win the SB. We have all seen Dak play lights out, especially this year, But it is gut check time, will Dak keep it going? If he does, watch out NFL.

Like I told the other poster there's always an excuse for why we lost. Romo didn't play good enough in 2014. That' just what it is.

 

[DallasEast]

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Show me those posts

Go find them. Why do I have to prove to you what I said? You called me a liar so prove I'm a liar. You have the same access to this forum as I do right?

 

[gimmesix]

It’s relative. You can criticize McCarthy but still acknowledge he’s a substantially better HC than Wade

I always find it funny that McCarthy doesn't get treated like a Super Bowl coach because there's the caveat that he had Aaron Rodgers at quarterback. If we go by that logic, Jimmy Johnson should not be given credit for Dallas' Super Bowls because he had Troy Aikman at quarterback. Same with Tom Landry ... didn't win a single Super Bowl without Roger Staubach at quarterback.

 

[WillieBeamen]

Go find them. Why do I have to prove to you what I said? You called me a liar so prove I'm a liar. You have the same access to this forum as I do right?

Exactly. Im going to continue to laugh at you, call you a liar, and disregard your opinion on this.

 

[5Stars]

Go find them. Why do I have to prove to you what I said? You called me a liar so prove I'm a liar. You have the same access to this forum as I do right?

Oh, hell no! That is not how it works. You said you blame Dak for losing, you said it, so you need to prove it...deflection is just lazy on your part.

 

[DallasEast]

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

It’s relative. You can criticize McCarthy but still acknowledge he’s a substantially better HC than Wade

Both are a SB champions.....and Wade surely isn't one because of Aaron Rodgers level talent on offense. These arguments just change depending on what the stance is. IF its to discredit to Dak then McCarthy is Bill Bellicheck. If its to discredit the Cowboys then McCarthy sucks and had time management issues.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Oh, hell no! That is not how it works. You said you blame Dak for losing, you said it, so you need to prove it...deflection is just lazy on your part.

I don't have to do anything. You accuse me of being a liar then prove it?

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

I always find it funny that McCarthy doesn't get treated like a Super Bowl coach because there's the caveat that he had Aaron Rodgers at quarterback. If we go by that logic, Jimmy Johnson should not be given credit for Dallas' Super Bowls because he had Troy Aikman at quarterback. Same with Tom Landry ... didn't win (or reach) a single Super Bowl without Roger Staubach at quarterback.

I wouldn’t criticize McCarthy for that; You need good players to be good. It’s what’s happened since I think where the majority of the question marks start popping up