Dak Prescott has had the 3rd worst postseason defense over the last quarter century

BoysForLife · 2025-01-13T18:37:15-0600

atlantacowboy said:
Well, it's not he's losing 35-31. The defense is getting its butt kicked and so is he.

Against GB, this statement has merit. Whole team stunk.

The previous 2 games against SF? Defense played solid. The offense was the Achilles heel in those losses

BoysForLife · 2025-01-13T18:37:58-0600

cowboys5xsbs said:
How did that defense do in the playoffs

No worse than the offense did

BoysForLife · 2025-01-13T18:38:40-0600

Playmaker3128 said:
Maybe not last year with GB but both 49er playoff games the defense gave up I think 23 and like 17 points. And if I remember 7-10 of those points were directly related to dak interceptions.

100% correct. Case closed

DickWhitman · 2025-01-13T18:40:16-0600

cowboys5xsbs said:
Imagine having a real defense and not whatever we trot out there every playoffs

Dak apologists are hilarious. Fact.

TheSport78 · 2025-01-13T18:44:04-0600

You can strawman and cherry pick all you want. I use the eye test. Smart and logical fans know what he is.

America's Cowboy · 2025-01-13T20:44:05-0600

5Stars said:
Hey, look everyone, the broken record strikes again. How embarrassing!

Look in the mirror. Epitome of embarrassing.

Gangsta Spanksta · 2025-01-13T21:04:02-0600

cowboys5xsbs said:
Imagine having a real defense and not whatever we trot out there every playoffs

Do you make excuses for yourself like that in life, or just for Dak?

cowboys5xsbs · 2025-01-13T21:16:30-0600

Gangsta Spanksta said:
Do you make excuses for yourself like that in life, or just for Dak?

Generally in life I don't blame one person for the failure of the team. Usually that isn't very productive.

Playmaker3128 · 2025-01-13T21:28:34-0600

2023 playoff game against SF they had no receiver over 100 yards, CMC and Elijah Mitchell 3.5 yards per carry. Defense gave up 19 points.

2022 playoffs, Kittle, Samuel, Ayuk, 9 catches combined. Jimmy G no tds and 1 pick. Our achilles heel that game was debo killed us in the run game. Gave up 23 points, and I believe 7-10 of those were direct result of dak turnovers.

I know last year was bad, but gimme a break this defense gave up average 20 ppg to a good 49ers team 2 years in a row. Should have been good enough to win

Cowboys5217 · 2025-01-14T07:15:49-0600

Playmaker3128 said:
2023 playoff game against SF they had no receiver over 100 yards, CMC and Elijah Mitchell 3.5 yards per carry. Defense gave up 19 points.

2022 playoffs, Kittle, Samuel, Ayuk, 9 catches combined. Jimmy G no tds and 1 pick. Our achilles heel that game was debo killed us in the run game. Gave up 23 points, and I believe 7-10 of those were direct result of dak turnovers.

I know last year was bad, but gimme a break this defense gave up average 20 ppg to a good 49ers team 2 years in a row. Should have been good enough to win

Yep. Mahomes as our QB and we win both 49ers games handily. By probably 10+ point margins.

starfan1 · 2025-01-14T07:41:15-0600

Dak Prescott has been part of the post season issues. Some seasons more than others but he isn't THE problem. The defense has been an issue as well. Coaching hasn't been stellar and at times our run game and WR core questionable. Swapping him out with another QB and still not have a complete team doesn't fix anything but the thirst for change. I wouldn't care if Dak retired tomorrow we are still a middling organization because we have won alot of games despite our GM. The problem is Jones and it always has been.

any other narrative is just trolling or lack of football understanding.

Cowboys5217 · 2025-01-14T07:43:01-0600

starfan1 said:
Dak Prescott has been part of the post season issues. Some seasons more than others but he isn't THE problem. The defense has been an issue as well. Coaching hasn't been stellar and at times our run game and WR core questionable. Swapping him out with another QB and still not have a complete team doesn't fix anything but the thirst for change. I wouldn't care if Dak retired tomorrow we are still a middling organization because we have won alot of games despite our GM. The problem is Jones and it always has been.

any other narrative is just trolling or lack of football understanding.

When you can't get over the hump in the playoffs, and this is a repeated issue, then you have a QB who isn't good enough. That's how it's always been. Neither Romo or Dak were/are good enough.

stilltheguru · 2025-01-14T08:12:34-0600

Cowboys5217 said:
Yep. Mahomes as our QB and we win both 49ers games handily. By probably 10+ point margins.

So if we had an elite qb we'd win? DUH. Do we have an elite qb? :facepalm:

Johannes44 · 2025-01-14T08:20:42-0600

Cowboys5217 said:
When you can't get over the hump in the playoffs, and this is a repeated issue, then you have a QB who isn't good enough. That's how it's always been. Neither Romo or Dak were/are good enough.

The issue is both the offense as a defense. We have an offense that simply disappears through large swaths of a game. You see this even in the regular season. Never gets addressed because they beat up the weaker teams on their schedule and keep claiming that they are the #1 offense in the league or some other useless stat that does not tell you the whole picture. The same applies to the defense - the year they got crushed by GB their offense was ranked #1 in the league and defense was ranked #5 - does anyone really think that ranking was accurate after seeing the performance of both sides of the football in that game? C'mon be real - the offense was a no-show in the entire first half of the game and the defense was as useless as drinking Mountain Dew for birth control.

Proof · 2025-01-14T08:46:44-0600

DizzyT said:
Our defense was perfectly fine when we lost to the 49ers 19-12 two years ago.

minus the ole' defense on the kittle circus catch, and dropped surefire int. yes.

Proof · 2025-01-14T08:49:22-0600

TheSport78 said:
Go ahead and cherry pick any stat you want with your straw man argument.

whats cherry picked, and how is presenting facts and data is a straw man argument?

gtb1943 · 2025-01-14T08:50:31-0600

Cowboys5217 said:
When you can't get over the hump in the playoffs, and this is a repeated issue, then you have a QB who isn't good enough. That's how it's always been. Neither Romo or Dak were/are good enough.

love how the QB is always to blame for the culture of a team that always craps the bed in the playoffs

Johannes44 · 2025-01-14T08:51:08-0600

Proof said:
minus the ole' defense on the kittle circus catch, and dropped surefire int. yes.

Yes, that one play was going to change everything. Meanwhile the offense could muster up just 12 points. But yea, that one play is what made the difference through 4 quarters of football.

gtb1943 · 2025-01-14T08:51:43-0600

Proof said:
minus the ole' defense on the kittle circus catch, and dropped surefire int. yes.

so basically your attitude is this:
"Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?"

Proof · 2025-01-14T08:52:05-0600

Johannes44 said:
Yes, that one play was going to change everything. Meanwhile the offense could muster up just 12 points. But yea, that one play is what made the difference through 4 quarters of football.

those are two plays. and yes, one absolutely, unequivocally changed everything. the other could have.

Dak Prescott has had the 3rd worst postseason defense over the last quarter century

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

The Excellence of Execution

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member